You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

SAG-AFTRA Defends Rights of Actors in ‘Innocence of Muslims’ Court Brief

SAG-AFTRA and other performers unions are weighing in on a lawsuit in which actress Cindy Lee Garcia’s  is seeking to force YouTube to remove the inflammatory “Innocence of Muslims” video that sparked protests in the Muslim world.

After YouTube refused to remove the “Innocence of Muslims” video, Garcia sought an injunction against the site, claiming that she had a copyright interest in her performance, even though she had only a minor role in the movie.

In an amicus brief filed with the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, the actors unions argue that court precedent has recognized that a performance copyrightable, and that in certain “rare circumstances,” actors can claim a separate copyright to their work. But they are not rendering a judgment on whether Garcia herself has a copyright claim to her brief appearance in the video, other than to note examples where even short performances can be sufficiently original to warrant copyright protection.

Google and other Internet companies have warned that should the 9th Circuit accept Garcia’s rationale, it’ll cripple distributors if they have to obtain clearances from even minor characters in a project.

But in their brief, SAG-AFTRA and other organizations argue that actors “are valued for their performance and the originality they bring for their respective roles. The actors imbue the lines with original expression that conveys emotion and brings the character to life.”

SAG-AFTRA is joined in the brief by the American Federation of Musicians of the United States and Canada, the International Federation of Actors and Actors Equity Assn., along with other organizations.

They cited a 2007 case in which the 9th Circuit used the Pink Panther films as examples of original expression, citing Peter Sellers’ performances along with Henry Mancini’s score and Blake Edwards’ direction. They argue that such a reference “places the actor’s performance at the same level as the composer’s musical work.”

They say that the fears expressed by Google are overwrought because so many performers are hired in an employer-employee relationship, in which an actors work is “made for hire” and they assign a copyright interest to the producer. That employer-employee relationship is recognized in SAG-AFTRA collective bargaining agreements. In other cases, the performer would be a joint author, with each author able to exploit a work non-exclusively.

The actors organizations, however, do not take a position as to whether Garcia’s performance “is properly considered her separately owned copyright or a joint work.” They do note that Garcia was not a SAG-AFTRA member.

The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals has scheduled an en banc hearing on Dec. 15.

Garcia said that she received death threats as the video sparked protests. She said that she was told that she was performing in a movie called “Desert Warrior,” yet the movie’s writer and producer, Mark Basseley Youssef, instead turned it into “Innocence of Muslims,” with her voice dubbed over so that she appeared to be asking, “Is your Mohammed a child molester?”

In a 2-1 ruling, a panel of the 9th Circuit sided with Garcia, with the majority disturbed by the idea that Garcia had no control over how her performance was being used. But last month, the 9th Circuit agreed to rehear the case in an en banc hearing.


More Biz

  • Katie Couric Sheryl Sandberg

    Katie Couric Steamrolls Sheryl Sandberg in Roving Vanity Fair Summit Interview

    Sending a jolt through a luxurious and excessively polite afternoon in Beverly Hills, veteran journalist Katie Couric delivered a relentless series of hardball questions to Facebook chief operating officer Sheryl Sandberg on Tuesday. Speaking in conversation at the sixth annual Vanity Fair New Establishment summit at the Wallis Annenberg Center for the Performing Arts, Couric’s [...]

  • Jussie Smollett

    Judge Refuses to Dismiss Chicago's Lawsuit Against Jussie Smollett

    A federal judge on Tuesday refused to dismiss a lawsuit filed by the City of Chicago, which is seeking to recoup investigative costs from former “Empire” actor Jussie Smollett. Judge Virginia M. Kendall rejected Smollett’s contention that he should not be made to pay $130,000 in police overtime costs, plus $260,000 in damages, because he [...]

  • It Is 'Unlikely’ That PledgeMusic Artists

    It Is 'Unlikely’ That PledgeMusic Artists and Creditors Will Be Paid, Receiver Says

    PledgeMusic, the direct-to-fan marketplace that went out of business earlier this year, was more than $7.4 million in debt when it entered liquidation, and its receiver says it is “unlikely” that artists and others owed money by the company will be paid, according to a report from the bank-appointed receiver. “I do not anticipate that [...]

  • Lori Loughlin

    Lori Loughlin Charged With Bribery in College Admissions Case

    Actress Lori Loughlin and her husband, designer Mossimo Giannulli, were indicted on a charge of conspiring to commit federal programs bribery on Tuesday, in connection with allegations that they paid $500,000 to get their daughters into the University of Southern California. Loughlin and Giannulli already faced charges of conspiring to commit mail fraud and money [...]

  • Gary Newman

    Fox TV Group Alum Gary Newman Joins Attention Capital as Executive Partner

    Former Fox TV Group chairman Gary Newman has joined Attention Capital, the startup venture launched earlier this year by another Fox alumnus, Joe Marchese. Newman and another media biz veteran, Lisa Gersh, were named Tuesday as executive partners of Attention Capital. Newman will focus on acquisition and investment opportunities. Marchese, who previously headed advertising sales [...]

  • Clio-Brand-Storytelling-Award

    Clio Awards, Brand Storytelling Team to Launch 'Storytelling for Good' Award

    Clio, the international advertising awards competition, announced Clio Brand Storytelling, a new program in partnership with Brand Storytelling, a media company exclusively built to support and inspire investment in the practice of brand-funded content. The inaugural Storytelling for Good Award will celebrate branded entertainment and content that promotes or creates awareness for a cause, foundation, [...]

  • Matt Lauer Kurt Sutter

    From Sutter to Lauer, Hollywood Sees a Flurry of Letters From the Edge (Column)

    Let’s talk about the whacked-out letters that hit the media sphere in the past eight days. One was that bizarre mea culpa dropped Oct. 17 by the no-holds-barred showrunner Kurt Sutter in response to getting canned from his series “Mayans MC.” No stranger to complaints of unprofessional behavior on his sets over the years, Sutter [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content