You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Netflix, Facebook, Twitter Voice Support for Google in ‘Innocence of Muslims’ Case

Netflix, Facebook and Twitter are among the companies siding with Google as it defends itself against an actress’ effort to force YouTube to remove the inflammatory “Innocence of Muslims” video that sparked protests in the Muslim world.

The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals has scheduled an en banc hearing on Dec. 15 in actress Cindy Lee Garcia’s lawsuit to obtain an injunction against YouTube. She claimed that she had a copyright interest in her performance, even though she had only a minor role in the movie, and that YouTube didn’t have her permission to have it posted on their site.

Garcia said that she received death threats as the video sparked protests. She said that she was told that she was performing in a movie called “Desert Warrior,” yet the movie’s writer and producer, Mark Basseley Youssef, instead turned it into “Innocence of Muslims,” with her voice dubbed over so that she appeared to be asking, “Is your Mohammed a child molester?”

But in an amicus brief filed earlier this week, Netflix warned that, were the court to accept Garcia’s legal rationale, “licensed distributors such as Netflix face the threat of costly suits seeking injunctions preventing those legitimate distributors from exhibiting films and television shows to millions of consumers.”

Netflix argues that Garcia’s rationale turns the concept of joint authorship on its head. A joint author has no power to prevent the other author from licensing their work, but is entitled only to an accounting of his or her share of the proceeds.

“Under Ms. Garcia’s unfixed, non-joint author view of copyright, however, any actress or background singer or spear carrier is granted veto power over the use of copyrighted works — including, as sought in this case, outright injunctions against their performance, distribution or reproduction — far beyond the rights afforded either a coauthor of a joint work,” Netflix’s attorneys, Michael H. Page and Joseph Gratz, wrote. “It is a view of copyright law under which Keith Richard cannot enjoin Mick Jagger’s use of ‘You Can’t Always Get What You Want’ in a car commercial, but any member of the boys’ choir in the background can.”

Facebook, Gawker Media, Twitter, Tumblr and Yahoo were among the other companies who signed on to briefs siding with Google. Film Independent, the Intl. Documentary Assn., Fredrik Gertten and Morgan Spurlock also lent their names to an amicus brief, noting that Garcia “was seriously harmed by a filmmaker who recklessly ignored her safety. But, in response, she urges this court to create unprecedented standards detrimental for the rest of us.”

In a 2-1 ruling, a panel of the 9th Circuit sided with Garcia, with the majority disturbed by the idea that Garcia had no control over how her performance was being used. But earlier this month, the 9th Circuit agreed to rehear the case in an en banc hearing.

Public Citizen filed an amicus brief siding with neither Google nor Garcia. They argued that Garcia should pursue claims in state court against the filmmakers rather than federal copyright claims.

More Biz

  • Ari Emanuel Endeavor

    Endeavor IPO Filing Offers Details of Company's Financials, Leadership Pay Packages

    Endeavor’s IPO filing Thursday offers a hard look at the company’s financial performance during the past three years during a period of rapid growth for the company that’s home to UFC, WME, Professional Bull Riders and a clutch of other assets. Endeavor is generating solid free cash flow from operations and healthy adjusted earnings for [...]

  • Pamela Anderson

    Pamela Anderson Fears Julian Assange 'Won't Survive' Extradition to U.S.

    After previously speaking out in support of her friend and WikiLeaks founder, Julian Assange, Pamela Anderson doesn’t think he would survive an extradition from the U.K. to the U.S. “I hope he gets out of there, but I don’t think he’ll survive extradition. It can’t happen. It’s not even an option. We can’t have him [...]

  • Jane Austin SAG AFTRA

    SAG-AFTRA Secretary-Treasurer Jane Austin Running for President

    Jane Austin, the National Secretary-Treasurer of SAG-AFTRA, has become the third candidate for the presidency of the performers union, joining incumbent Gabrielle Carteris and Matthew Modine. Austin is running as an independent for the top post at SAG-AFTRA, which has 160,000 members. Carteris will seek re-election as the head of the ticket for the Unite [...]

  • Endeavor

    Endeavor Group Holdings Files for Initial Public Offering

    Endeavor Group Holdings, the parent company of talent agency WME, has filed to go public in a development that has long been expected. The company, which filed a Form S-1 with the Securities and Exchange Commission on Thursday, plans to list on the New York Stock Exchange under the ticker “EDR.” The number of shares [...]

  • Lisbeth R Barron Investment Banker

    Investment Banker Lisbeth R. Barron on How She Became a Broadway Deal Specialist

    If you want to get a deal done on Broadway, call Lisbeth R. Barron. Barron is a veteran investment banker who launched her own shingle, Barron Intl. Group, in 2015. She has brokered a slew of deals throughout her career — which has included stops at S.G. Warburg and Bear Stearns — involving companies and [...]

  • The Prom Broadway

    'The Prom': How the Little Show That Could Found Its Way to the Tonys Dance

    Does a Broadway musical still count as an underdog if it’s got über-producer Ryan Murphy in its corner? It does if it’s “The Prom,” the labor of love from a team of Broadway veterans that’s carving out a place for itself as an original story on a street full of familiar titles and well-known brands. [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content