×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

MGM’s Attorney Blasts Universal’s Latest Response to James Bond Lawsuit

Updated

Universal is asserting that MGM is trying to limit competition with its lawsuit claiming that the pending project “Section 6” is a ripoff of the James Bond franchise.

In a court filing on Tuesday, Universal contended that MGM’s goal is “not to prevent the infringement of the James Bond works. They are instead intent on scaring away Universal and any other would-be competitors, thereby gaining a monopoly on the British spy genre.”

But Bobby Schwartz, the attorney representing MGM, said that Universal’s latest response to the lawsuit “is hollow rhetoric from a studio, coming on the heels of a judge rejecting their arguments.”

“There is nothing original or creative about that screenplay,” he said.

U.S. District Judge James Otero last month refused to dismiss MGM’s lawsuit, which it filed in April along with longtime James Bond producer Danjaq. They claim that Universal and screenwriter Aaron Berg are infringing on the 007 franchise, even though “Section 6” is set around the formation of MI6 after World War I.

Otero’s decision was originally sealed, but a redacted version was recently released showing that he found enough similarities between the “Section 6” script and the Bond franchise to warrant keeping the litigation alive. He cited some of the screenplay’s dialogue, specifically in the way that the lead “Section 6” character Alec Duncan and James Bond introduce themselves. “Duncan. Alec Duncan.” and “Bond. James Bond.”

“The similarities are sufficient to give rise to a claim for copyright infringement,” Otero wrote. He cited a previous 1995 court ruling in favor of MGM which sought to stop a Honda commercial featuring a charming British spy character and other elements that suggested, but did not name, Bond. Otero noted that the court ruled back then that “both James Bond movie scenes and the James Bond character were copyrightable because the films were ‘unique in their expression of the spy thriller idea,’ and although James Bond has been portrayed by different actors in different movies, his ‘specific qualities remain constant.'”

“In the current case, ‘Section 6’ bears more similarities than the Honda commercial: Plaintiffs have pointed out many similarities in character, theme, plot, sequence and dialogue,” Otero wrote.

Universal has also argued that the MGM lawsuit is premature as it has not decided whether to make “Section 6.” But Otero wrote that because Universal purchased rights to the screenplay, and has hired various people to develop the project, that amounted to a “transitory” film-making product that made the “copyright issues ripe for review.”

“Universal’s assertion that it does not intend to infringe Plaintiff’s copyright is also irrelevant because good faith is not an excuse for copyright infringement,” he wrote.

Schwartz called on Universal to ask Otero to remove his redactions to disclose the similarities between the script and 007.

Nevertheless, Universal contends that the MGM lawsuit is “antithetical to copyright law, which only protects concrete expression, not abstract ideas, and was never intended to be used as a sword to prevent lawful competition.”

 

More Biz

  • MGM logo

    MGM Television Expands Unscripted Team With Three Hires

    Metro Goldwyn Mayer has announced three additions to its unscripted television team. It is currently led by Barry Poznick, president of the division and Mark Burnett, chairman of MGM’s Worldwide Television Group (“Survivor,” “The Voice”). Justin Dudek has joined MGM as senior VP of physical production, Zena Van Ackeren has onboarded as VP of talent [...]

  • Wanda Sykes Silicon Valleywood

    Wanda Sykes on Doing Business With Netflix: 'They Moved That Comma'

    MENLO PARK, Calif. — Wanda Sykes wears a lot of hats as a comedian, writer, producer and entrepreneur, and that gives her a keen sense of the ever-growing content marketplace. She also has a very clear understanding of what she’s worth in dollars and cents, as she shared Tuesday in her Q&A at Variety’s Silicon [...]

  • Jussie Smollett

    Brothers Accused of Jussie Smollett Attack Sue His Attorneys for Defamation

    The two brothers who allegedly participated in a staged hate attack on Jussie Smollett have filed a defamation suit against Smollett’s lawyers, accusing the attorneys of smearing their reputations in a bid to salvage Smollett’s image. Olabinjo and Abimbola Osundairo filed suit in federal court in Illinois on Tuesday. The suit alleges that Smollett’s attorneys [...]

  • Sylvia Rhone

    Sylvia Rhone Promoted to Chairman & CEO of Epic Records

    Sony Music Entertainment today announced the promotion of Sylvia Rhone to Chairman and CEO of Epic Records. According to the announcement, in this role, Rhone will report to Rob Stringer, CEO, Sony Music Entertainment. She will lead the overall creative direction and management of Epic Records, overseeing a roster of chart-topping artists including Camila Cabello, [...]

  • silicon valleywood Wanda Sykes

    Silicon Valleywood Confab Will Mine Maximum Data Strategies

    As Apple’s recent star-studded event for its new TV streaming service demonstrated, the worlds of entertainment and technology are becoming increasingly intertwined — a convergence Variety will explore during its inaugural Silicon Valleywood Summit on April 23 in Menlo Park. Entertainment leaders will join tech giants on the latter industry’s home turf to discuss how [...]

  • Beyonce Lemonade HBO

    Beyonce’s ‘Lemonade’ Is Finally Available on Spotify and Apple Music

    As exclusively revealed by Variety last week, Beyonce’s ‘Lemonade’ album — which had been exclusively available for streaming on Tidal — is now available across all major streaming services, including Spotify and Apple Music. Upon its release in 2016, sources close to the singer said that the album would be a Tidal exclusive “in perpetuity,” [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content