Combat as spectator sport?

“There’s more to football than the violence, but the violent nature contributes to its appeal.”

Steve James is an award-winning filmmaker whose pics include “Hoop Dreams” and “The Interrupters.” His latest doc, “Head Games,” investigates the debilitating health issues behind head injuries not only in football but also in other sports. James talked to Variety’s Carole Horst about sports violence as entertainment. 

I don’t think it’s an accident that football is the religion of America — not just the sports religion, but the religion. That’s due in part to its violence. It’s taken over from boxing, and you don’t have to go back too far to when boxing was the preeminent sport in the world — Muhammad Ali, Joe Lewis, the heavyweight champion of the world was the most recognized face in the world.

There is a link between the violence and popularity of the NFL, although I think football is less blatantly violent than boxing.

There’s more to football than the violence, but its violent nature contributes to its appeal.

I’m not an expert but the birth of competitive sports was to give warriors a way to compete without killing each other in combat. The very nature of sports is war by any other means.

In “Head Games,” the brother of Penn football player Owen Thomas, who committed suicide, says football is the closest thing to war without going to war.

There’s something in that statement in that it’s both greatly appealing to those that play it and those that watch it. It’s greatly appealing to the players who play through the pain, the blood.

It’s America being America — just look at its history. The way this country came in to being was through violence and subjugation. That doesn’t go away with the frontier — it gets translated to other arenas. Mixed martial arts is one of the fastest-growing sports in America and when its governing body introduced more rules, they pushed it into another direction to make it a sport and not some bloodlust activity. That’s how “legitimate” sports manage to attain the essential violence that makes it appealing.

The nonviolent Canadians are the reason that fighting has not left hockey. It is such an important part of Canadian hockey history. The NHL feels they’re going to lose or alienate fans if they get rid of it.

We are becoming a less violent society — statistics show that violent crime has been dropping for years — and the less violence in a society the greater the fulfillment of that desire, and sports becomes more important because it provides a socially acceptable outlet for violence.

As I was editing “Head Games,” as I was going though it frame by frame, the expressions of the people in stands during hockey fights really leapt out at me. Some have fire in their eyes, thinking, “I’m the luckiest guy in the world because this fight is happening right in front of me,” and the person next to him is horrified.

It’s a great metaphor: When these real-life violent incidents happen like Sandy Hook, it allows us to step back and reflect on it. But we’ll go back to the movies and play the videogames and watch the sports that give us a safer version of that violence and we’ll enjoy it.

Popular on Variety

More Voices

  • "The Stockholm Syndrome" - Pictured: Rajesh

    Emmys: Is It Time to Give Multicams Their Own Category? (Column)

    The question of whether multi-camera sitcoms are a dying breed isn’t a new one. The few remaining purveyors of the format, including “The Big Bang Theory” executive producer Chuck Lorre, have been asked that question for years. But even as Lorre ventures into the single-camera world with such shows as the Golden Globe-winning “The Kominsky [...]

  • Veep HBO

    Celebrating Julia Louis-Dreyfus, Emmy's Comedy Queen (Column)

    Let’s take a moment to give Julia Louis-Dreyfus some much-deserved praise. As HBO’s “Veep” ends its run — and aims to add a coda to its already amazing haul over the years at the Emmys — the actress is poised to make history one more time this September. All signs point to another win in [...]

  • Emma Watson MTV Movie Awards

    It's Time for the Emmys to Eliminate Gender-Specific Acting Categories (Column)

    As TV and storytelling continue to evolve, does it still make sense to silo male and female performers into separate Emmy categories? Splitting up “outstanding actor” and “outstanding actress” awards as if they’re different skill sets seems like an outdated practice — yet combining them, and eliminating half of the key acting Emmys in the [...]

  • The Good Place NBC

    Broadcasters Committed to Emmy Telecast Despite Cable, Streaming Dominance (Column)

    Here’s what you won’t see much of at the Primetime Emmy Awards on Fox: Fox.  It’s Fox’s turn to telecast the ceremony, yet it’s a somewhat bittersweet affair for the network, which only landed 18 nominations this year. That means few Fox stars will even be in attendance at the Microsoft Theater, let alone onstage, [...]

  • Eugene Levy Schitts Creek

    Emmy Nods to Veteran Actors Prove Importance of Longevity (Column)

    Despite some well-documented snubs, Television Academy members did a great job with this year’s Emmy nominations when it came to recognizing new series, such as FX’s “Pose” and Netflix’s “Russian Doll,” as well as rising talent including Anthony Carrigan (HBO’s “Barry”), Joey King (Hulu’s “The Act”) and Billy Porter (“Pose”). That spotlight on fresh series [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content