×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Concept for Live TV On-the-Go Was Around Long Before Aereo

Aereo markets itself with the simple motto, “Watch Live TV Online.”

The technology is new; the concept, not so much.

The mantra for the digital age has been to give consumers what they want, anywhere and anytime they want it.

But when it comes to providing live, mobile streams of broadcast content, history has been erratic and elusive, whether it be due to legal doubts or slow, sluggish investment on the part of stations. There’s also a question of demand, and whether a standalone mobile TV service makes sense in an era of apps.

John Fletcher, analyst for SNL Kagan, notes an Internet Advertising Bureau study that 63% of video viewing on mobile devices is done in the home, meaning that live TV already is readily available on the set.

The presumption, however, is that there would be a natural audience for live TV on the go, particularly for sports, news and weather.

Portable TVs go back decades, to the 1960s, but there was always a problem with them: The reception of those hand-held TVs was always spotty, and they never took off beyond a niche product. 

The Internet changed all that. Once dial-up service started giving way to cable broadband, entrepreneurs started experimenting with the idea of providing broadcast TV to the Web.

Back in 1999, Canadian businessman William Craig launched iCrave TV, a website that offered streaming signals of Canadian and U.S. stations available in Toronto. Broadcasters sued, claiming violation of copyright law, and the service shut down the following year.

Two services tried again in 2010, ivi TV in Seattle and FilmOn in Los Angeles, but they too were shut down in the courts. Ivi had even argued that its streams were legal because it was really an online cable company, but the legal argument didn’t fly.

Aereo’s launch in 2012 was novel because its setup — individually assigned, dime-sized antennas and DVR-like functions to capture live TV signals — was designed to get around legal pitfalls, even if Denny Chin, a dissenting judge in the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals, characterized it as a “Rube Goldberg device.” 

Slingbox, which launched in 2005, also gives consumers the ability to watch live TV online, but its functionality is tied to a user’s cable or satellite subscription. Only recently did a broadcaster challenge its legality — Fox, in a dispute with Dish Network over its Hopper features — and even then, courts seem to be leaning toward upholding the legality of Slingbox’s “place-shifting” features.

Jason Krikorian, co-founder of Sling Media, said that what helped drive its creation was the desire by he and his brother to get access to San Francisco Giants games when they were traveling. “It was content delivered to our homes in sports packages we already subscribed to,” he says. 

He says that they enjoyed a “relatively conflict-free path as a startup.” EchoStar purchased the company in 2007, and one of the more popular mobile TV apps has been Dish’s Sling Player for iPad, according to research firm SNL Kagan.

Yet the prospects for live TV on the go are limited short of being a cable, satellite or telco subscriber. Disney has been the most aggressive among all the media conglomerates in putting its broadcast network shows online, but its WatchABC app provides live streams only after a user authenticates their MVPD subscription.

Broadcasters have obvious reason to slow-go it on simply putting their signals up online: They don’t want to undercut their retransmission consent revenue.

Instead, they have long been pursuing ways to offer mobile TV over their own spectrum, via the ATSC standard.

Among the broadcasters’ ventures is Dyle TV, launched in 2012, which provides broadcast signals in certain markets using a small wireless receiver from Audiovox or a dongle adapter that plugs into a smartphone or tablet and captures the signal.

Stations still have to invest in outfitting their transmitters with mobile capability. So Dyle, which is backed by a consortium of station groups as well as Fox and NBC, is still in somewhat of an early stage, available in about 40 markets. And not all local stations are available in every market. In Los Angeles, for instance, KABC is not among the options.

The advantage is that there is no subscription fee, other than the purchase of a device, nor does the video consumption count against a mobile data plan.

The question, says Salil Dalvi, co-general manager of Dyle TV, is whether “live TV is an important enough part of the video experience that consumers are willing to make an investment.”

“What we are going through at Dyle is really understanding that,” he says, adding that they have “a long ways to go” before they can see if demand is viable.

