You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

FilmOn X Seeks To Intervene As Supreme Court Weighs Aereo Case

FilmOn X, the Aereo rival that also offers digital streams of broadcast signals, has asked the Supreme Court that its attorneys be allowed to file briefs and address the justices in oral arguments when the networks’ case against Aereo reaches the high court this spring.

FilmOn X, founded by Alki David, has had a much different path in the courts than Aereo. Federal judges in Los Angeles and Washington have halted its offering of station signals without broadcasters’ permission, and the D.C. judge even prohibited FilmOn X from offering those streams in much of the country. After the Supreme Court agreed to take the Aereo case on Jan. 10, FilmOn X’s appeals have been frozen in place as courts wait for an opinion from the justices.

“Although FilmOn X and Aereo have a common interest in this court in protecting an individual’s right of private performance, FilmOn X is uniquely situated,” FilmOn X’s attorney, Ryan Baker of Baker Marquart, said in a motion to intervene submitted to the Supreme Court on Friday. “It has been enjoined from offering its consumers access to network content across most of the United States. Aereo is not subject to the injunctions issued against FilmOn X, which has suffered significant harm as a result of the enjoinment. Aereo has an incentive to leave injunctions against its primary competitor intact and may not adequately represent FilmOn X’s interests before this court.”

FilmOn X contends that its intervention would not delay the court, which has yet to schedule oral arguments in the Aereo case, although they are expected for some time in April. The company says that its participation “will ensure that the viewpoints of all the necessary and appropriate parties are considered, which will advance the causes of justice and finality.” FilmOn X’s attorney Baker added that “it is likely that any ruling against Aereo would impair FilmOn X.”

“Should the nearly nationwide injunction against FilmOn X remain, it will cause FilmOn X to suffer continued revenue losses, market share losses, loss of brand recognition, loss of customer loyalty, lost opportunities with vendors and sponsors and lost goodwill — All to Aereo’s benefit,” the company’s attorney said in the filing.

Oral arguments were held in August in FilmOn X’s appeal to the 9th Circuit of the Los Angeles decision. But the 9th Circuit last week said that it would not issue an opinion pending the Supreme Court’s judgment in the Aereo case.

FilmOn X is still operating as a free service, just not the major network affiliate feeds, and contends that it “has always been willing to negotiate appropriate content license agreements where such agreements are required.”

The networks have contended that Aereo and other similar services undercut their retransmission agreements with cable and satellite companies, and that the unauthorized streams of their signals violate the public performance provision of the Copyright Act.

Popular on Variety

More Digital

  • United Talent Agency Reveals New Logo

    UTA Unveils New Logo, Corporate Image

    UTA raised the curtain Monday on a new corporate logo. The three-dimensional image is meant to emphasize the talent agency’s focus on uniting ideas, opportunities and talent. Building signage with the new logo will go up next month at UTA’s headquarters in Beverly Hills. “Our new identity captures the multiple facets and intersections of our [...]

  • Altice One set-top

    Amazon Prime Video Coming to Altice's Optimum, Suddenlink Cable Services

    Altice USA plans to launch Amazon Prime Video for Optimum and Suddenlink cable customers nationwide in the next few months, under a pact announced Monday. Altice is the third pay-TV operator in the U.S. with a distribution deal for Amazon Prime Video, after Comcast and Cox Communications. The cable operator is adding Prime Video to [...]

  • youtube leanback screenshot

    YouTube to Shut Down Leanback Web TV Interface on October 2

    YouTube is getting ready to retire its TV-optimized browser interface, also known as YouTube Leanback, on October 2, Variety has learned. The move comes as YouTube is putting a bigger emphasis on its native TV apps, but also represents a blow to users who directly connected their PCs to their TVs. YouTube started to inform [...]

  • Terminator: Dark Fate

    Paramount & Adobe Launch ‘Terminator: Dark Fate’ Trailer Remix Contest

    Adobe has teamed up with Paramount Pictures to launch a remix contest for the trailer of “Terminator: Dark Fate,” which is set to debut in theaters November 1. The winner of the contest will get $10,000 as well as a one-year Adobe Creative Cloud membership and a private screening of the movie for up to [...]

  • Gabrielle Carteris

    SAG-AFTRA Urges Gavin Newsom to Sign Law Punishing 'Deep Fake' Videos

    SAG-AFTRA National Executive Director David White is urging Gov. Gavin Newsom to sign legislation that institutes penalties for nonconsensual digital sexually explicit videos, also known as “deep fakes.” The legislation, Assembly Bill 602, targets companies and individuals who create and distribute the videos in California without the consent of the individual being depicted. “We urge Gov. [...]

  • Facebook Portal logo

    Facebook Is Launching a Portal TV Device: Here’s What We Know

    Facebook is getting ready to launch a TV streaming device in time for the holiday season, Variety has been able to confirm with multiple sources familiar with the company’s plans. The new streaming hardware will be part of the company’s Portal family of devices, featuring a camera, and combining video chatting with TV viewing and [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content