You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘Return to Homs’

An essential, ground-level look at the Syrian civil war, embedded among "the men of Zeer street" and their charismatic champ, Abdul Basset Saroot.

Abdul Basset Saroot, Ossama al Homsi. Narrator: Talal Derki. (Arabic dialogue)

How differently people might remember the Alamo had there been a camera crew there to observe it. Talal Derki’s “Return to Homs” represents a remarkable achievement in immersive conflict-zone filmmaking, fearlessly taking auds to the front lines of the Syrian civil war and embedding them alongside soccer star turned resistance leader Abdul Basset Saroot, a charismatic nonviolent protestor pushed into taking up arms against the oppressive regime. What the film lacks in context it gains in visceral eyewitness value, its countless tragedies serving as a potential rallying cry to supporters wherever this Sundance World Cinema docu winner unspools abroad.

When the film opens, Homs could pass for a thriving Syrian city, though tanks in the streets and soldiers on rooftops reflect the mounting tension between the locals and the country’s leader, president Bashar al-Assad, “elected” (the 2000 ballot offered no alternatives) after the death of his father, who had controlled the country for three decades before him. By the end, Homs will be a shelled-out ghost town, these once-healthy neighborhoods populated only by troops and an underground resistance movement.

Of all the countries stirred toward freedom by the Arab Spring, Syria had perhaps the most tangled situation. In 2011, civil war broke out after the national army met peaceful, youth-driven demonstrations with a show of force. Derki and his team were present to witness these early protests in Homs — the center of the uprising — observing a small faction of freedom fighters, “the men of Zeer street,” for the next two years as the situation escalated. Despite voiceover narration from the director, “Return to Homs” seldom actually explains what it depicts. Instead, in true verite style, the scenes must speak for themselves, even though it may take multiple viewings to make sense of the film’s many intricacies.

The early scenes are the easiest to follow, as a handsome local celebrity, 19-year-old goalkeeper Saroot, galvanizes a crowd by singing in a local square. Young and optimistic, he seems convinced that change is possible without violence, but Assad’s harsh reaction to this movement proves otherwise: The army cracks down, claiming the lives of innocents and children in the process, while detaining suspected dissidents — including activist cameraman Ossama al Homsi, whom Derki had hoped to feature as one of the docu’s main characters, until his disappearance.

Such unforeseen twists reiterate the tangible tragedy of making a real-world war movie, as opposed to one where the casualties are scripted for poetic effect. Here, no one is safe, and we fear for Saroot’s safety, especially as his remaining friends and relatives fall, making the young man increasingly obsessed with martyrdom. Thankfully, fatalities typically don’t occur on camera, although the bloody aftermath becomes a frequent focus. This consequences-centric approach underscores the demoralizing senselessness of the violence and the futility of such a mismatched insurgence, where the rebels’ only hope is that the outside world will intervene on their behalf.

Logistically, making such a film is no less complicated — or dangerous — than the revolution itself, and “Return to Homs” may ultimately prove more effective in attracting the support the movement requires. With digital cameras smuggled into the siege zone the same way arms are, and semi-exposed operators (including producer Orwa Nyrabia) shooting footage at great personal risk, the project ensures that the personal sacrifice of those fighting for a true democracy is documented and broadcast abroad.

Though the footage consists of jittery, often disconnected fragments, many of these images leave a haunting impression: a child’s doll abandoned in a pile of rubble, a tank exploding in a plume of smoke, a dead boy felled by a sniper’s bullet. Even amid so much violence, the most frequent sight is that of Saroot singing, his hopeful chants serving as the unofficial soundtrack to the film — and an anthem to the city of Homs in general. (Docu’s sound work is something of a marvel under the circumstances.) Saroot’s homemade videos already spread the revolutionary cause via YouTube, while this essential, unsparing documentary (also available in a TV-ready, 53-minute cut) gives their struggle a powerful international boost.

Film Review: 'Return to Homs'

Reviewed at Intl. Documentary Film Festival Amsterdam (opener), Nov. 26, 2013. (Also in Sundance Film Festival — New Directors/New Films.) Running time: 90 MIN.

