Berlin Film Review: ‘Aloft’

Peruvian Oscar nominee Claudia Llosa enlists a courageous Jennifer Connelly in her latest subversion of pseudo-religious beliefs.


Jennifer Connelly, Cillian Murphy, Melanie Laurent, William Shimell, Zen McGrath, Winta McGrath, Oona Chaplin, Peter McRobbie, Ian Tracey, Andy Murray. (English, French dialogue)

Claudia Llosa expands her preoccupations with mysticism and superstition in the modern world, working her way up from a medieval-minded Andean village in “Madeinusa” to faith healing at the frigid far reaches of the Arctic Circle with “Aloft.” But this time, instead of seeming plugged into some primitive native religion, the Peruvian helmer invents a rickety belief system as a pretext for tearing it all down, botching the telling of a more satisfying character-based story in the process. Replacing melancholy muse Magaly Solier with an equally forlorn-looking international cast led by a courageous Jennifer Connelly, Llosa stands to baffle more than her usual circle of arthouse adherents with this doleful downer, snapped up by Sony Classics before its Berlinale premiere.

Chief among Llosa’s new champions is exec producer Mark Johnson, whose involvement has allowed the helmer to operate on a far more expansive canvas than her Golden Bear-winning 2009 film “The Milk of Sorrow,” enlisting such vital collaborators as composer Michael Brook (“Into the Wild”) and cinematographer Nicolas Bolduc (“War Witch”), but hasn’t necessarily made her austere style any more accessible.

Eschewing traditional exposition, “Aloft” uses documentary techniques — namely, verite-style voyeurism amplified by disorienting jump cuts and restless handheld camerawork — to immerse audiences in its slightly off blue-collar world. We first spy Nana (Connelly) with her hand buried elbow deep in a pregnant sow, struggling to deliver a blocked piglet. From this startling image, the pic cuts to a decidedly unromantic tryst between Nana and a fellow farmer in the back room.

Life’s pleasures are few — and showers seemingly unheard of — for this grime-covered single mother, who has her hands full raising two kids, one a restless autodidact named Ivan (Zen McGrath), the other a terminally ill cherub whom everyone calls Gully (Winta McGrath). Starved for the context needed to navigate a world foreign enough to qualify as science fiction, viewers learn on the run that Nana and others in her scruffy rural community pin their limited hopes on a traveling miracle worker, subjecting themselves to a crude lottery system to see who will be lucky enough for a laying-on of hands.

Ivan is less than enthusiastic about tagging along for a trip to the weird wigwam-style structure where his brother might be “treated,” asking whether he can bring his pet falcon along for the trip. Yes, his falcon … because a unicorn might have disrupted the precarious pseudo-realistic parallel universe Llosa is so diligently constructing, positioned somewhere between poverty and post-apocalypse — where “Kes” meets “Children of Men.” Some confusing things happen, amid which the falcon goes rogue, the stick hut collapses and Nana discovers that she, too, has the healing touch.

“Aloft” belongs to an ambitious school of allegorical storytelling whose creators find it more interesting to raise open-ended questions than explain everything with pat answers. But until this point, the questions most people will be asking are: Who are these people, where are we, and what is going on? But after the incident with the falcon, Llosa is free to delve into the themes that really interest her, namely Nana’s subsequent decision to sever all ties to her previous life in order to work as a folk artist-cum-shaman.

To better understand the consequences of Nana’s choice, the film introduces a parallel narrative a quarter-century down the road, as Ivan (who’s bloomed into a morose-looking Cillian Murphy) has become a professional falconer, hacking — as the raptor-training process is called — young birds from the dumpy shack he shares with his wife (Oona Chaplin). Into his life arrives Jannia (Melanie Laurent, beautiful but barely intelligible), a guarded French woman purportedly investigating a documentary about falconry — one of the few indications of mass media in a world where Dark Age customs (like falconry) freely thrive again.

At the young lady’s insistence, Ivan agrees to travel to the far north, where his estranged mother has now dedicated herself to building strange stick sculptures and healing strangers full-time. Murphy, who hasn’t appeared so angst-ridden onscreen since “Breakfast on Pluto,” has the most baggage to work through over the course of the film, while Llosa plays her cards as a series of short, exasperatingly obtuse glimpses into Ivan’s past, until such time as the helmer deems it appropriate to reveal her full hand.

