×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

MPAA: Piracy Hub Hotfile Found Liable for Copyright Infringement

Cyberlocker Hotfile has been found liable for copyright infringement for housing pirated movies and TV shows on its site, the MPAA said on Wednesday.

The summary judgment decision from U.S. District Court Judge Kathleen Williams in Florida was the first such ruling on whether cyberlockers can be held liable for the content stored on their site, the MPAA said. It also said that the company’s principal, Anton Titov, also was held liable for infringement.

The decision is sealed for about two weeks, after confidential and proprietary information has been redacted.

“We applaud the court for recognizing that Hotfile was not simply a storage locker, but an entire business model built on mass distribution of stolen content,” said MPAA chairman Chris Dodd.

The studios claimed that Hotfile “protected” those who uploaded movies and TV shows to its storage lockers and even gave them an incentive. It paid users to upload files and post links to them on third party sites.

“Today’s decision was a critically important step toward protecting an internet that works for everyone — both the people who create the content and the audiences who enjoy watching it,” Dodd said.

Janet Munn, attorney for Hotfile, did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

But the company has maintained that it was protected under the safe harbor provision of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, which shields user-generated sites from liability if owners promptly remove infringing material in response to takedown notices.

After the studios sued Hotfile in February, 2011, claiming copyright theft on a “massive scale,” the company fought back. It sought records of the studios’ own anti-piracy tactics, claiming that Warner Bros. in particular was overly aggressive in implementing Hotfile’s automatic takedown technology that removed material it did not even own.

The MPAA said that the court found that “Hotfile was successful in large part because it did not control infringement activity on its system.” In 2005, the Supreme Court ruled that peer-to-peer file sharing service Grokster could be held liable for inducing copyright infringement via the technology it offered. But Hotfile said that it actually earned praise from the studios for implementing a “special rightsholder account” system to copyright holders could immediately take down files by themselves.

More Biz

  • Alan Horn Disney

    Variety Keynote Speaker Alan Horn Sees Opportunities in Expanded Portfolio

    As Walt Disney Studios co-chairman and chief creative officer, Hollywood veteran Alan Horn oversees the most enviable content portfolio in show business. In step with his co-chairman, Alan Bergman, Horn has command of monolithic brands like Marvel Studios, Lucasfilm and Pixar — to say nothing of the 21st Century Fox film assets the men added [...]

  • Edward Cheng, Tencent Pictures CEO

    Tencent Results Show Rising Cost of Compliance, Impact of China's Slowing Economy

    Tencent, the Chinese tech giant that commands dominant positions across games, music, streaming and social media, Wednesday revealed third quarter results weighed down by slowing ad sales, slowing PC games and rising costs. Revenues in the July-to-September period showed a 21% year-on-year increase to RMB97.2 billion ($13.8 billion). Net profits dropped 13% to RMB20.4 billion [...]

  • Lilly Burns Tony Hernandez

    Variety to Honor Jax Media Chiefs Tony Hernandez, Lilly Burns at New Leaders Event

    Emmy Award-winning producer Tony Hernandez and Emmy-nominated producer Lilly Burns will receive the Creative Leadership Award on behalf of Jax Media at the Variety New Leaders event presented by City National Bank, taking place Nov. 14 in New York City. As founders of Jax Media, Hernandez and Burns have produced shows and specials such as [...]

  • Andrea Bocelli

    Andrea Bocelli Calls Plácido Domingo Cancellations Due to Sexual Harassment Claims ‘Absurd’

    Italian singer Andrea Bocelli is defending embattled opera star Plácido Domingo, saying it is “absurd” that concerts have been canceled in the wake of multiple sexual-harassment allegations. “I am still appalled at what happened to this incredible artist,” Bocelli said, according to the Associated Press. “I don’t understand this. Tomorrow a lady can just come up [...]

  • Rudy Lopez Negrete Returns to CAA     

    Rudy Lopez Negrete Returns to CAA

    Rudy Lopez Negrete has rejoined CAA as an agent in the Music Touring department, specifically focused on leading brand partnerships for CAA’s Latin music clients. He will be based in the company’s Los Angeles office, where he will work with Latin artists including Enrique Iglesias, Ricky Martin, Jennifer Lopez, Becky G, Isabela Merced, Luis Fonsi, Mon [...]

  • Richard Plepler HBO

    Former HBO Chief Richard Plepler Close to Signing Apple TV Plus Production Pact

    Former HBO chief Richard Plepler is close to signing an exclusive production pact with Apple TV Plus. Apple declined to comment and Plepler could not immediately be reached for comment. It’s understood that Plepler plans to launch a boutique production company designed to focus on a handful of high-profile projects. Among his advisors in pulling [...]

  • Byron AllenVariety Inclusion Summit, Inside, Los

    Byron Allen, Comcast to Square Off in Supreme Court on Racial Discrimination Case

    Byron Allen’s racial discrimination case against Comcast Corp. on Wednesday heads to the Supreme Court, where justices will consider Comcast’s argument that the case should hinge on two words: “but for.” Allen filed a $20 billion lawsuit against Comcast in February 2015, arguing that the nation’s largest cable operator was discriminating against his company, Entertainment [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content