×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Berlin Film Review: ‘History of Fear’

Benjamin Naishtat never explicitly reveals what is making his characters so uncomfortable in this tense sociological thriller.

With:

Jonathan De Rosa, Tatiana Gimenez, Mirella Pascual, Clauda Cantero, Francisco Lumerman.

In “Jaws,” Steven Spielberg realized it was more frightening to withhold the shark than to show it. With “History of Fear,” budding Argentine helmer Benjamin Naishtat takes that tactic one step further, delivering a tense sociological thriller in which he never explicitly reveals what is making his characters so uncomfortable. Nor does he quite explain who those characters are, a shortcoming that ultimately thwarts audiences from connecting with this unsettling allegory on the most fundamental human level. Still, as the latest neophyte auteur to kneel at the altar of Michael Haneke, Naishtat doesn’t seem confined to homage, but instead has fresh, regionally relevant observations to make.

Naturally, the idea of sharks is more fearsome than the more ambiguous phobias that lurk in the minds of those who inhabit the suburbs north of Buenos Aires. Yet in Naishtat’s hands, the subtext intimidates even as what’s happening on the surface sometimes seems inscrutable, the helmer aiming not to confuse so much as to allow audiences to project their own interpretations. Perhaps the most straightforward example occurs early in the film, when a young man, Camilo (Francisco Lumerman), asks the head guard of an upscale housing estate to investigate whatever might have triggered the burglar alarm at his uncle’s mansion. The camera remains on the curb as the guard goes inside with shotgun drawn: Have criminals broken in, waiting to murder the owners and steal their possessions? The film offers no satisfying explanation, but allows audiences to share Camilo’s apprehension for the duration of this uneasy scene.

First and foremost, “History of Fear” functions as an exercise in prolonged tension, as one scenario after another encourages the viewer to identify with the nervous state of the collection of individuals — ciphers more than characters — who resurface over the course of the film’s running time: the anxiety of being trapped in an elevator alone, the self-inflicted thrills of riding a roller coaster, the threat of strangers encroaching on private property and, above all, the suggestion that virtually anything could be waiting in the dark.

Popular on Variety

At its most fundamental level, fear is created when people have something they are afraid of losing: health, property, life, stability, power, family. Only those without have nothing to fear. Stoking the collective discomfort, just as unsourced videotapes managed to upset the tenuous bourgeois stability in Haneke’s “Cache,” Camilo subjects those around him to a series of interviews about their fears. Over the course of an ordinary dinner party, he proposes a game in which everyone around the table must name what they want “to do and own.” If the scene works according to Naishtat’s design, audiences will soon find themselves considering the same question, and the instant one identifies these desires, fear is introduced, for there now exists something — if only an ambition of future happiness — of which they can be deprived.

But just how effective is this austerely conceived work at actually generating anxiety? It depends on many factors, but given that the director relies almost entirely on suggestion, the burden falls on the viewers themselves. Watching a roller coaster from a fixed position off to the side, where the tracks are abstractly framed and the revelers remain anonymous strangers, yields little or no vicarious identification with what those passengers feel. But stumbling around an exposed housing estate in the dark, after news reports have established a context of violence and previous scenes reveal the vulnerability of private property to unseen outsiders? That can be altogether more unsettling, especially when a child is missing and the film depicts the experience on the faces of his panic-stricken parents.

With virtually no music beyond that heard within each vignette (the exception being a low tonal hum that reverberates under several scenes), “History of Fear” relies on meticulous sound design to set the stage in scenes where many will find themselves flailing for sufficient context. Sometimes, not being told what to feel can be more nerve-racking than the strategy traditional horror movies use of emphasizing tension through score.

But there are also other tactics that, however cliched, might have strengthened Naishtat’s conceptual approach, including cutaways to a subjective camera angle (a la the VHS tapes in “Cache,” the lurking serial-killer p.o.v. seen in “Halloween,” or any chiller where a handheld camera lurks behind the bushes). While the pic may reject such gimmicks, it remains contrived enough in most other respects that one wishes it might have embraced a more established generic approach at times. After all, it seems odd to insist on inventing new ways of unnerving audiences when so many proven suspense strategies exist, especially in a film that calls itself “History of Fear.”