In the end, everything fits together rather ingeniously, though it’s clear that in orchestrating her needlessly complicated nonlinear narrative, Llosa has mistaken confusion for suspense. The story isn’t a proper mystery, sharing more in common with dreams than memory, but the helmer withholds key clues, including Ivan’s relation to Nana (which couldn’t really be written around), with the perversity of a cruel deity — one who not only establishes the religion of the land, but takes it upon herself to dismantle it as well.

Berlin Film Review: 'Aloft'

Reviewed at Berlin Film Festival (competing), Feb. 12, 2014. Running time: 116 MIN.


(Spain-Canada-France) A Sony Pictures Classics (in U.S./Latin America) release of a Wanda Vision, Arcadia Motion Pictures, Buffalo Gal Pictures production in co-production with Manitoba Films, Noodles Prod., with the participation of TVE, Canal Plus, TVC, with the support of ICAA, IEC, Telefilm Canada, Manitobal Film & Music, NCN, Institut Francais. Executive producer, Mark Johnson.


Directed, written by Claudia Llosa. Camera (color, widescreen), Nicolas Bolduc; editor, Guille de la Cal; music, Michael Brook; production designer, Eugenio Caballero; sound designer, Fabiola Ordoyo; line producer, Sandra Hermida.


Jennifer Connelly, Cillian Murphy, Melanie Laurent, William Shimell, Zen McGrath, Winta McGrath, Oona Chaplin, Peter McRobbie, Ian Tracey, Andy Murray. (English, French dialogue)

More Film

  • Too Old to Die Young

    Cannes: 2019 Lineup Includes Terrence Malick, Pedro Almodóvar, Four Films by Women

    The 72nd Cannes Film Festival unveiled its lineup, boosting the number of female filmmakers in official selection to 13 — four of which will compete for the Palme d’Or, the highest number since 2011. Additionally, new movies by Pedro Almodóvar and American directors Terrence Malick and Ira Sachs join Elton John biopic “Rocketman” and the [...]

  • Cannes Unveils 2019 Official Selection (Watch

    Watch Cannes Lineup Announcement (Updating Live)

    The 72nd Cannes Film Festival is announcing the films chosen for “official selection” — including those competing for the event’s coveted Palme d’Or prize — in a press conference Thursday starting at 11 a.m. in Paris. The livestream of the press conference is available here. (Please note that the broadcast seldom starts on time.) Last [...]

  • Godzilla

    'Godzilla' Owner Toho Poised for Expansion in Hollywood

    Toho, the largest movie group in Japan, is expanding a subsidiary in the U.S. with a view to working more with Hollywood. The company said that its existing Toho International Inc. subsidiary has been injected with $14 million (JPY15.4 billion), through a share issue subscribed to by the parent company. The subsidiary has existed since [...]

  • View Conference Opens Registration for 2019

    2019 View Conference Opens Registration, Calls for Short Film Competition Entries

    Registration is now open for the 2019 edition of the View Conference in Turin, Italy. No speakers have been announced yet, but past conferences have featured some of the world’s top creative talents in visual effects, animation, gaming, virtual reality, augmented reality and mixed reality. Last year’s edition featured composer Hans Zimmer, Paramount Animation topper [...]

  • Former professional boxer Bradley Welsh in

    Bradley Welsh, 'T2 Trainspotting' Actor, Shot Dead in Edinburgh

    Bradley Welsh, an actor in “T2 Trainspotting” and a former boxer, died after being shot in Edinburgh, Scotland, on Wednesday. He was 42. The Edinburgh Police Division reported an incident on Chester Street in Edinburgh’s West End neighborhood around 8 p.m. local time. They found Welsh seriously injured in the street and said he died [...]

  • Jim Gallagher Warner Bros

    Jim Gallagher Joins Warner Bros. as EVP of Marketing, Animation and Family

    Former head of DreamWorks Animation theatrical marketing Jim Gallagher has joined Warner Bros. Pictures in a newly created role as executive vice president of marketing, animation and family, announced today by Blair Rich, president of worldwide marketing at Warner Bros. Pictures and Warner Bros. Home Entertainment. Gallagher will develop innovative and strategic global campaigns for [...]

  • Timothy Olyphant Luke Perry

    Timothy Olyphant Recalls Working With Luke Perry on 'Once Upon a Time in Hollywood'

    Luke Perry’s last role will be in Quentin Tarantino’s “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood,” and his co-star Timothy Olyphant got a front-row seat to the late actor’s final performance. Perry, who died this March after suffering a massive stroke, had completed all of his scenes in the upcoming film prior to his sudden death. [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content