×

Toronto Film Review: ‘Boychoir’

Dustin Hoffman coaches a group of angel-voiced young men in this feel-good, yet far-from-treacly family drama.

With:
Dustin Hoffman, Kathy Bates, Eddie Izzard, Debra Winger, Josh Lucas, Kevin McHale, Garrett Wareing, Joe West.

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3302706/

The voices are the stars, while Dustin Hoffman is just along to support the gifted preteen sopranos in “Boychoir.” A welcome return to feature filmmaking by “The Red Violin” director Francois Girard, this relatively by-the-numbers boarding-school drama distinguishes itself through song, thanks to the exceptional musical talents of the American Boychoir School, preteen sopranos whose otherworldly talent lasts for only a few years at most. The mystery of where that ability comes from, coupled with the urgency to share it, lends urgency to an otherwise generic coming-of-ager sure to delight those seeking spiritually grounded, emotionally uplifting entertainment.

The distressing thing about most talent is that it tends to come with a shelf life, nearly always fading over time. (That means you, Justin Bieber!) From pop stars to Olympic gold medalists, exceptional ability typically has an expiration date, and few fields illustrate that narrow window of opportunity better than that of the boychoir: angelic-voiced young men racing against puberty to make their mark. (The rather drastic Italian “solution” of castration offers a metaphor for the desperate ways humans try to artificially extend their period of artistic relevance, although that’s a conversation for another time.)

With myriad chances for transcendent musical interludes along the way, mixed to take full advantage of theater audio systems, “Boychoir” looks at a single season in the life of one such soprano, a Texas kid named Stet (Garrett Wareing) who’s born with an uncanny musical ability, but raised with neither training nor encouragement. Stet acts out at public school, where the principal (Debra Winger) rather miraculously picks up on his potential and begs Carvelle (Hoffman), the creatively fictionalized headmaster of the American Boychoir School, to audition the troubled 11-year-old for a spot in his elite choral program.

That same day, Stet’s mom dies in a car crash — a tragedy presented so tastefully it actually borders on tacky. That’s because music-savvy screenwriter Ben Ripley (“Source Code”) has rigged the family dynamics to suit the drama, eliminating Stet’s mother and introducing in her place an illegitimate father, Gerard (Josh Lucas), who writes a generous enough check to ensure Stet a spot at ABS, but otherwise shows zero interest in his estranged son, whose existence threatens his married life back in New York.

While the school’s practical-minded headmistress (Kathy Bates) takes Gerard’s “donation,” Carvelle resents this approach, holding the bribery against his new student. Sharing the skepticism is his No. 2, Drake (Eddie Izzard), an ambitious would-be choirmaster itching to inherit Carvelle’s chair. Drake’s competitive fervor ultimately taints the group, sparking a ruthless rivalry between the arrogant lead singer (Joe West) and the friendless Stet.

“It must be a special kind of torture waiting for someone to retire,” the headmistress snaps at Drake, demonstrating the kind of turpentine wit that distinguishes Bates’ voice amid this impressive adult ensemble. It should be said that all three veteran thesps — Hoffman, Bates and Izzard — defy the rule of talent waning with time, and though this isn’t necessarily the type of project any of them might have taken at their peak, the film benefits from their almost casual excellence: They make it look easy.

For his part, Hoffman wasn’t content to play the icy choirmaster who gradually thaws to the realization that the undisciplined Stet is the most talented student he’s ever encountered. He, too, has a few things to learn from the young man, although this isn’t the sort of tuner where classical tradition must yield to modern tendencies. We hear the kids rapping in their free time, but the film celebrates the centuries-old art of religious choral arrangements, culminating in a modified presentation of Handel’s “Messiah” at Christ Church, Conn., hinging on one of the boys’ being able to hit a high “D.”

Hoffman graciously allows Wareing to shine, while reinforcing the theme that there’s a finite opportunity for greatness, and his depends on finding the right group of talented kids to cement his legacy before he retires. Hoffman plays it stern, but when the facade cracks and he finally shows warmth, audiences’ hearts will melt in appreciation. “Boychoir” may be soft, but it’s not run-of-the-mill TV-movie treacle, offering just enough edge to lend credibility (one reason for that earlier car crash) while keeping it appropriate for all ages.

Wareing has his work cut out for him opposite Hoffman, needing to look convincing as both a vocal prodigy and a tormented youth — although the actor, whose flip-forward hairstyle and bee-stung lips suggest Chloe Moretz’s male twin, looks a bit too genteel for the tough-guy routine. He wins us over during a heartbreaking holiday montage, when all the other students go home, leaving Stet alone on campus, abandoned by his father and forgotten by his peers. Of the younger cast, “Glee’s” Kevin McHale most impresses as the junior instructor who shows faith in Stet’s ability.

