Upfronts: What Are New Shows’ Chances for Survival?

One in three new shows earns renewal

So now that the major broadcast networks have announced which new scripted shows will grace their fall schedules, what are their prospects?

If the past four years are any indication, about 33% of scripted series will make it to a second season, 25% to a third season and 20% to a fourth.

According to research by Variety and Variety Insight, of the 135 primetime scripted series ordered by ABC, CBS, Fox and NBC since the May 2009 upfronts, exactly one-third — 45 — earned season-two renewals (with one, NBC’s “Hannibal,” legitimately awaiting resolution of its fate).

Depending on your perspective, that doesn’t seem like a bad batting average — and it’s fairly consistent across the networks, no matter how many shows they ordered. Fairing the best over the past four years were Fox series (10 for 27, 37.0%), while the worst were CBS freshmen (8 for 26, 30.8%), but the percentage difference is fairly negligible. The success rate for ABC (14 for 40, 35.0%) and NBC (13.5 for 42, 33.7%), which ordered the most shows, fell in range.

The best single season for any network since 2009 was ABC’s 2011-12, when it greenlit 12 new shows and renewed six for sophomore seasons: “Don’t Trust the B,” “Last Man Standing,” “Once Upon a Time,” “Revenge,” “Scandal” and “Suburgatory.” Five of those programs remain alive today, with “Scandal” emerging as a bonafide hit and “Once Upon a Time” strong enough to spawn a 2013-14 spinoff, “Once Upon a Time in Wonderland.”

This past season appears to have been pretty rough for new skeins on NBC, with only two survivors out of 12, “Chicago Fire” and “Revolution” — though “Chicago Fire” also generated a spinoff in “Chicago PD,” and “Hannibal” could still make things respectable. The real backbreaker for the Peacock was 2010-11, when 12 freshmen took to the air, one (“Harry’s Law”) made it to season two and none to season three.

ABC has more new 2011-12 series alive today than the other three networks combined. The lone Fox survivor that debuted that season is “New Girl,” while for NBC it’s (appropriately) “Grimm.” Of the seven CBS shows that premiered in 2011-12, only “Person of Interest” is on its 2013-14 schedule, though “Unforgettable” rose from the dead to earn a second season as a summer series beginning in late July, nearly 18 months after it was supposedly canceled.

In total, 27.6% of the 39 2011-12 premieres appear three seasons later on 2013-14 schedules for the big four networks. An almost identical 26.9% of 2010-11 premieres and 27.5% of 2009-10 premieres reached at least season three.

What about four seasons? The recent figures show more variance. While 24.1% of 2009-10 shows made it to a fourth season, merely 13.9% of shows born the following year did so, for an overall total of 12 out of 65 —18.5%.

Eliminating “Cougar Town,” which migrated to TBS after three years on ABC, the shows since 2009 that have gone at least four years on the big four are the Alphabet net’s “Modern Family” and “The Middle,” CBS’ “Blue Bloods,” “The Good Wife,” “Hawaii Five-0,” “Mike & Molly” and “NCIS: Los Angeles,” Fox’s  “Bob’s Burgers,” “The Cleveland Show” and “Raising Hope” and NBC’s “Community” and “Parenthood.”

More TV

  • NBC Sky World News Plots Summer

    NBC Sky World News Plots Summer Launch

    The company known for American news staples like “Today” and “Meet The Press” wants to create similar journalism landmarks for audiences around the world. NBCUniversal and Sky, both owned by parent Comcast Corp., will this summer launch NBC Sky World News, a news service aimed at English-speaking audiences around the globe. The company intends to [...]

  • 'Vikings': Katheryn Winnick on Directing the

    'Vikings’s' Katheryn Winnick Breaks Down Directing the 'Start of Bjorn's Downfall'

    SPOILER ALERT: Do not read if you have not yet watched “Valhalla Can Wait,” the eighth episode of the sixth season of “Vikings.” When “Vikings” creator Michael Hirst came to terms with killing off the fan-favorite Lagertha character, he knew he wanted to bring portrayer Katheryn Winnick back into the creative fold at least once more [...]

  • Picture by Simon Wilkinson/SWpix.com 22/01/2020 -

    Tartikoff Honorees Call for Commitment to Diversity and Protection of Press Freedom

    MIAMI — Jeff Zucker didn’t mince words. “Nothing is as important than what I’m doing now,” the CNN Worldwide chief said of his long career in media as he was feted Wednesday night as one of five Brandon Tartikoff Award honorees. Zucker, president of CNN Worldwide and chairman of WarnerMedia News and Sports, sounded the [...]

  • Greta Gerwig, Ava DuVernay Urge Changes

    Greta Gerwig, Ava DuVernay Among Directors Urging Changes in DGA Parental Policies

    Greta Gerwig, Ava DuVernay, Reese Witherspoon and more than 40 other women directors are urging the Directors Guild of America to change its policies for new and expectant parents. The directors have co-signed a letter by documentary filmmaker Jessica Dimmock seeking an extension of the qualifying period for DGA health insurance coverage to 18 months [...]

  • NBC Orders Drama Pilots 'Echo,' 'At

    NBC Orders Drama Pilots 'Echo,' 'At That Age'

    NBC has picked up two more drama pilots for the 2020-2021 season. Universal Television will produce both pilots. The first is titled “At That Age.” It is described as an exploration of an African-American family’s legacy. After the Cooper family’s golden child suffers a catastrophic event, seven family members face a foundational shift, make life-altering [...]

  • Tom Papa Netflix special

    TV News Roundup: Netflix Reveals Premiere Date for Tom Papa's Standup Special

    In today’s TV news roundup, Netflix announced the premiere date for “Tom Papa: You’re Doing Great!” and Quibi unveiled the title and artwork for its upcoming series starring Liam Hemsworth and Christophe Waltz.  DATES “Tom Papa: You’re Doing Great!” will launch globally on Feb. 4, Netflix announced. The veteran comedian aims to remind viewers to [...]

  • Alex Okosi

    YouTube Hires Viacom Exec Alex Okosi to Bolster EMEA Growth

    YouTube has tapped ViacomCBS Networks International exec Alex Okosi as managing director of emerging markets in Europe, the Middle East and Africa (EMEA), the company announced Tuesday. Okosi will be responsible for running YouTube’s business and partnership teams in Russia, the Middle East, and Africa, and will report to the head of YouTube EMEA, Cécile [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content