‘Crouching Tiger,’ Hidden Agenda: Questioning Netflix’s Movie Motives

The pact announced earlier this week bringing together Netflix, Weinstein Co. and IMAX in support of the sequel to “Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon” is drawing some skeptical glances from analysts.

Citing the boycott that quickly followed the announcement from major theater chains, senior analyst Michael Nathanson of MoffettNathanson questioned whether any other major studio will step up to be one of the several unspecified films Netflix says is part of a slate of upcoming day-and-date releases.

“We are skeptical that any other major movie studio  would be willing to go down this path as it jeopardizes the entire profit model for a successful release by essentially collapsing all windows and eliminating transactional purchases (box office, home video, EST) in favor of a subscription model,” he wrote Wednesday.

But while Nathanson was pessimistic that the “Crouching” sequel would set any kind of precedent, he pointed to Netflix’s experience in the TV business as a reason not to entirely discount the possibility, either.

SEE ALSO: As Theaters Boycott Netflix, Collapsed Windows Seen as Inevitable

Popular on Variety

“As long as none of the major studios break rank, we feel like this Netflix test will ultimately fizzle away just like premium VOD,” Nathanson said. “That said what we learned from the TV side of the business is that Netflix is willing to write big checks to convince its partners to test new strategies.”

Tony Wible of Janney Capital Markets interpreted the deal as marketing-minded considering the domestic exhibitor shutout will severely limit the theatrical distribution. “Essentially, Netflix will get hype for a relatively low cost via a film that will largely only be seen online in the U.S.,” he wrote.

Citing Netflix’s overseas growth, Wible wondered whether the deal was intended more for international strategic reasons.

“Netflix could use this model in foreign markets to get more exclusive content. Film rights are frequently pre-sold into smaller international markets. Studios may welcome another bidder for theatrical distribution rights in these countries, which would allow Netflix to get early access to exclusive content in newer markets without having to wait until the typical pay TV window.”

It seems highly unlikely these savvy companies all collectively possessed enough hubris not to anticipate that all major U.S. exhibitors would circle their wagons, effectively cutting off “Crouching” from domestic theatrical distribution in all but a handful of IMAX-owned theaters. Which essentially means that as far as the U.S. goes, “Crouching” was never really going to get a day-and-date release in the truest sense of the term.

Perhaps Netflix/Weinstein/IMAX envisioned their announcement as their best option for an opening salvo in negotiations to come with exhibitors, akin to how Warner Bros. and AMC eventually arrived at an agreement ahead of the release of “Veronica Mars” earlier this year.

The inevitable next step in this controversy: Netflix publicly complaining about being robbed of the opportunity to let U.S. fans see “Crouching” in theaters, putting exhibitors on the defensive. Netflix effectively raises the point it wants to make in the marketplace about disrupting windows without actually challenging a status quo too difficult at this time to change.

As Wible seems to indicate, just demonstrating its disruptor bona fides to subscribers has value for Netflix even if the company hasn’t achieved its actual goal of rattling Hollywood’s traditional window system.

More Film

  • Charades Scores Flurry of Sales Across

    Charades Scores Flurry of Sales Across Prestige Animation Slate (EXCLUSIVE)

    Charades, the Paris-based sales company behind the Oscar-nominated “I Lost My Body” and “Mirai,” has closed a raft of deals on high-profile animated features, including “Little Nicholas” and “Marona’s Fantastic Tale.” Anca Damian’s “Marona’s Fantastic Tale,” which world premiered in competition at last year’s Annecy Film Festival and was nominated at the European Film Awards, [...]

  • Editorial use only. No book cover

    Federation Entertainment Acquires Alejandro Amenabar’s ‘Thesis’ for Series Adaptation (EXCLUSIVE)

    Paris and Los Angeles-based Federation Entertainment has acquired the TV format and remake rights to Alejandro Amenábar’s debut feature, “Thesis.” It’s a prime example of the value of key older movie titles from standout younger foreign-language auteurs. Producer of “The Bureau,” “Marseille,” “Bad Banks” and “Hostages,” Federation Entertainment will produce a drama series based on [...]

  • European Film Market Berlinale Berlin Film

    Berlin: NL Film, Hupe Film Board 'Life Through a Dead Man's Eyes' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Amsterdam-based NL Film and Hupe Film in Cologne have boarded Jo Baier’s upcoming Nazi war criminal horror thriller “Life Through a Dead Man’s Eyes.” The companies join co-producers Films in Motion (FIM), the Berlin-based shingle run by American producer René Asch, and Angelika Mohr’s Morefilms in Munich, which is also handling world sales. German thesps [...]

  • Luna Nera Netflix Italy

    Italy's Women Filmmakers Set to Make Waves

    The Berlinale in recent years has been a prime launching pad for Italian films directed by women, which though fewer in number to their male counterparts, make up a considerable portion of the country’s representation on the festival circuit — Alice Rohrwacher (“Happy as Lazzaro”) at Cannes, Susanna Nicchiarelli (“Nico”) at Venice, and Berlin regular [...]

  • Bad Tales Italian Cinema

    Italian Programmers and Directors Take on Top Jobs at International Fests

    Though hiring a foreigner to run a national institution such as the Berlinale in Germany is rather rare, it’s been happening to other Italians lately. Carlo Chatrian at Berlin is the most prominent case. But there are several more. In 2018, Italy’s Paolo Moretti, who now heads the Cannes Directors’ Fortnight, became the first non-French [...]

  • Scandinavia's Snowglobe Shows Knack for Auteurs

    Scandinavia's Snowglobe Shows Knack for Auteurs

    One of the hippest, most international Scandinavian companies, the Copenhagen-based Snowglobe, is the 5-year-old banner behind “Wildland,” the female-powered crime film set to world premiere at the Berlinale. Starring Sidse Babett Knudsen (“Borgen”) as a mafia ringleader and introducing Sandra Guldberg Kampp, “Wildland” was written by Ingeborg Topsoe (“The Charmer”) and directed by Jeanette Nordahl. [...]

  • Beyond The Raging Sea

    Mad Solutions/Vox to Release Refugee Doc 'Beyond The Raging Sea' Across MENA (EXCLUSIVE)

    “Beyond the Raging Sea,” an extreme sea adventure documentary aimed at raising awareness of the global refugee crisis, is set for a wide theatrical release across the MENA region via Arab marketing and distribution company Mad Solutions and Middle East exhibitor Vox Cinemas. The deal between the two companies and the International Emerging Film Talent [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content