But the goal is to convince wireless providers, and consumer electronics manufacturers, that they should put a chip in smartphones to capture TV signals. At its launch, Dyle partnered with for its service with MetroPCS Communications to carry Samsung Electronics’ Samsung Galaxy S LightRay, which featured a receiver of the mobile broadcast signal, but the product was discontinued.

“In a chicken and egg environment, the broadcasters can lead,” Dalvi says, adding, “The thing we are competing against is the existing model, and whether the consumer believes their existing experience is good enough.”

Dyle’s prospects may be unclear, but the idea of using broadcast spectrum to transmit mobile TV is the subject of other kinds of experimentation.

According to SNL Kagan, Verizon Wireless and AT&T Mobility have been working on an LTE broadcast standard to handle live events and sports, an answer to the rising amount of mobile data consumption. Sinclair and other stations are working on an ATSC 3.0 broadcast standard that would enable two-way interactivity.

Last week, FCC chairman Tom Wheeler cited some of these developments in a speech to the National Assn. of Broadcasters in Las Vegas. His message was that broadcasters can remake themselves into industry disruptors, via such things as mobile TV and online offerings. But others like Yahoo are looking to offer such things as local news, he said, and “your window of opportunity won’t stay open forever.”

More Biz

  • Obit Obituary Placeholder

    Talent Agent Joseph Eric Rice Dies at 61

    Joseph Eric Rice, a talent agent who headed JR Talent Group, died unexpectedly at his home in Laguna Beach, Calif. He was 61. Rice headed his own talent agency based in Studio City where he primary handled actors. Earlier in his career, he headed the theatrical department at Abrams Artists Agency. Rice was born in [...]

  • Terry Back chairman ACF

    Veteran U.K. Media Investor Terry Back Joins ACF as Chairman

    CANNES — Veteran U.K. film industry investor Terry Back has joined ACF investment bank as chairman. ACF, headed by CEO Thomas Dey, has been at the forefront of the M&A activity around independent TV and film production outfits, mostly in the unscripted TV arena. ACF is in the midst of expanding its activities in the [...]

  • Santos Dumont

    Mipcom: International TV Output Picture Changing for U.S. Majors

    The global import-export strategies of the U.S. majors are in flux as the world’s major content companies gather this week in Cannes for the annual Mipcom market and conference. Disney, WarnerMedia and the other handful of media conglomerates that control the vast majority of the U.S. market are in the midst of a radical transition [...]

  • Jane Fonda Arrested

    Jane Fonda Arrested in D.C. During Climate Change Protest

    Jane Fonda was arrested on Friday in Washington, D.C. during a climate change protest, Variety has confirmed. “Today, the United States Capitol Police arrested 16 individuals for unlawfully demonstrating on the East Front of the U.S. Capitol,” Capitol Police communications director Eva Malecki said in a statement to Variety. She added that all were charged with crowding, [...]

  • Firefighters battle the Saddleridge fire in

    Saddleridge Fire Forces Evacuations, TV Production Shutdowns

    A wind-whipped wildfire has spread across parts of the San Fernando Valley north of Los Angeles and forced evacuations, threatened thousands of homes and closed parts of five major freeways. The Saddleridge fire has prompted mandatory evacuations affecting about 100,000 people between Porter Ranch, Granada Hills and Sylmar. Mandatory evacuations have been called for about [...]

  • amazon-studios

    Amazon Studios Pacts With Howard University for Entertainment Education Program

    Howard University and Amazon Studios have teamed to launch Howard Entertainment, a two-semester program based in Los Angeles that offers Howard students the ability to take courses, network with Amazon industry partners and gain work experience in the entertainment industry. The inaugural program will begin January. The curriculum and immersive experiences will start with academic [...]

  • Remembering Prince

    Prince Estate Slams Trump Campaign for Playing ‘Purple Rain’ at Minneapolis Rally

    The Prince Estate strongly criticized the Trump campaign for playing “Purple Rain” at a Minneapolis rally in which the president made multiple aggressive and juvenile comments about Democratic leaders, Bruce Springsteen, Beyonce and Jay-Z. In a statement posted on social media, the Estate wrote, “President Trump played Prince’s ‘Purple Rain’ tonight at a campaign event [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content