How ‘Maze Runner’ Escaped the Young Adult Franchise Curse

The Maze Runner” kicked off a fresh young adult film franchise this weekend when it raced to an $81.5 million debut globally.

Despite the monster grosses of “The Hunger Games” and “Twilight,” hit young adult films like “The Maze Runner” are the exception and not the rule.

Just ask the good folks behind “Ender’s Game,” “Beautiful Creatures,” “Eragon,” “The Giver” and “The Spiderwick Chronicles,” all of which seem unlikely to spawn future sequels. Others, such as “The Mortal Instruments,” probably won’t be generating new chapters, despite protestations to the contrary. Those stories may have devoted readers, but not enough people bought tickets when they made the transition from page to screen.

“Even with a baked-in must-see factor, you never know with this audience,” said Paul Dergarabedian, senior media analyst at Rentrak. “They change their minds when wind blows.”

Like “The Maze Runner,” these pictures arrived with literary pedigree allowing their backers to proclaim, “Based on the best-selling phenomenon,” while crowing about “brand pre-awareness.” That’s lovely. It’s just not enough.

“You still have to make a good movie that resonates with a core fanbase, but can stand on its own,” said Jeff Bock, a box office analyst with Exhibitor Relations.

Instead, these films seemed overly derivative. There was a dusting of female empowerment, a la “The Hunger Games,” or a hunky vampire or immortal in the vein of “Twilight,” and an endless array of post-apocalyptic backdrops as in, well, practically everything. Yet audiences rejected pictures that felt like Frankenstein’s monsters patched together by a committee in order to mirror the elements that studio executives had come to believe explained those films’ successes.

What set “The Maze Runner” apart was a cast led by “Teen Wolf” star Dylan O’Brien and a plot that had a group of teenagers struggling to survive a deadly labyrinth.

“It’s the first YA franchise that has a male protagonist,” said Chris Aronson, domestic distribution chief for 20th Century Fox, the studio behind the movie.

That meant that “The Maze Runner” was able to attract roughly an equal number of men and women, with 49% of the opening crowd being male. Appealing to men certainly helped “The Hunger Games,” which drew an opening crowd that was 39% male in 2012, and it worked this time around as well. In order to broaden the film’s appeal, “The Maze Runner” was marketed as an action-heavy thriller. That also helped it stand out from “The Giver,” “Divergent” and all the other dystopian adventures popping up on screens these days.

“These films are marketed by professional adults, not teenagers, so it can be hard to put your finger on what it is that that young audiences think is cool,” said Dergarabedian. “Six or seven times out of ten, you’re not going to hit that mark, but when you do, you’ve really got something.”

Having caught lightning in a bottle, Fox wasted no time announcing a sequel. “Maze Runner: Scorch Trials” will open on Sept. 18, 2015.

Not everyone agrees that young adult films are a knotty genre to untangle. After all, it can be hard to make any type of film pop in the era of Twitter, YouTube, videogames and other amusements.

“I don’t know what the batting average is for other genres, but young adult films are a relatively new thing and they may just be having more attention paid to them,” said Ben Carlson, co-creator of the social media tracking service Fizziology. “If you compare it to science fiction or R-rated comedies, it’s probably a similar batting average.”

What is different, Carlson argues, is the kind of success “The Maze Runner” managed to achieve. Filmed for $34 million, the picture is an economical bet that paid off, but it did not match the success of “Divergent,” “The Hunger Games” or “Twilight,” all of which debuted to north of $50 million.

“This film was a really solid hit, but it wasn’t a monster one,” said Carlson. “As a genre matures, you’re going to have more solid hits like this that aren’t $50 million opening blockbusters or ‘Why did that only open to $15 million?’ failures. We haven’t really seen that in the YA space until now.”

With that, a genre geared at kids comes of age.

More Film

  • Disney Pandora World Of Avatar, Lake

    The Piano Guys Play 'Avatar' Theme in Disney World (Watch)

    The YouTube sensation The Piano Guys have taken a trip to the world of Pandora for a performance of the theme to “Avatar.” Shot in the bioluminescent floating forest in Disney World, cellist Steven Sharp Nelson and pianist Jon Schmidt put their spin on the score to James Cameron’s 2009 blockbuster. The video immerses the [...]

  • Editorial use only. No book cover

    Billy Drago, 'Untouchables' Star, Dies at 73

    Billy Drago, who often played harming but chilling gangster roles and appeared in Brian De Palma’s “The Untouchables” and Clint Eastwood’s “Pale Rider,” died Monday in Los Angeles of complications from a stroke. He was 73. The character actor played Al Capone’s henchman Frank Nitti in 1987’s “The Untouchables.” On TV series “Charmed,” he put [...]

  • Grant Sputore

    'I Am Mother' Director Tackles Margot Robbie-Produced Thriller 'Augmented'

    Warner Bros. has hired “I Am Mother” director Grant Sputore to helm the science-fiction thriller “Augmented” which Margot Robbie is producing, Variety has learned exclusively. Michael Lloyd Green is rewriting an original script by Mark Townend. Denise Di Novi and Tom Ackerley are also producing. Production companies are Robbie’s LuckyChap and Di Novi’s eponymous Di [...]

  • Miley Cyrus

    Miley Cyrus Teases 'Charlie's Angels' Collaboration with Ariana Grande and Lana Del Rey

    Three of the biggest female pop stars have joined forces in a new song for the Elizabeth Banks-directed reboot of “Charlie’s Angels.” In a tweet posted Wednesday, Miley Cyrus hinted at a collaboration between herself, Lana Del Rey, and Ariana Grande in the forthcoming film. Alongside a 14-second teaser, originally posted by Sony Pictures, the [...]

  • AMC TheatresShop signs, Los Angeles, America

    AMC Subscription Program Hits 860k Members

    AMC’s subscription service, launched in 2018 as a challenger to MoviePass, has reached 860,129 members in its first 12 months. Given the unwieldy moniker of AMC Stubs A-List, the service costs between $19.95 to $23.95 per month depending on where users live. The company initially said it had hoped to sign up 500,000 members in [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content