In a country where musical talent is so often confused with sex appeal, “Boychoir” offers a welcome alternative, celebrating discipline, talent and the sound of untainted innocence. In the real world, this style of singing is too easily subject to homophobia and teasing, and yet the film treats it in such a way that could inspire other young men to seize their potential while it lasts.

Popular on Variety

Toronto Film Review: 'Boychoir'

Reviewed at Toronto Film Festival (Gala Presentations), Sept. 5, 2014. Running time: 103 MIN.

Production: An Informant Media presentation and production, in association with Embankment Media. (International sales: Embankment Films.) Produced by Judy Cairo, Carol Baum, Jane Goldenring. Executive producers, Michael A. Simpson, Eric Brenner, Tim Haslam, Hugo Grumbar, Grant Guthrie, Ben Ripley, Darrel Casalino, Guirec van Slingelandt, Rob van den Berg, Paul B. Loyd Jr., Jeff Steen, Bob Westendarp, Jarod Becker.

Crew: Directed by Francois Girard. Screenplay, Ben Ripley. Camera (widescreen, color), David Franco; editor, Gaetan Huot; music, Brian Byrne; production designer, Jane Musky; sound (Dolby), Tom Nelson; re-recording mixer, Bernard Gariety; special effects coordinator, Drew Jiritaro; casting, John Papsidera.

With: Dustin Hoffman, Kathy Bates, Eddie Izzard, Debra Winger, Josh Lucas, Kevin McHale, Garrett Wareing, Joe West.

More Film

  • Mickey Mouse waves to members of

    Spider-Man, Spicer and Splashy First-Looks: Everything We're Looking For at D23

    As if Disney hasn’t owned enough weekends this year at the box office, the biennial D23 Expo will light up Anaheim, Calif. over the next three days to celebrate the content monolith. From a new Netflix-competing streaming platform to scores of movie and series reveals — along with a few hot controversies to confront — [...]

  • Angel Has Fallen

    'Angel Has Fallen' to Dominate Modest Box Office With $20 Million Weekend

    Gerard Butler and Morgan Freeman are leading the way at the North American box office with “Angel Has Fallen” on its way to about $20 million, early estimates showed Friday. Should forecasts hold, “Angel Has Fallen” will take in about double the next title, Universal’s second weekend of raunchy comedy “Good Boys” with about $10 [...]

  • Aracne

    Sanfic Standout ‘Aracne’ Filmmakers Discuss the State of Chilean Genre

    A key project at this year’s Santiago Lab, the Santiago Intl. Film Festival industry forum for promising Latin American projects, Florencia Dupont’s “Aracne” is representative of a push from the next generation of Chilean filmmakers into genre cinema and the themes it can explore. “Aracne” turns on Beatriz, a young journalist at a small Santiago [...]

  • Eduardo Machuca

    Chile’s Eduardo Machuca Unveils Machuca Films Slate (EXCLUSIVE)

    SANTIAGO, Chile – Eduardo Machuca, the former film co-ordinator of Chile’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, has launched his own production company, Machuca Films. “After 25 years at the ministry, I felt I needed to tap my creative side,” said Machuca, who is also tying the knot on Saturday (Aug. 25) with a former Sanfic staffer, [...]

  • Robert Downey Jr. Disney Legends Ceremony,

    Robert Downey Jr. Reveals He Was Busted for Smoking Pot at Disneyland

    Robert Downey Jr. celebrated his Disney Legend status by sharing the endearing tale of how the first time he visited Disneyland, he was arrested. The Iron Man actor was being honored in Anaheim at Disney’s biennial D23 convention. After a brief introduction by Disney chief executive officer Bob Iger, Downey felt he had to come [...]

  • Thandie Newton Reminiscence

    Thandie Newton Reteams With 'Westworld's' Lisa Joy on 'Reminiscence' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Following her Emmy win for her performance on “Westworld,” Thandie Newton is joining the feature directorial debut of the show’s co-creator. Sources tell Variety that Newton is set to join Hugh Jackman and Rebecca Ferguson in Warner Bros.’ “Reminiscence,” directed by “Westworld’s” Lisa Joy. WB acquired the rights to the package after this year’s Berlin [...]

  • Ming-Na Wen poses at the Disney

    Original 'Mulan' Star Ming-Na Wen Weighs in on Remake's Controversy

    Ming-Na Wen, who played the leading voice role in the original 1998 version of “Mulan,” has spoken out about the recent controversy surrounding Disney’s forthcoming live-action remake, which has been co-opted by China’s authoritarian regime to attack Hong Kong protestors. “We are living in a world right now where there’s so much change and confusion [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content