Film Review: ‘All Relative’

A misguided indie romantic comedy to watch with someone you hate.

Connie Nielsen, Jonathan Sadowski, Sara Paxton, David Aaron Baker, Al Thompson, Erin Wilhelmi, Liz Fye, Sarah Steele, Audrey Jessup.

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3214248/

Sleeping with your girlfriend’s mother is only a minor obstacle to true love in “All Relative.” Kinda-sorta reworking the bizarre love triangle at the center of Mike Nichols’ “The Graduate,” writer-director J.C. Khoury’s second feature clearly intends to treat all its characters with respect and understanding but somehow winds up making them look like complete idiots instead. Day-and-date theatrical and VOD release has very little going for it on any platform.

Bland New York grad student Harry (Jonathan Sadowski) is still nursing a broken heart after his fiancee cheated on him and ended their engagement. His luck improves when he meets bubbly blonde Grace (Sara Paxton) at a bowling alley, only to discover she’s currently attached to a middling prospect she met online. Looking to drown his sorrows, Harry runs into seductive fortysomething Maren (Connie Nielsen) at a bar and almost immediately winds up in her bed. At Maren’s urging, Harry pursues Grace, which leaves Maren the odd woman out when Grace gives in to Harry’s advances.

Up until this point, Khoury has avoided dropping the bombshell that Maren is actually Grace’s mother, to the audience or the characters — though trying to keep the very premise of the film a secret does nothing to heighten its impact. It’s not until Grace brings Harry home to meet the parents a month into their relationship that Harry and Maren realize the connection (Grace still has no idea), and promptly freak out.

The snowballing absurdity of the lengths both Harry and Maren go to to keep their secret becomes simultaneously preposterous and infuriating, played for a not-so-deft balance of wacky misunderstandings and pseudo-profound emotional reveals. Among the former, Harry’s stereotypically loutish pal Jared (Al Thompson) thinks Harry can somehow parlay the situation into a threesome. Repping the latter, Maren’s husband, Phil (David Aaron Baker), may have also had an affair. A frank talk about their future is surely in order.

It’s impossible to conceive of a conventional happy ending in this scenario, but Khoury tries his hardest to imagine one. The resolution is made all the more difficult to swallow by the utter lack of characterization when it comes to Grace, who seems to exist solely to satisfy Harry’s fantasies of a good-hearted dream girl. Paxton isn’t able to provide requisite backbone for a confounding character, who — when one steps outside the film’s myopic romantic-comedy p.o.v. — is subjected to repeated emotional abuse by both her boyfriend and her mother in the service of painfully unfunny farce.

Among the ensemble, Nielsen at least intrigues as an unconventional choice for this type of role and film, but “All Relative” fails to capitalize on the casting, pigeonholing Maren as a generically stifled suburbanite. (Nielsen currently has a far superior showcase in a handful of recurring guest spots on CBS’ “The Good Wife.”) Even a brisk running time, barely topping 80 minutes, is too long to ask audiences to stay in the company of these characters and their terrible self-inflicted predicaments. Tech credits are average at best.

Popular on Variety

Film Review: 'All Relative'

Reviewed online, West Hollywood, Nov. 23, 2014. (In Woodstock, Austin film festivals.) Running time: 85 MIN.

Production: A FilmBuff release of a Shoot First Entertainment presentation. Produced by J.C. Khoury, Trevor Herrick. Executive producer, Lynn Kressel. Co-­producer, David Rogue.

Crew: Directed, written, edited by J.C. Khoury. Camera (color, HD), Andreas von Scheele; music, Didier Lean Rachou; songs, David Rogue, Kelley McRae; production designer, David Barber; art director, Chloe Reisen; sound, Matthew Kraus, Michael McMenomy; supervising sound editor/re-recording mixer, McMenomy; associate producer, Heather M. Kelly; assistant directors, Sean Francis Fornara, Michael Scully; second unit camera, Steven Schuermans; casting, Lindsay Chag.

With: Connie Nielsen, Jonathan Sadowski, Sara Paxton, David Aaron Baker, Al Thompson, Erin Wilhelmi, Liz Fye, Sarah Steele, Audrey Jessup.

More Film

  • So Long, My Son directed by

    Wang Xiaoshuai's 'So Long, My Son' Earns Six APSA Nominations

    Chinese drama, “So Long, My Son,” was nominated in six categories for this year’s Asia Pacific Screen Awards. The unprecedented haul makes it a clear favorite. The Wang Xiaoshuai-directed drama about separation, secrets, a lifetime of regret, and the consequences of China’s one child policy, had its premiere in February at the Berlin festival. There [...]

  • Alan Rickman

    Film News Roundup: 'Galaxy Quest' Documentary Set for Release

    In today’s film news roundup, rescue drama “Not Without Hope” is back in development, a “Galaxy Quest” documentary is set for release, “The Two Popes” wins another award, and Ella Joyce gets cast. PROJECT REVIVED U.K.-based financing-production outfit Goldfinch has bought feature film rights to Nick Schuyler’s “Not Without Hope” and signed “The Fog” director [...]

  • Ryan Reynolds John Krasinkski

    Ryan Reynolds, John Krasinski in Talks for 'Imaginary Friends' Movie

    Ryan Reynolds and John Krasinski are in talks to board the fantasy comedy “Imaginary Friends” at Paramount Studios. Paramount recently won the bidding for the property over Lionsgate and Sony. Krasinski will write, direct,  produce and star while Reynolds will co-star if the deals go through. The story centers on a man who can see [...]

  • Willem Dafoe attends the "Motherless Brooklyn"

    Willem Dafoe Joins Guillermo Del Toro's 'Nightmare Alley'

    Willem Dafoe has closed a deal to join Bradley Cooper, Cate Blanchett and Rooney Mara in Guillermo del Toro’s adaptation of “Nightmare Alley.” Collider had first reported that Dafoe was being considered for a role in the film, but sources now say the “Lighthouse” star has closed a deal to join the cast. The “At [...]

  • 'To the Ends of the Earth'

    Busan Film Review: 'To the Ends of the Earth'

    “To the Ends of the Earth,” the story of a young Japanese journalist’s experiences in Uzbekistan filming a report for a Japanese TV travel show, was originally commissioned to celebrate 25 years of cordial diplomatic relations between director Kiyoshi Kurosawa’s hyper-developed island homeland and the less affluent, landlocked Central Asian nation. As such we might [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content