You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘Atlas Shrugged: Who Is John Galt?’

The weak cinematic trilogy derived from Ayn Rand's 1957 screed-cum-novel limps to its merciful end.

Kristoffer Polaha, Laura Regan, Joaquim de Almeida, Rob Morrow, Eric Allen Kramer, Stephen Toblowski, Mark Moses, Lew Temple, Jen Nikolaisen, Dominic Daniel, Greg Germann, Peter MacKenzie, Neal McDonough, Louis Herthum, Tony Denison, Claude Knowlton, Ned Vaugh, Grover Norquist, Sean Hannity, Glenn Beck, Ron Paul.

The spirit is willing but the filmmaking is oh so weak in “Atlas Shrugged: Who Is John Galt?,” the last installment of a cinematic trilogy based on Ayn Rand’s 1957 screed in epic novel form. Pic represents a certain leap of faith, as 2011’s “Part I” bombed in expansion after a promising limited opening, while 2012’s “Part II: The Strike” flopped outright. This finale to the free-market goddess’ pulpy ultimate tract answers not only the titular question, but also the matter of “What box set to get my favorite libertarian this Christmas?” (S)he probably won’t have seen this chapter already, as the shoddy pic took a B.O. swan dive in its opening U.S. weekend, grossing a reported $355,000 on 242 screens.

That must be the fault of those damn freedom-hating socialists, or perhaps it’s due to the fact that so few of the Tea Party types the series’ producers once hoped would queue up are, er, the literate sort. Or maybe it’s just that the prior installments weren’t very good movies, and it should surprise few that this last one is the worst of the lot. You can’t really blame the filmmakers: Stuck with a budget that again halves its immediate predecessor’s (now down to $5 million), they’re hapless to convey the grand scale of events Rand intended.

Also, cast and crew have been almost entirely overhauled yet again. Now it’s Laura Regan playing railroad heiress Dagny Taggart, last seen crashing her plane in pursuit of the mysterious John Galt (Kristoffer Polaha), whose name has become a byword for truly free enterprise in a “People’s State of America” turned corrupt, collectivist, self-destructive and dysfunctional under the thumb of government toadies like Head of State Thompson (Peter MacKenzie). Turns out engineering genius Galt opted out of a society that now disgusts him, luring other titans of industry and innovation to his secret, self-sufficient Atlantis community in the mountains.

Having barely survived her landing there, Dagny is duly impressed by this group of rugged rich individualists who, feeling unappreciated, took their toys and talents out of circulation. (They’ve also helped the outside world’s infrastructural collapse along by sabotaging their old businesses.) They say tsk-tsking things like “You’ve been told people have a right to a living, just because they’re human.” Perish the thought.

Though she’s found her utopia — and her sexy capitalist superman — Dagny returns to the outer world, unwilling to see her family’s hard-built business flushed down the toilet by government “takers.” The latter, facing various crises and rising citizen unrest, are furious when John commandeers the airwaves to deliver a big speech of vague libertarian philosophy. (Well, bigness is relative, as what took Rand nearly 60 pages is here reduced to under four minutes.) Shadowing Dagny, he’s captured by the evildoers, then tortured and rescued in a ridiculous action climax.

Helmer J. James Manera sports the thinnest resume among the trilogy’s directors, but it would have been hard for anyone to pull this enterprise off. Crowd scenes that should be vast boast a cast of dozens. Stock footage, still photos and an omnipresent narrator awkwardly patch large gaps where the grandiose story goes beyond this movie’s ability to realize. Though under the circumstances tech contributions are OK, “Who Is John Galt?” has the feel of a low-grade TV soap opera, with acting to match. (The biggest name here, Rob Morrow in the hitherto major role of steel baron Hank Rearden, makes just an eyeblink appearance.) Rand would have been embarrassed by its tacky reductionism, even if the literary “Atlas” is pretty sudsy itself.

Then there’s the problem all three movies suffered from, namely their choosing to avoid a costly period setting, but failing to compensate by adequately updating a narrative very much rooted in the American economical logistics of more than a half-century ago. A more abstract, even sci-fi approach might have made the story still work as parable. But the dully literal-minded execution that producers John Aglialoro and Harmony Kaslow have carried through each installment only makes Rand’s creaky plotting seem more archaic and illogical. “Atlas Shrugged” may be a terrible novel, but its still-controversial philosophies will always attract avid followers. (Prominent conservative pundit types including Grover Norquist and Sean Hannity duly make cameo appearances as themselves here to further the cause.) It’s hard to imagine anyone, however, having a “Eureka!” experience watching these lame movies, this latest least of all.

