×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Is Disney’s Big-Game Hunting Paying Off?

Acquisition of Maker Studios is Mouse House's latest high-profile purchase in the Iger era

Compared with the sizable acquisitions Disney CEO Bob Iger has made in the past, his $500 million-plus payout for Maker Studios last week seems downright thrifty. But the purchase not only moved Disney-watchers to question Maker’s value, it also had them asking whether the extended shopping spree that has defined the Iger era is the best strategy for a media conglomerate.

Since 2005, Disney has spent more than $18 billion on acquisitions, including Pixar ($7.4 billion), Marvel Entertainment ($4 billion) and Lucasfilm ($4 billion) — an amount far greater than any of its rivals.

Those additions have delivered north of $12 billion in shareholder value to date, according to Tuna Amobi, senior media and entertainment equity analyst S&P Capital IQ. “Under Bob Iger, Disney has been very, very disciplined about acquisitions,” he said.

But some analysts were baffled by the Maker takeover. Gabelli & Co.’s Brett Harriss said Disney is overpaying to play in the unproven world of multichannel networks (MCNs), most of which have failed to make money even from billions of eyeballs. “It’s a total head-scratcher,” he added. “Think about how many writers and producers you could buy with a billion dollars.”

Several of Iger’s other digital acquisitions have done little to boost the bottom line at Disney, most notably social-game firm Playdom (for which it paid $563 million) and Club Penguin ($350 million). “The overall track record of new-media company integrations by big-media buyers is pretty poor,” Cowen & Co. analyst Doug Creutz observed, citing MySpace, which News Corp. bought in 2005 for $580 million and sold six years later for $35 million. “We are not convinced Maker will be able to maintain its success now that it is part of a large bureaucratic organization.”

Perhaps to allay concerns, Disney for now plans to keep Maker as a standalone unit, with Ynon Kreiz, the multichannel network’s exec chairman and CEO, reporting to Disney chief financial officer Jay Rasulo, instead of to the struggling Disney Interactive unit where some of the previous disappointing acquisitions currently sit.

But can Maker, which has yet to be profitable, do any better? Disney intends to use the firm’s 5.5 billion monthly views as way to promote and distribute the Mouse House’s own projects, and incubate new content and talent through the MCN for potential TV shows or movies. “With our younger, millennial audience growing on YouTube — and Maker is the obvious leader (in the multichannel space) — that will create a lot of value,” said Kevin Mayer, Disney’s exec VP of corporate strategy and business development.

Amobi conceded the move is risky, adding he was surprised at the size of the deal — $500 million up front, plus up to $450 million more if the MCN hits performance targets. But, he added, “All it would take is to launch a billion-dollar franchise through Maker and it would pay for itself.”

Other traditional entertainment firms, including Warner Bros. and Chernin Group, have taken a much more cautious approach to the MCN space by making investments instead of going all-in like Disney. “Time Warner put $25 million in Maker,” Harriss noted. “That seems the scale at which you’d want to invest in these unproven models.”

Also last week, Collective Digital Studio, an MCN with franchises that include “Video Game High School” and “The Annoying Orange,” said that German broadcasting giant ProSiebenSat.1 had taken a 20% stake in the company with an eight-figure investment, according to Michael Green, chairman of CDS.

Said Peter Csathy, CEO of Manatt Digital Media Ventures: “(MCNs are) now top-of-mind for all the major studios. There will certainly be a flurry of M&A activity in the next 12-18 months.”

Fullscreen, a major MCN like Maker, with investors that include Chernin Group, Comcast Ventures and global ad agency WPP, is not publicly entertaining major studio suitors, according to CEO George Strompolos. However, he said, the MCN does see value in combining with a large, well-heeled player like Disney — and the two companies will certainly be involved in projects together, even without fiduciary ties.

“There is something to be said for ‘upstreaming’ the best creators, the best intellectual property into more of the avenues that traditional media (offers),” Strompolos said, in an interview prior to Disney announcing the Maker acquisition. “We see a lot of promise there in years to come.”

It’s worth noting that the Maker deal, while not pocket change, is not a bet-the-farm accord. Disney generated $45 billion in revenue for fiscal 2013, and had $4.4 billion in cash and equivalents at the end of 2013. And, given Maker’s scale and relatively low fixed costs, the  purchase is unlikely to be a significant drag on Disney’s free cash flow.

But Daniel Leff, managing director of Luminari Capital, a small fund focused on digital video investments, believes acquisitions can’t be measured just by dollars in the brave new world Maker represents. “Large media companies have not participated in this form of content creation and distribution heretofore,” Leff said. “Disney needs access to that innovation.”

Susanne Ault contributed to this report.

More Biz

  • Deborah Dugan

    Reports of Ousted Grammy Chief Demanding $22 Million Are 'Outrageous,' Sources Say

    UPDATED: As the war of words between the Recording Academy and ousted president/CEO Deborah Dugan continues to escalate, interim boss Harvey Mason Jr. today issued a statement to the Academy’s membership about Dugan’s alleged misconduct and warned about “leaks and misinformation.” The letter claims that Dugan’s attorney Bryan Freedman sought “millions of dollars” for his [...]

  • Frontrunners Emerge As BBC's Tony Hall

    Frontrunners Emerge as BBC Boss Tony Hall Set to Leave Broadcasting Behind

    As the U.K. industry reacts to news of Tony Hall’s intention to depart the BBC this July, top-level executives including Charlotte Moore and Tim Davie as well as external contenders such as Channel 4’s Alex Mahon are beginning to emerge. Variety understands that Lord Hall, who has headed the BBC for seven years as director [...]

  • Recording Academy President/CEO Deborah Dugan participates

    Executive Assistant Preparing Lawsuit Against Ousted Grammy Chief

    In the latest twist in the increasingly bitter exit of Deborah Dugan from the Recording Academy after just five months, the ousted president/CEO is about to face a lawsuit from her former assistant, Claudine Little, who has retained former Harvey Weinstein/ Charlie Walk attorney Patty Glaser to represent her, two sources tell Variety. The news was [...]

  • Two Rivers Media Buys Out Parent

    Two Rivers Media Buys Out Parent Kew Media Group's Stake In Business

    Two Rivers Media has bought out parent group Kew Media Group’s minority stake in the business. Formed by former STV Productions head Alan Clements in January 2019, the production outfit behind Channel 5’s recent “Susan Hill’s Ghost Story” launched with the backing of Kew, Noble Grossart Investments and Channel 4’s Indie Growth Fund. Noble Grossart [...]

  • Grammy Awards 60th Annual Grammy Awards,

    Recording Academy Paid Millions Annually to Outside Law Firms

    Among the concerns listed in a memo sent to the Recording Academy’s head of HR by president/CEO Deborah Dugan before she was placed on administrative leave Thursday was an item about the organization’s “exorbitant and unnecessary” legal fees to outside law firms, according to sources familiar with the document. According to the most recent 990 [...]

  • Chuck D of Public EnemyGods of

    Public Enemy’s Chuck D Slams Grammys Over Deborah Dugan Ouster

    Chuck D, frontman of Public Enemy — who are receiving the Lifetime Achievement Awards at the Grammys next week — posted a long statement on Instagram criticizing the Recording Academy over its sudden ousting of new president/CEO Deborah Dugan yesterday. Dugan, who had been in the job only five months, was placed on administrative leave after [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content