You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Cannes Film Review: ‘The Blue Room’

Mathieu Amalric's adaptation of Georges Simenon's mystery novel honors the text, but misses the atmosphere.

Mathieu Amalric, Lea Drucker, Stephanie Cleau, Laurent Poitrenaux, Serge Bozon, Blutch, Mona Jaffart, Veronique Alain, Christophe Aubry.

Not a chamber piece in the most literal sense, but with all the poky airlessness that its title implies, “The Blue Room” represents a disappointing return to Cannes for actor-turned-auteur Mathieu Amalric. Adapting Georges Simenon’s slender mystery novella with fidelity to its bleak narrative but indifference to its disquieting erotic and psychological subtext, Amalric’s fourth feature as a director is less a whodunit than a whodunwhat, with the star in wounded, taciturn form as a businessman under investigation for an initially unspecified crime. But while this appropriately brief film unravels its enigma at a tidy clip, it gathers neither enough heat, nor quite enough of a chill, to linger in the bones. Amalric’s name and a sexy premise may secure some distributor interest outside France, but the view from this “Room” is nonetheless limited.

Amalric’s last feature as director, the sweet-and-spiky burlesque-ensemble study “On Tour,” was a surprise hit in the 2010 Cannes competish, winning him best director and netting far wider arthouse exposure than his first two films. That “The Blue Room” was relegated to Un Certain Regard suggested less confidence on the selectors’ part, particularly with its roots in a key work by one of France’s most celebrated authors. (Maurice Pialat and Andre Techine are among the filmmakers who previously toyed with bringing it to the screen.) That caution is justified: Niche in appeal despite nifty, James M. Cain-esque genre trappings, Amalric’s exceedingly neat film doesn’t conjure the breath-holding intensity of mood that marks cinema’s best Simenon adaptations, including Cedric Kahn’s “Red Lights” and Patrice Leconte’s “Monsieur Hire.”

Only Gregoire Hetzel’s swooping, shrilling orchestral score  which evokes Maurice Jarre’s “Eyes Without a Face” compositions in isolated flashes  nods overtly to the noirish alarm of the material; Amalric’s verbal and visual storytelling otherwise operates at a low-temperature proficiency that stresses the story’s procedural structure ahead of its darker, nastier motivation. His most interesting formal coup is to confine his d.p. Christophe Beaucarne, traditionally a lushly generous craftsman, to a boxy 1.33:1 aspect ratio  which duly imbues proceedings with a certain itchy claustrophobia, but equally emphasizes the 75-minute pic’s formal and emotional slightness.

Though character names have been changed to no obvious end, Amalric and co-writer/co-star Stephanie Cleau hew close to Simenon’s text in many scenes, notably the lovers’ tryst in the eponymous hotel room that, while portrayed only in memory fragments, provides all the clues needed to unlock what emerges as a classically simple mystery. “If I were suddenly free, could you free yourself too?” asks foxy pharmacist’s wife Esther (Cleau) of mild-mannered family man Julien (Amalric) in their postcoital fug. Only as the film progresses does it become clear how seriously she means the question: From the office of the investigating magistrate (Laurent Poitrenaux), Julien reflects rather coldly on the outcome of the affair, and its effect on his already strained relationship with wife Delphine (Lea Drucker).

The combination of nonlinear narrative with rearview narration is managed with some skill by Amalric, as the film effectively keeps the question of Julien’s guilt  not to mention the small question of what he might actually be guilty of  in play for some time, until the return of Esther to present-day proceedings gets his blood up. But while the geometry of the storytelling might do Simenon proud, the atmospherics are lacking. Francois Gedigier’s editing effectively takes its cue from the clean, regular cadence of the novel’s sentences, but the rhythm doesn’t always move with the stakes, even as the film enters courtroom-drama territory in the final act. Imagery is similarly modest, though it makes good on the possibilities for color-coding presented by the title. Punchier than the cobalt walls of the hotel room (and, later, the courthouse) is red,  the obvious color of recrimination  whether in a heart-shaped drop of blood on bed linen or the scarlet hairdo of a witness.

