Ed Asner’s Suit Against SAG-AFTRA Dismissed

Action had been filed in May

A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit filed against SAG-AFTRA by Ed Asner and 15 other plaintiffs over alleged mishandling of $132 million in residuals and foreign royalties.

U.S. District Court Judge Manuel Real said in a filing Tuesday that he had granted the union’s dismissal motion, noting that union has been sufficiently cooperative in providing access to its materials.

“At this point in time it is apparent that SAG-AFTRA is working with plaintiffs to allow them to examine records SAG-AFTRA believes they are entitled to examine,” Real said. “The dispute over such examination is therefore not ‘definite and concrete’ because it is not even clear which books and records, if any, are not being proferred for examination.”

Real indicated that the plaintiffs may be able to re-visit the issue. He wrote that the factual situation is still developing, adding that it would be “impracticable” to decide whether SAG-AFTRA is not allowing access to documents that the plaintiffs are entitled by law to examine.

“This issue is therefore not fit for judicial decision at this time,” he added.

Real said that the both sides can continue to work on the issue of examining documents, and that the plaintiffs can still pursue a claim under the federal laws requiring unions to file annual financial reports with the Dept of Labor. He also dismissed the suit’s state law claims alleging conversion and unfair business practices, asserting he had no jurisdiction over the state law matters.

The suit alleges that SAG-AFTRA has improperly withheld funds and stonewalled requests for information about $130 million held in trust by the union — including domestic residuals and foreign royalties collected by the union through foreign collecting societies without authorization or knowledge of union members. The suit also alleges that the union has cashed residuals checks and then claimed an inability to locate the actors to whom it owes money.

Eric Hughes, one of the plaintiffs, alleged on Wednesday that SAG-AFTRA had misled Real as to its conduct in providing the plaintiffs access to its records. He also indicated that the plaintiffs are considering filing another claim under the federal statutes covering union financial reporting.

“We have not been given any financial records but instead Microsoft PowerPoint presentations and have not been allowed to leave the building with agreements which SAG-AFTRA has entered into without any authority to do so, and without disclosure, which have long affected the rights of every member of SAG and every member of AFTRA and diverted monies rightfully ours to our employers,” he said.

“SAG-AFTRA now has the option of doing what they have misled the Court into believing that they are doing or, as the Court has made clear, we are free to, and will again, file a claim under § 431,” Hughes continued.

SAG-AFTRA Chief Administrative Officer and General Counsel Duncan Crabtree-Ireland said in a statement, “We are pleased with the judge’s order and believe the complete dismissal is fully warranted. The Court acknowledged SAG-AFTRA’s ongoing cooperation with the plaintiffs. SAG-AFTRA has more than 1,000 pages of annual disclosure documents available online to anyone.”

Since the suit was filed eight months ago, the union repeatedly insisted that it’s done nothing wrong and characterized the suit as “frivolous.” It has also asserted on numerous occasions that without its efforts, actors would not have seen any of the foreign funds nor received unclaimed residuals — a theme sounded again by Crabtree-Ireland on Wednesday.

“Despite this unfortunate and unnecessary litigation, we remain focused on collecting and distributing foreign royalties and unclaimed residuals, programs of which we are justifiably proud,” Crabtree-Ireland said. “We hope that this dismissal will mark an end to such lawsuits that needlessly expend union resources.”

SAG-AFTRA said Wednesday that its foreign royalties program claims funds on behalf of SAG-AFTRA performers under foreign countries’ laws that provide for payments to artists in audiovisual works to compensate for private copying (home recording), cable retransmissions, video rentals and other uses.

“Over the last six years, the union has distributed more than $17.5 million in foreign royalties to SAG-AFTRA members money that would have been lost to them forever had we not taken action,” it added.

The original suit was filed on May 24. Real narrowed the issues on Oct. 7, allowing the suit to include the issue of residuals and three of the 16 plaintiffs to proceed with their claims on unpaid foreign royalties.

