You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

TV Creators Warn FCC: Don’t Let Internet Become ‘Like Cable Television’

As the FCC prepares new rules of the road for the Internet, more than 240 TV showrunners and creators have signed on to a Writers Guild of America West letter urging the commission to avoid regulations that would allow content companies to pay for speedier delivery to users.

The letter, sent on Tuesday, was the most significant response yet from Hollywood figures as the commission prepares for a key vote on Thursday.

FCC chairman Tom Wheeler outlined a proposal last month that would allow for certain forms of paid prioritization, and it was met by a storm of protest from public interest groups and some Capitol Hill lawmakers who see it as watering down the concept of net neutrality, and opening the door to a two-tiered Internet, in which media conglomerates can pay ISPs for “fast lanes” to consumers.

Wheeler has since revised his proposal, in an effort to prohibit an ISP from slowing non-paying traffic in order to boost the more lucrative fast lanes. But he also is seeking public comment on whether to pursue a stronger form of regulation, that of declaring the Internet a utility and putting it under the same kind of oversight as phone companies.

In the letter, the writers argue that “if Net Neutrality is neutered, the Internet will become like cable television. A few corporate gatekeepers such as Comcast will be allowed to decide what content consumers can access and on what terms. The danger is that blocking, discrimination and paid prioritization could occur.

“This puts decision making and power over the Internet in the hands of the few, especially those with money. The Internet is too vital to the free exchange of ideas to allow the few companies who control Internet technology to edit the ideas and content that flow through it.”

The signers include an array of top showrunners, including John Wells, Matthew Weiner and Howard Gordon. They do not explicitly urge the FCC to pursue regulation that would treat the Internet like a utility, but they note that it has worked “like the phone lines.” Their biggest message is that the Internet has opened up new opportunities for content creators, giving them new options after a wave of media consolidation in the past two decades.

“There are new buyers for what we as writers create. But if this new competition is unfairly pushed aside because the FCC adopts weak rules, rather than allowing consumers to decide what they prefer, neither innovation nor the best interests of society will be served,” the letter says.

There has been a flurry of lobbying of the FCC before Thursday’s meeting, where the commissioners will decide whether to place Wheeler’s proposal out for formal public comment.

Earlier today, the public interest group Free Press released a letter from dozens of artists and musicians in which they argued that allowing for paid prioritization would ultimate shift “power away from individual artists and creators” and interfere “with freedom of speech and expression.” Among those who signed were Mark Ruffalo, Fred Armisen, James Schamus, Michael Stipe and Oliver Stone.

While the backlash against Wheeler’s initial proposal has stirred the creative community, it also appears to have triggered concern among Internet providers that the FCC will respond to the outcry by ultimately pursuing a stronger regulatory hand. Some 28 CEOs from broadband Internet companies urged the commission to pursue a light regulatory touch.

Classifying the Internet as a public utility — called “Title II” in regulatory parlance —  “would greatly distort the future development of, and investment in, tomorrow’s broadband networks and services.” Among those who signed the letter were Comcast CEO Brian Roberts, Time Warner Cable CEO Rob Marcus, AT&T CEO Randall Stephenson and Verizon CEO Lowell McAdam. The complete letter is here.

They warned that under “Title II,” “new service offerings, options and features would be delayed or altogether foregone. Consumers would face less choice, and a less adaptive and responsive Internet. An era of differentiation, innovation and experimentation would be replaced with a series of — Government may I? requests from American entrepreneurs. That cannot be, and must not become, the U.S. Internet of tomorrow.”

The irony is that that last time that the FCC wrote open Internet rules, in 2010, it declined to regulate broadband as a utility and instead pursued a less restrictive approach that nevertheless prohibited Internet providers from blocking or discriminating against certain types of content. Yet Verizon still challenged those rules in court, leading to the D.C. Circuit decision in January in which the most significant parts of the FCC’s open Internet rules were struck down. That is what led to the latest debate as Wheeler pursues a new approach.


More Biz

  • Sony Recorded Music Revenues Dip in

    Sony Recorded Music Revenues Dip in 2018 Earnings Report

    As part of Sony’s earnings report for its 2018 fiscal year (which ended on March 31) the company’s music division showed mixed results, with recorded music revenues dropping around 4.5% to 426.9 billion yen ($3.82 billion) and overall revenue up just 1% to 795 billion yen ($7.2 billion). The company attributed the drop to lower [...]

  • Sony Pictures logo

    Sony Pictures Profits Rise to $489 Million but Music Profits Tumble

    Profits at Sony Pictures rose to $489 million for the financial year running to the end of March 2019. That compares with $376 million in the previous financial year. The pictures division result was achieved despite a fall in revenue. That dropped from $9.13 billion in the preceding financial year to $8.87 billion in the [...]

  • Los Angeles Ballet

    MovieCoin Startup Accused of Reneging on Ballet Gift

    Los Angeles Ballet filed suit against MovieCoin on Thursday, accusing the film finance startup of trying to pay a $200,000 pledge in worthless tokens. MovieCoin was founded in 2017 by producer Christopher Woodrow, the former CEO of Worldview Entertainment and Vendian Entertainment. The company offered the chance to invest in films using a blockchain-based token. [...]

  • CBS Viacom

    CBS and Viacom Move Closer to Merger Talks

    The CBS Corp. board of directors is moving closer to initiating acquisition discussions with Viacom, according to multiple sources close to the situation. The move has been expected for months, although there may still be obstacles on the road to a reunion for the two sides of the Redstone media empire. Price could still be [...]

  • Ken Basin Liz Miller

    Paramount TV Ups Ken Basin to Head Business Affairs, Hires Liz Miller as Production SVP

    Paramount Television announced that Ken Basin has been elevated to head of business affairs for the division, and Liz Miller has been hired as senior vice president of production. David Goldman, the previous head of business affairs, has left the company to pursue other opportunities. Basin will report to Nicole Clemens, the president of Paramount [...]

  • eOne Names Bill Wilson Senior VP

    eOne Names Bill Wilson Senior VP

    Entertainment One (“eOne”) has tapped Bill Wilson as Senior Vice President Digital Operations and Innovation, Music, the company announced today. Wilson will oversee all aspects of digital strategy across the company’s music business, including label service, talent management, music publishing and live entertainment, according to the announcement.  Wilson will be based in New York City and [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content