Brooding BBC America drama recalls 'The Killing,' but doesn't equal Brits' best crime fare

David Tennant, Olivia Colman, Andrew Buchan, Jodie Whittaker, Vicky McClure, Arthur Darvill, Pauline Quirke, Will Mellor, Carolyn Pickles, Matthew Gravelle, Simone McAullay, Jonathan Bailey, Oskar McNamara, Charlotte Beaumont, Susan Brown, Adam Wilson, Joe Sims, David Bradley, Jacob Anderson.

Brooding and gloomy, “Broadchurch” is a grudgingly effective crime drama — managing to pull viewers through its grinding, “The Killing”-like paces even as its plethora of cop-drama cliches become increasingly aggravating and enervating. Like a lot of small towns on TV, this one is not what it seems, requiring only the shocking death of a young boy to scratch the surface and unleash all sorts of dark and sordid secrets. Although the Brits have developed a well-deserved reputation for gritty crime, this eight-part BBC America offering is a couple of notches below its best.

Created by Chris Chibnall (whose credits include the U.K. version of “Law & Order” and “Torchwood”), “Broadchurch” derives its name from the seaside community where 11-year-old Danny Latimer meets his grim end.

Much like “The Killing,” the multipronged plot focuses on his grieving family, journalists seeking a big break and, of course, two mismatched police investigators: newcomer Alec Hardy (David Tennant), who harbors secrets of his own; and the local cop passed over when he got the job, Ellie (Olivia Colman), whose role in the case is complicated by the facts she knows the dead boy’s family and has a son the same age.

The results are often visually striking, from the mesmerizing rows of identical housing to the sweeping coastal views. It’s only too bad the series doesn’t have more flair in terms of its narrative properties. Indeed, it would be nice just once to meet a new cop who wasn’t sporting a three-day-old beard and scars from a recent case that people keep referencing or who didn’t experience seizures at inconvenient moments. And the use of slow motion is as tedious as it is manipulative.

SEE ALSO: Fox Orders Brit Crime Drama ‘Broadchurch’ to Series

Yet even with those gripes, the story does drag the audience along, creating suspicions surrounding one character after another, and using the pain and loss of a single death to probe their individual stories. Part of that interest has to do with the strength of the cast, including Andrew Buchan and Jodie Whittaker as Danny’s parents.

This latest iteration on the protracted crime drama — teasing one investigation over an extended stretch, as opposed to the tidy resolutions of U.S. procedurals — also lends itself well to a European model consisting of shorter series orders, since it’s difficult to imagine something like “Broadchurch” being extended even a week longer. (Just witness the ruckus AMC’s adaptation of “The Killing” unleashed when it didn’t provide closure in season one.)

While the show’s payoff is likely to strike many as strained and unsatisfying, as well as disturbing, its raison d’etre is as much about the atmospherics and the getting there, with the twists trumping the actual whodunit.

“Who killed Danny Latimer?” won’t resonate like Laura Palmer, or even Rosie Larsen. But like Tennant’s dogged cop, those who commit to “Broadchurch” probably won’t want to give up on the investigation until they finally know who did.


(Series; Wed. Aug. 7, 10 p.m.)

Production: Produced by Kudos and Imaginary Friends, and distributed by Shine Intl.

Crew: Executive producers, Chris Chibnall, Jane Featherstone; producer, Richard Stokes; directors, James Strong, Euros Lyn; writer, Chibnall; camera, Matt Gray; production designer, Catrin Meredydd; editor, Mike Jones; music, Olafur Arnalds; casting, Kelly Valentine Hendry, Victory Jenkins. 60 MIN.

Cast: David Tennant, Olivia Colman, Andrew Buchan, Jodie Whittaker, Vicky McClure, Arthur Darvill, Pauline Quirke, Will Mellor, Carolyn Pickles, Matthew Gravelle, Simone McAullay, Jonathan Bailey, Oskar McNamara, Charlotte Beaumont, Susan Brown, Adam Wilson, Joe Sims, David Bradley, Jacob Anderson.

More TV

  • Bong Joon Ho 'Parasite' Director

    Listen: Who Will Take Home the Oscars for Best Director and Picture?

    The Oscars are just two weeks away, so it’s time to start making final predictions about who is going to win. On this week’s episode of “The Big Ticket,” Variety and iHeart’s movie podcast, I invited the magazine’s deputy awards and features editor (and my “Pick of the Week” co-host) Jenelle Riley onto the show [...]

  • Dazzler, Tigra, Hit-Monkey, and M.O.D.O.K.

    'Howard the Duck,' 'Tigra & Dazzler' Animated Marvel Shows Not Moving Forward at Hulu

    Marvel Television’s remaining slate continues to dwindle. Variety has confirmed that the animated shows “Howard the Duck” and “Tigra & Dazzler” — two of four animated Marvel projects set up at Hulu — are no longer in the works at the streamer. The other two shows, “M.O.D.O.K” and “Hit Monkey,” are currently still on track [...]

  • Star Wars Obi-Wan Kenobi movie

    After 'Star Wars' Obi-Wan Kenobi Delay, Is the Force Still Strong With Disney Plus?

    The issues on Disney Plus’ Obi-Wan Kenobi series are either a minor stumble or a portent of trouble ahead, depending on who you ask. It was reported on Thursday that series writer Hossein Amini was no longer attached to the project as Disney wished to overhaul the scripts. The move led to pre-production in London [...]

  • The unboxing teaser

    TV News Roundup: HBO Releases 'The Undoing' Teaser

    In today’s TV news roundup, HBO released a teaser for “The Undoing” and Showtime dropped a trailer for “The Trade” Season 2. FIRST LOOKS HBO released a teaser for its forthcoming limited series “The Undoing,“ which will premiere in May. The six-part series based on the novel “You Should Have Known” by Jean Hanff Korelitz, [...]

  • Sean Hannity

    Sean Hannity Set for Super Bowl Pre-Game Interview With President Trump

    Sean Hannity has talked with President Donald Trump many times, but never quite like this. Hannity is the latest TV-news personality to take on what has in recent years developed into a Super Bowl Sunday tradition: a pre-game interview with the President of the United States. Savannah Guthrie, Gayle King and Bill O’Reilly are among [...]

  • CBS Orders Comedy Pilot From '9JKL'

    CBS Orders Comedy Pilot From '9JKL' Creator, Comedian James Acaster

    CBS is developing a project that takes a comedic look at the age-old “12 Angry Men” dilemma of how does a jury come to a unanimous verdict? The network has issued a pilot order for “We The Jury,” a hybrid series from “9JKL” co-creator Dana Klein and Stephanie Darrow. The project hails from CBS Television [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content