The union filed the 18-page motion on Nov. 20, asserting that the plaintiffs’ claims under state law should be tossed because they are “completely preempted by federal labor law” and that the plaintiffs “do not have the authority to sue on behalf of anyone other than themselves.”

The plaintiffs responded on Dec. 16, portraying the union as reckless in how it handles funds that it’s supposed to distribute to performers.

“SAG-AFTRA simply does not record what is earned but it willy-nilly converts checks as it sees fit, by either endorsing checks made out to performers and placing same into its purported Trust Account, or by holding onto performers checks for months if not years on end to the ongoing detriment of its members who depend on these earnings to live,” the plaintiffs said in last month’s filing.


Popular on Variety

More Film

  • Noele trailer Anna Kendrick

    Disney Unveils 'Noelle' Trailer Starring Anna Kendrick, Bill Hader

    Among the many announcements at the D23 Expo, Disney debuted the first look at holiday feature “Noelle,” which is set to premiere exclusively on Disney Plus this fall. “It isn’t Christmas without Santa’s Sister,” Walt Disney Studios said of the film on Twitter. Starring Anna Kendrick and Bill Hader, the Christmas flick tells the story [...]

  • A Hidden Life Movie Austria

    Film News Roundup: Austin Festival Selects Terrence Malick's 'A Hidden Life'

    In today’s film news roundup, the Austin Film Festival selects a Terrence Malick title, “A Day Without a Mexican” gets a sequel and DCR Finance signs a first-look deal. FESTIVAL SCREENING The Austin Film Festival will screen Terrence Malick’s “A Hidden Life,” which won the Francois Chalais and Ecumenical Jury awards at the Cannes Film [...]

  • Blake Lively

    Blake Lively's 'Rhythm Section' Moved Back to 2020

    Paramount Pictures has moved the release date of Blake Lively’s “The Rhythm Section” back two months from Nov. 22 to Jan. 31, 2020, the weekend of Super Bowl LIV. The spy tale, adapted from Mark Burnell’s novels surrounding character Stephanie Patrick, is produced by James Bond producers Barbara Broccoli and Michael G. Wilson through their [...]

  • The Mandalorian

    'The Mandalorian': Watch the First Trailer for 'Star Wars' Series

    The gunslinging lone warrior — the Mandalorian, as they call him — calls the far reaches of the “Star Wars” galaxy home. Disney dropped the first trailer for the spinoff series during its biennial D23 convention on Friday, finally giving fans a closer look at the franchise’s newest character. “The Mandalorian” creator Jon Favreau, who [...]

  • Lady and the Tramp trailer

    'Lady and the Tramp': Disney's Live-Action Remake Gets First Trailer (Watch)

    Ready your dog-friendly bowl of spaghetti, Disney has debuted the first trailer for its live-action remake of “Lady and the Tramp,” starring Tessa Thompson and Justin Theroux. The teaser was released during Disney’s D23 Expo in Anaheim at the Disney + presentation. In addition to Thompson and Theroux, who play the Lady and Tramp, respectively, [...]

  • Mickey Mouse waves to members of

    Spider-Man, Spicer and Splashy First-Looks: Everything We're Looking For at D23

    As if Disney hasn’t owned enough weekends this year at the box office, the biennial D23 Expo will light up Anaheim, Calif. over the next three days to celebrate the content monolith. From a new Netflix-competing streaming platform to scores of movie and series reveals — along with a few hot controversies to confront — [...]

  • Angel Has Fallen

    'Angel Has Fallen' to Dominate Modest Box Office With $20 Million Weekend

    Gerard Butler and Morgan Freeman are leading the way at the North American box office with “Angel Has Fallen” on its way to about $20 million, early estimates showed Friday. Should forecasts hold, “Angel Has Fallen” will take in about double the next title, Universal’s second weekend of raunchy comedy “Good Boys” with about $10 [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content