Berlin Film Review: 'History of Fear'

Reviewed at Berlin Film Festival (competing), Feb. 8, 2014. Running time: 79 MIN. Original title: "Historia del miendo"

Production:

(Argentina-France-Germany-Uruguay-Qatar) A REI Cine, Ecce Films, Mutante Cine, Vitakuben production. (International sales: Visit Films, New York.) Produced by Benjamin Domenech, Santiago Gallelli. Co-producers, Fernando Epstein, Agustina Chlarino, Emmanuel Chaumet, Leif Magne Tangen, Sarah Mirjam Schipschack.

Crew:

Directed, written by Benjamin Naishtat. Camera (color, widescreen, HD), Soledad Rodriguez; editors, Andres Quaranta, Fernando Epstein; production designer, Marina Raggo; sound designer, Fernando Ribero; casting, Maria Laura Berch.

With:

Jonathan De Rosa, Tatiana Gimenez, Mirella Pascual, Clauda Cantero, Francisco Lumerman.

More Film

  • ‘Gravedigger,’ ‘Zanka Contact,’ ‘Sweet Annoyance’ Win

    ‘The Gravedigger,’ ‘Zanka Contact’ and ‘Sweet Annoyance’ Win Top Prizes at 2nd Atlas Workshops

    Djibouti’s “The Gravedigger,” Morocco’s “Zanka Contact” and Ethiopia’s “Sweet Annoyance” were among the major winners in the post-production and development categories of the second edition of the Marrakech Film Festival’s Atlas Workshops. “The Gravedigger,” by Khadar Ahmed, and “Zanka Contact,” by Ismaël el Iraki, won the top awards – €20,000 ($22,000) and $11,000 respectively – [...]

  • Robert De Niro, Martin Scorsese and

    Film News Roundup: Leonardo DiCaprio Presenting Robert De Niro SAG Life Achievement Award

    In today’s film news roundup, Leonardo DiCaprio will present Robert De Niro with his SAG Life Achievement Award, the Oliver Sacks documentary finds a home and UCLA’s School of Theater, Film and Television gets a new dean. AWARD PRESENTATION Leonardo DiCaprio has been selected to present Robert De Niro the SAG Life Achievement Award  at [...]

  • KARNAWAL

    ‘Karnawal,’ ‘Restless,’ ‘Summer White,’ ‘Firsts’ Win Big at Ventana Sur

    BUENOS AIRES  — With Ventana Sur now firing on multiple cylinders, featuring pix-in post or project competitions for not only art films but also genre pics and animation – two sectors embraced by young creators in Latin America – “Karnawal,” “Restless,” “Summer White” and  “Firsts” proved big winners among Ventana Sur’s arthouse and animation competitions, [...]

  • (center) George MacKay as Schofield in

    From "1917" to "Jojo Rabbit," Composers of Some of the Year's Top Scores Talk Shop

    “1917,” Thomas Newman The 20-year collaboration of director Sam Mendes and composer Thomas Newman has encompassed midlife crisis (“American Beauty”), crime in the Depression (“Road to Perdition”), the Gulf War (“Jarhead”), marriage in the 1950s (“Revolutionary Road”) and two James Bond adventures (“Skyfall,” “Spectre”). Now they’ve tackled World War I, with “1917,” but Mendes’ much-talked-about [...]

  • Billy Magnussen Aladdin

    'Aladdin' Spinoff With Billy Magnussen's Character in the Works for Disney Plus

    Disney is developing a spinoff of its live-action “Aladdin” with Billy Magnussen reprising his Prince Anders character. The unnamed project is in early development for the studio’s recently launched Disney Plus streaming service. Disney has hired Jordan Dunn and Michael Kvamme to write a script centered on the haughty Prince Anders, one of Princess Jasmine’s [...]

  • ROAD TRIP – In Disney and

    Disney Boasts a Bevy of Hopefuls for Oscar's Original Song Race

    When the Academy announces its shortlist for song nominations on Dec. 16, you can be certain that at least one Disney song will be on it and probably more. Disney songs have been nominated 33 times in the past 30 years, winning 12 of the gold statuettes. This year, the studio has at least four [...]

  • Innovative Scores Elevated the Year's Documentaries

    Innovative Scores Elevated the Year's Documentaries

    It’s next to impossible for a documentary score to be Oscar-nominated alongside the dozens of fictional narratives entered each year. But it did happen, just once: In 1975, composer Gerald Fried was nominated for his music for “Birds Do It, Bees Do It,” a documentary on the mating habits of animals. Fried, now 91, perhaps [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content