Performances are fine across the contained ensemble, with Cleau putting a contemporary, independent spin on a femme fatale role. It’s only in such nuances of interpretation that the material is updated: Though Amalric sets the film in a world of visible Mac computers, it seems odd that an extramarital affair should proceed with the exchange of posted letters, and not a single text message.

Cannes Film Review: 'The Blue Room'

Reviewed at Cannes Film Festival (Un Certain Regard), May 16, 2014. Running time: 75 MIN. (Original title: "La Chambre bleue")

Production: (France) An Alfama Films production in co-production with Film(S), Arte France Cinema production in association with Cofinova 10. (International sales: Alfama Films, Paris.) Produced by Paulo Branco. Co-producer, Remi Burah.

Crew: Directed by Mathieu Amalric. Screenplay, Stephanie Cleau, Amalric, based on the novel by Georges Simenon. Camera (color), Christophe Beaucarne; editor, Francois Gedigier; music, Gregoire Hetzel; production designer, Christophe Offret; costume designer, Dorothee Guiraud; sound, Olivier Mauvezin; supervising sound editor, Severin Favriau; re-recording mixer, Stephane Thiebaut; visual effects supervisors, Jean-Francois Michelas, Damien Stumpf; visual effects, Atelier VFX; associate producer, John Simenon; assistant director, Amandine Escoffier; casting, Anne-Sophie Pierres.

With: Mathieu Amalric, Lea Drucker, Stephanie Cleau, Laurent Poitrenaux, Serge Bozon, Blutch, Mona Jaffart, Veronique Alain, Christophe Aubry.

More Film

  • I Lost My Body

    Netflix Pickup ‘I Lost My Body,’ ‘Buñuel,’ ‘Away’ Top Annecy Festival

    ANNECY, France  — Fulfilling expectations, Jeremy Clapin’s “I Lost My Body, the subject of one of the highest-profile Netflix deals at this year’s Cannes, won this Saturday the Annecy Festival’s top Cristal Award of best feature plus, in a relatively rare Annecy double whammy, the festival’s Audience Award. The first was expected, the second a [...]

  • 'Fausto' Review: Andrea Bussmann's Beautuful, Inscrutable

    Locarno in Los Angeles Film Review: 'Fausto'

    In more ways than one, “Fausto” is a film that likes to keep its audience in the dark: The bulk of its imagery is thickly cloaked in velvety night, often barely illuminated but for pinpricks of moonlight or a flickering candle, sometimes to the point where viewers must strain and squint to identify what they’re [...]

  • Toy Story 4

    The 15 Best Films of 2019 (So Far)

    By now, audiences have caught on to the way American distributors tend to stockpile their quality movies for end-of-year award-season release, but that doesn’t mean there aren’t treasures to be found in the first two quarters. In fact, sometimes it’s the movies that aren’t making a self-important Oscar push that wind up hitting closest to [...]

  • Chris Hemsworth (H) with Em (Tessa

    'Men In Black: International' Taking in $26 Million Amid Franchise Fatigue

    North American moviegoers spurned sequels this weekend with Sony’s “Men in Black: International” heading for a modest $26 million debut while “Shaft” will finish with a dismal $7.3 million in seventh place. “Men in Black: International,” the fourth iteration of the sci-fi comedy franchise, is performing under expectations, which had been in the $30 million [...]

  • Night scenery of the Bund in

    Shanghai Festival Defies Gloom to Open on Upbeat Note

    The Chinese film industry may not yet have emerged from a “cold winter” production freeze, nor its box office kept pace with 2018. But but those inclement elements did not put a chill on the pageantry at the Shanghai International Film Festival. The opening ceremony for the festival’s 22nd edition went ahead Saturday with the [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content