Production: (Documentary — Syria-Germany) A Journeyman release of a Proaction Film, Ventana Films production, in co-production with SWR, SVT, NHK, in association with Arte, TSR, Radio Canada, with the support of AFAC, IDFA Bertha Fund, IMS, Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affaires, Goethe Institute, Zero Prods. Produced by Orwa Nyrabia, Hans Robert Eisenhauer.

Crew: Directed, written by Talal Derki. Camera (color, HD), Kahtan Hassoun, Ossama al Homsi, Derki, Orwa Nyrabia; editor, Anne Fabini; sound/sound designer, Sebastian Tesch, Ansgar Frerich; line producers, Bilal Mohammad, Mahmoud Al Fahed; associate producer, Diana El Jeiroudi.

With: Abdul Basset Saroot, Ossama al Homsi. Narrator: Talal Derki. (Arabic dialogue)

More Film

  • France’s Bertrand Blier Reflects On Oscars,

    Bertrand Blier: Love Is The Most Boring Subject Of All

    PARIS —  In his first feature since 2010’s “The Clink of Ice,” filmmaker Bertrand Blier returns with a somber, existentialist farce reminiscent of the last century’s most celebrated absurdist theater. Vladimir and Estragon, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, meet Taupin and Foster (Gérard Depardieu and Christian Clavier). One is homeless, the other well off, though that dynamic [...]

  • Marvel Man Defied Naysayers to Build

    How Kevin Feige Defied Naysayers to Build a Lucrative Universe

    Given its impact on Hollywood moviemaking, it’s hard to believe that the first movie in the Marvel Cinematic Universe debuted just over a decade ago, reviving “Iron Man” star Robert Downey Jr.’s career in the process. But Marvel Studios president Kevin Feige, who will receive the PGA’s David O. Selznick award for his industry-changing body [...]

  • Gaumont Reteams with Quad on Mohamed

    Gaumont Reteams with Quad on Mohamed Hamidi's 'Queens of The Field' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Gaumont is reteaming with “The Intouchables” and “C’est La Vie” production banner Quad on Mohamed Hamidi (“One Man and His Cow”)’s concept company “Queens of The Field.” The movie is set in a small rural town which is on the verge of losing its funding along with its field. The threat leads the town women [...]

  • Toby Emmerich

    Toby Emmerich Recalls Rachel Adams' Chemistry Read With Ryan Gosling

    In the span of one year, Toby Emmerich ascended to the chairman role at Warner Bros. Picture Group, shepherded the studio’s record-breaking slate at the worldwide box office, and was selected as the latest recipient of the PGA’s Milestone Award, a kudo that has previously gone to execs including Donna Langley and Robert Iger. Among [...]

  • Editorial use only. No book cover

    The Story of 'A Star Is Born' Before Bradley Cooper's Version

    “A Star Is Born” has always been a great talent vehicle, including the new Bradley Cooper-Lady Gaga version, which Warner Bros. opened Oct. 5. Previous versions showcased big-name talent, but there’s also a stellar lineup of people who almost made the film but didn’t, including Cary Grant, Cher, Elvis Presley, Whitney Houston, Denzel Washington, Tom [...]

  • PGA Presidents Gail Berman and Lucy

    PGA Presidents Gail Berman and Lucy Fisher on the Need for More Change

    Midway through their first year as co-presidents of the Producers Guild, Gail Berman and Lucy Fisher are pleased with their guild’s progress tackling some of the industry’s thorniest issues — sexual harassment and inequality among them — but fully aware how much more work needs to be done. Luckily, as producers and former studio bosses, [...]

  • Sandy Climan

    Writing Platform Open Screenplay Launches With Backing From Sandy Climan

    With backing from longtime Hollywood player Sandy Climan, Khaled Sabawi has quietly launched Open Screenplay as a free online platform for aspiring screenwriters. Open Screenplay is aimed at helping writers create better stories through its story-writing process and tools. It has launched a contest with a $2,000 prize and has more than 100 screenplays in various [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content