Though publicized without the numeral, the pic’s onscreen title is “Atlas Shrugged III: Who Is John Galt?”

Popular on Variety

Film Review: 'Atlas Shrugged: Who Is John Galt?'

Reviewed at AMC Metreon 16, San Francisco, Sept. 15, 2014. MPAA Rating: PG-13. Running time: 99 MIN.

Production: An Atlas Distribution Co. release of an Atlas Prods. production. Produced by John Aglialoro, Harmony Kaslow. Executive producers, William A. Dunn, Ronald G. Smith. Co-producer, Bernie Laramie.

Crew: Directed by J. James Manera. Screenplay, Manera, Harmony Kaslow, John Aglialoro, based on the novel by Ayn Rand. Camera (color, HD), Gale Tattersall; editor, Tony Ciccone; music, Ella Cmiral; production designer, Jack G. Taylor; costume designer, Eric Edell Phillips; set decorator, Donald W. Krafft; sound mixer, David M. Kelson; re-recording mixer, Michael Perricone; supervising sound editor/sound designer, James Gallivan; assistant directors, Andrew M. Ward, Daniel Katzman; casting, Lisa Beach, Sarah Katzman.

With: Kristoffer Polaha, Laura Regan, Joaquim de Almeida, Rob Morrow, Eric Allen Kramer, Stephen Toblowski, Mark Moses, Lew Temple, Jen Nikolaisen, Dominic Daniel, Greg Germann, Peter MacKenzie, Neal McDonough, Louis Herthum, Tony Denison, Claude Knowlton, Ned Vaugh, Grover Norquist, Sean Hannity, Glenn Beck, Ron Paul.

More Film

  • Nicolas Cage Hainan International Film Festival

    China's Hainan Film Festival Launches Golden Coconut Competition

    The deep-pocketed, government-run Hainan Island International Film Festival has launched a new competition section for its second iteration, set to take place from December 1-8. This year, ten ‘Golden Coconut Awards’ will be given out across three categories of films: feature-length, feature documentaries, and fictional shorts. Prizes will be presented for best picture, best director, [...]

  • Panda

    France's Troisième Œil Teams With China's CICC on Richard Dale's 'Panda Kingdom' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Troisième Œil Productions is teaming with Chinese partners to make its first international co-production with the premium documentary “Panda Kingdom,” and has brought BAFTA-winning director Richard Dale on board to helm it. The outfits China Aviation Pictures and CICC are co-producing the documentary with Troisième Œil Productions. The docu feature will explore the captive breeding [...]

  • Andhadhun receives AACTA nomination

    Indian and Chinese Titles Dominate AACTA Asian Award Nominations

    Three Indian and three mainland Chinese films are among the nine feature movies shortlisted for the Best Asian Film Award by the Australian Academy of Cinema and Television Arts. The Indian selections are box office hit “Andhadhun,” “Super Deluxe, and “Gully Boy,” which premiered in February at the Berlin festival. The Chinese trio includes “Shadow,” [...]

  • Fernando Meirelles The Two Popes

    Film News Roundup: 'The Two Popes' Wins Audience Award at Miami Festival

    In today’s film news roundup, “The Two Popes” wins an audience award, “A Night with Janis Joplin” and “Fittest in Dubai” get releases, Artists First reorganizes, SAG-AFTRA expands its headquarters and Film Fest 919 announces its winners. AUDIENCE AWARD Fernando Meirelles’ “The Two Popes” has won the audience award at the Miami Gems Film Festival. [...]

  • Scotty Bowers

    Scotty Bowers, Old Hollywood's Sexual Matchmaker, Dies at 96

    Scotty Bowers, a “sexual matchmaker” for dozens of stars during the Golden Age of Hollywood who wrote about his colorful — and sometimes unbelivable — life in his memoir “Full Service: My Adventures in Hollywood and the Secret Sex Lives of the Stars,” died at his Laurel Canyon home on Sunday. He was 96. The [...]

  • AMC theater

    AMC Entertainment Introducing On-Demand Movie Service

    AMC Entertainment will introduce an online video store in the United States on Tuesday. Adam Aron, AMC’s president and chief executive, said that the AMC Theaters On Demand will offer about 2,000 films for sale or rent after their theatrical runs — much like Amazon or iTunes. Disney, Warner Bros., Universal, Sony and Paramount have [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content