×

Amazon Fire Phone Panned as Frustrating, Gimmicky by Reviewers

The first reviews of Amazon’s Fire Phone are in, and the technorati are not impressed.

The poor critical reception is a signal that the e-commerce company will face even higher hurdles than previously expected in attempting to challenge Apple’s iPhone, Samsung Electronics’ Android smartphones and other incumbent players.

Reviewers cited the Fire Phone’s limited battery life, absence of key apps, lack of features available in rival products, its ungainly industrial design, and the fact that it works only with AT&T.

In unveiling the smartphone, Amazon touted whizzy new features as delivering a new “immersive” smartphone experience. Those include Dynamic Perspective, a system that uses four cameras to detect where the user is looking to render 3D-like perspectives and gesture controls, and Firefly, which can identify some 100 million items, including songs, movies, TV shows and products (sold by Amazon) using different sensors.

But critics found those gimmicky and not very practical. The phone’s “big new features (were) less useful than I expected, and sometimes outright frustrating,” wrote Re/code’s Walt Mossberg. The Firefly auto-recognition was inconsistent, and navigating using Dynamic Perspective was more difficult than simply swiping the phone, he said.

SEE ALSO: Amazon Unveils Fire Phone, in Bid to Challenge Apple’s iPhone

In addition, the Amazon Fire Phone lacks some key functions both Apple and Samsung smarphones offer, including a fingerprint reader and integrated video calling, Mossberg noted. And while Amazon offers 185,000 apps for the Fire Phone, that’s less than 20% of the apps that run on Apple and Android phones, and doesn’t currently have apps such as YouTube and Google Maps.

The biggest problem with the Amazon Fire Phone was battery life, according to The Wall Street Journal’s Geoffrey Fowler, who noted that like the iPhone the battery cannot be replaced.

“In the past five days, I couldn’t once get the Fire’s battery to last to day’s end — a telephonic cardinal sin,” he wrote. In a battery “torture test” streaming video over Wi-Fi with the screen at 50%, the Fire lasted just 6 hours and 40 minutes, 16% less than the Samsung Galaxy and 25% less than the iPhone, according to Fowler.

Other reviewers also found the smartphone’s hardware performance wanting. “The quad-core Qualcomm Snapdragon 800 processor struggles to respond, battery life sputters out quicker than I’d like, and the phone also throws off enough heat to melt a pat of butter,” CNet’s Jessica Dolcourt said.

Critics also took issue with the Amazon Fire Phone’s design: “It’s a study in ruthless efficiency, without regard for anything so immeasurably subjective as ‘beauty,'” said The Verge’s David Pierce, calling it “a dense black slab” that leaves the impression that the Fire Phone “was well-conceived but never quite perfected.”

Not everyone hated the Fire Phone. The New York Times’ Farhad Manjoo called it “uncommonly friendly and easy to use.”

“As a bare-bones smartphone, it should prove especially attractive to people who find themselves overwhelmed by today’s crop of do-it-all superphones,” Manjoo wrote. “When you forget about its whiz-bang marketing, the Fire begins to stand out as something much more interesting: a phone for the rest of us.”

And consuming media on the Fire Phone is “a better experience than what you get on other platforms,” wrote TechCrunch’s Kyle Russell. People who buy all their digital content from Amazon or subscribe to Prime — which offers unlimited access to libraries of video titles and songs — “might find that the Fire Phone is perfectly capable of meeting all of their needs,” he said. Movies and books are treated as apps on the home screen, and Prime members can download TV episodes for offline viewing.

The Fire Phone is slated to start shipping July 25, exclusively through AT&T, in two configurations: a model with 32 GB of storage for $199.99 and a 64 GB model at $299.99 (both with a two-year contract). Without a contract, the phones are $649 and $749, respectively.

Popular on Variety

More Digital

  • Tycho weather app

    This Website Creates Spotify & Apple Music Playlists Based on Your Local Weather

    Electronica musician Tycho launched a clever promotional website for his new album “Weather” this week: Visitors of Tycho’s website can use a web app to generate a playlist based on their local weather. Playlists can be saved to both Spotify and Apple Music, and consist of 25 songs, both from Tycho’s catalog as well as [...]

  • AT&T TV

    AT&T TV: An Unskinny Streaming Bundle That Looks a Lot Like Traditional Pay TV

    AT&T this week launched AT&T TV, a new subscription streaming television service that uses an Android-based internet set-top, in 10 markets. But the way it’s priced and packaged looks very similar to cable and satellite TV services — in other words, AT&T TV isn’t targeted at the cord-cutter crowd. It’s basically designed as a way [...]

  • Sofia Wylie arrives at Variety's Power

    Disney Channel Enlists Duplass Brothers for YouTube Hip-Hop Dance Series Starring Sofia Wylie

    Disney Channel’s first original scripted series made exclusively for release on YouTube is “Shook,” a hip-hop dance short-form series starring Sofia Wylie, produced by Mark Duplass and Jay Duplass. “Shook” will debut Saturday, Sept. 28, on Disney Channel’s YouTube channel. The scripted single-camera show centers on 15-year-old Mia (Wylie), who yearns to dance professionally but [...]

  • YouTube logo

    YouTube Is Getting Rid of Messaging Feature

    YouTube is killing off a feature that allowed users to share videos and other messages with each other. YouTube Messages, which was first introduced in January of 2017, will be turned off by September 18, the company announced this week. “We’re constantly reevaluating our priorities and have decided to discontinue YouTube’s native direct messaging feature [...]

  • Yara Shahidi

    Audible Teams Up With Big Names as Audio-Only Storytelling Expands

    Hobnobbing with the likes of Reese Witherspoon, Kate McKinnon and Yara Shahidi isn’t typically the gloss applied to the cerebral audiobook set, but Audible is putting the humble audio story through its own movie-makeover montage, inking high-profile development deals with entertainment names like “The Walking Dead” comics creator Skybound Entertainment, Witherspoon’s Hello Sunshine and Lorne [...]

  • Geneva Wasserman

    Condé Nast Taps Film Veteran Geneva Wasserman as SVP of Motion Pictures

    Condé Nast Entertainment hired Geneva Wasserman as senior vice president of motion pictures, overseeing development of the media company’s slate of feature film properties. Wasserman, a nearly 20-year veteran of the entertainment industry, most recently served as co-founder and executive producer of production firm Project Z Entertainment. She takes over the role at CNE after [...]

  • A view of the SK Telecom

    Korean Regulators Approve Four-Way Streaming Merger

    South Korean regulators have approved the merger of the video services of three local broadcasters and SK Telecom’s streaming app Oksusu. The new service, operating under the name Wavve will launch in September and be Korea’s largest. Proposed in January as a measure to combat the incursion of international video players, the deal was given [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content