You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Lifetime Seeks to Lift Judge’s Ban on TV Movie

'Romeo Killer: The Christopher Porco Story' was to air on Saturday

Lifetime is challenging a New York judge’s order that prohibits them from showing, or even marketing, a TV movie on Saturday about a man who killed his father and severely maimed his mother.

The movie, “Romeo Killer: The Christopher Porco Story,” is being challenged by Porco, currently in prison, under a New York publicity rights statute that requires permission from a subject for use of his or her image for “advertising purposes or for the purposes of trade.” Robert J. Muller, Judge of the Supreme Court of New York, rejected arguments from Lifetime that his issuance of a temporary restraining order would set a “dangerous precedent,” ruling that he found Lifetime’s argument “unavailing” because the network “appears to concede this movie is fictionalized.”

The cabler filed an emergency motion today calling for Muller’s order to be vacated, on the grounds that it is a “patently unconstitutional, prior restraint.”

Noting that Porco had not even seen the movie, Lifetime’s attorneys said that “with nothing more than this unexplored claim of ‘fictionalization,’ the trial court entered a temporary restraining order, finding that Porco might otherwise be deprived of his ‘statutory remedy’ of injunctive relief is he is able to prevail at a preliminary injunction hearing the court has now scheduled for late April.”

The TV movie business was practically built on torn-from-the-headlines tales of real-life crimes, often with producers not obtaining rights from their subjects, which is why the judge’s order was such a surprise. Lifetime argued that any politician or other public figure could merely claim that a movie project was fictionalized and get a court to halt it.

California also has a publicity rights statute, but its reference to the commercialization of a person’s image is often interpreted as meaning such things as merchandising and advertising, not the content of shows. Muller’s conclusion that “Romeo Killer” is fictionalized is what seems to have placed it in a whole different category from First Amendment protected works.

Porco, who was convicted in 2006, already has been the subject of a “48 Hours Mystery” and an episode of the TruTv series “Forensic Files.”

Lifetime said in its filing that Muller appeared to base his contention that the movie was fictionalized “based solely on Porco’s hearsay observations about how the movie was being advertised” and “without any factual support at all.”

“The Supreme Court’s order is unprecedented and would cause grave and irreparable damage not just to Lifetime but the constitutional protections for speech,” Lifetime said in its briefing.

More TV

  • Disney-Family-Movies

    Disney Family Movies SVOD Service Is Shutting Down Ahead of Disney Plus Debut

    After 11 years, Disney is pulling the plug on Disney Family Movies On Demand — with the service’s shutdown coming just days before the launch of the Mouse House’s Disney Plus. Disney Family Movies, which cost between $5-$10 per month, has been available via pay-TV providers in the U.S., including Comcast Xfinity, Charter Communications, Verizon [...]

  • Sunnyside

    TV Ratings: 'Sunnyside' Stable in Final Broadcast Episode

    NBC’s “Sunnyside,” which was pulled from the network’s schedule this week, closed off its broadcast run to roughly the same numbers as last week. The Kal Penn comedy posted a 0.3 rating and 1.2 million total viewers, continuing its run as the lowest rated and least watched new fall show in Live+Same Day. NBC has [...]

  • Bill Macy dead

    Bill Macy, 'Maude' Star, Dies at 97

    Bill Macy, who played Bea Arthur’s husband Walter Findlay on the “All in the Family” spinoff, “Maude,” died on Thursday. He was 97. “My buddy Bill Macy passed away at 7:13pm tonight. He was a spitfire right up to the end,” producer and manager Matt Beckoff wrote on Facebook. “My condolences to his beautiful wife Samantha [...]

  • Credit: Netflix / Black Mirror

    All3Media Drops Out of the Bidding for Endemol Shine (EXCLUSIVE)

    All3Media has dropped out of the running to buy rival production and distribution giant Endemol Shine, Variety has learned. All3Media, jointly owned by Discovery and Liberty Global, had lately been running the numbers to see if the acquisition made sense. Liberty is building up a huge war chest, having gained approval to offload a raft [...]

  • Issa Rae Launches Raedio Label With

    Issa Rae Launches Raedio Label With Atlantic; Watch First Release, TeaMarrr’s ‘Kinda Love’ (EXCLUSIVE)

    Raedio, the new label co-founded by Emmy-nominated actress-producer-writer Issa Rae, and Atlantic Records have announced a new partnership, which kicks off with today’s release of the new single, “Kinda Love,” by singer-rapper TeaMarrr. The companion visual, directed by child (Ari Lennox, Lucky Daye), features cameos from Rae and comedian Jessie Woo — watch it below. [...]

  • Chris-Hayes-live-audience-MSNBC

    Live, From New York... It's MSNBC Anchor Chris Hayes?

    The comedian wanted people to laugh. But not all the time. Sometimes, not at all. Ryan Reiss typically spends his evenings warming up studio audiences for Seth Meyers’ “Late Night” show. Big guffaws are in demand. On recent Friday evenings, however, Reiss has held forth in a different studio at NBC’s 30 Rockefeller Plaza headquarters, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content