TV Review: ‘Does Someone Have to Go?’

Fox reality show distastefully explores letting employees choose a colleague to fire

Despite its popularity in basic-cable environs from Bravo to Spike, the business-makeover genre has a mixed track record on broadcast networks. Fox seeks to bring its reality brand to the format by framing its latest summer fill-in “Does Someone Have to Go?” as an ostensibly relatable speculative proposition: If given the chance to ax someone around the office, who would you pick? The employees spend a lot of time agonizing over the choice, amid a show that insists, “The stakes are real.” Perhaps so, but cloaked in all the customary, heavily dramatized trappings, it ultimately feels like “Survivor: Dunder Mifflin.”

As with some of Fox’s other summer shows, such as Gordon Ramsay’s “Hotel Hell,” the program makes a somewhat greedy misstep by seeking to spread the drama surrounding each of the three companies to be featured over two parts, beginning with Illinois-based Velocity Merchant Services. While that provides more time to get acquainted with the people involved, it also creates the need to stretch their “Oh this is so tense” banter to the point of flabbiness.

Family run, VMS’ husband-and-wife owners inform their employees that they will be empowered to select three people for potential termination. Along the way, the staff is treated to taped interviews conducted with each of them bad-mouthing colleagues, and (in the most uncomfortable segment) a slide show detailing everyone’s salary. (How all of this cleared legal is anyone’s guess, but one suspects the usual reality-show waiver, already voluminous, was phone-book-sized in this case.)

The main issue, which isn’t necessarily detrimental from a promotional standpoint, is the inherent distastefulness of turning someone’s dismissal — especially in this economy — into entertainment. “This isn’t a gameshow,” one of the employees notes. “We’re messing with people’s livelihood.”

Yet gameshows have always been aspirational, offering ordinary people the chance to win something fabulous. Here, the idea is to threaten taking away someone’s job, which — while obviously designed to tap into apprehensions about high unemployment — sounds like a George Carlin joke run amok.

Indeed, everything about “Does Someone Have to Go?” quickly dispenses with any notion this is an “experiment,” as advertised, and rather screams TV elimination game — from the urgent music to the prolonged voting process (determining who’s “safe”) to the art-deco, “Mad Men”-style opening titles. Moreover, each employee is introduced with an onscreen label — as in Shawn (the Jerk) or Zoe (the Slacker) — intended to reduce them to handy stereotypes.

Thanks to the editing it’s easy to be misled regarding the participants’ stated agony, and since the premiere doesn’t provide much resolution, we still don’t know if the underlying question “Does Someone Have to Go?” will be answered in the affirmative. Taken at face value, though, while the premise hardly plumbs new depths for the genre, it doesn’t set the limbo bar especially high either. From a critic’s perspective, the main down side when reviewing a show so obviously intended to provoke hostility is one suspects such slings and arrows are privately welcomed, hoping righteous outrage will inspire people to see what triggered all the fuss.

“I feel like I’m watching people get beheaded,” one woman mutters as the salaries of her co-workers flash by.

Hey, if this doesn’t work, maybe next time.

TV Review: 'Does Someone Have to Go?'

(Series; Fox, Thur. May 23, 9 p.m.)

Production: Produced by 51 Minds and Endemol USA.

Crew: Executive producers, Cris Abrego, Fernando Mills; co-executive producer, Scott Teti; supervising producers, Jack Cannon, Juliana Kim, Michelle Brando; senior producer, Eric Rudnick; supervising story producer, Arjen Van Eijmeren; supervising editors, H.A. Arnarson, Jeannie Gilgenberg; camera, Timothy Baker. 60 MIN.

More TV

  • Emilia Clarke Actors on Actors 2019

    Watch Emilia Clarke, Billy Porter And More 2019 Emmy Nominees on Variety's 'Actors on Actors'

    What did Emmy nominee Billy Porter from “Pose” learn about women from co-nominee Rachel Brosnahan on “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel?” What does Michael Douglas respect the most about Benicio del Toro’s acting ability? And how does Maya Rudolph’s recent meditations on the afterlife in the “The Good Place” coincide with the conversations Natasha Lyonne’s thoughts [...]

  • Russian Doll

    2019 Emmy Nominations Did Right by a Great Year in Comedy (Column)

    Even before the 2019 Emmy nominations were announced, the biggest and most obvious story belonged to the fact that last year’s drama nominees almost completely cleared the way for the final season of “Game of Thrones.” But for as weak as the drama categories are overall (give or take a “Pose”), the comedy categories have [...]

  • Big Little Lies Stranger Things

    Here's Why 'Big Little Lies' and 'Stranger Things' Weren't Nominated for 2019 Emmys

    Meryl Streep joined “Big Little Lies” this season, and “Stranger Things” broke a Netflix record — so why didn’t either show score an Emmy nomination? Every year, critically acclaimed and fan-favorite shows are noticeably omitted from the Emmy nominations, but not because they were snubbed. It’s because they’re not eligible.  This year, ineligible series include [...]

  • Game of Thrones Finale

    'Game of Thrones' Emmy Love Confounds the Show's Critics (Column)

    Today’s widespread Emmy recognition for “Game of Thrones” — now the most-Emmy-nominated series for a single season, a record that it seems odd the heavily-decorated drama didn’t already have — comes in most senses as no surprise. This series is both an awards favorite, having won the top prize at the ceremony for its last [...]

  • Elisabeth Moss Handmaid's Tale

    Emmys 2019: Writing, Directing Nominations Far From Parity

    While big name television writers and directors including Amy Sherman-Palladino and Ava DuVernay saw Emmy nominations this year, overall, the state of parity in such behind-the-scenes nods is far from being achieved. Looking closely at the directing fields for scripted series this year, the drama category is 75% male and 25% female nominees, while the [...]

  • Emmy Queen Bey? Beyonce's 'Homecoming' Lands

    Beyoncé's 'Homecoming' Documentary Lands Six Emmy Nominations

    It’s going to be a busy awards season for Beyonce. She could be up for Grammys or Oscars in the next six months, but she’s already made a splash with the fresh crop of Emmy nominations. Her documentary/concert movie “Homecoming: A Film by Beyoncé” has been nominated for six Emmys, and a win in most [...]

  • Astronomy Club

    Astronomy Club Sets Netflix Sketch Comedy Series With Kenya Barris Producing (EXCLUSIVE)

    The sketch and improv group Astronomy Club has landed a self-titled variety sketch series at Netflix, Variety has learned exclusively. The streamer has given the half-hour series a six episode order. Kenya Barris will executive produce under his Khalabo Ink Society banner at Netflix, with the show falling under the “Black-ish” creator’s overall deal. Daniel [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content