Fox Faces the Music as ‘American Idol’ Takes Tumble

The success of 'Following' spurs renewed focus on male-friendly shows as the net rebuilds its sked

Going in to the 2012-13 campaign, Fox was already in need of new hits, but the sense of urgency has been amped up due to the surprisingly steep decline of “American Idol,” a show that propped up the net for a decade.

Projected to finish in second place behind CBS among young adults after winning a record eight consecutive seasons, Fox finds itself in a time of transition — and that could mean some big changes in the fall.

Among the net’s challenges is that there’s not a lot of room on its 15-hour sked for growth potential when “Idol” (and its fall counterpart, “The X Factor”) takes up so much space. Adding to the clog, shows like “Bones” and “Glee” are doing well enough to stick around even though their best days, from a ratings perspective, are behind them.

After a few seasons that saw the net skew more female than it had in years, Fox appears poised to pivot back to its male roots. Most of its drama pilots and some of its highest-profile comedies seem geared for guys; the net’s best new performer from this season, drama “The Following,” is a high-octane, edgy thriller that fares well with men.

As Fox prepares for fall, its biggest needs are strengthening Monday and Tuesday, where it ranks fourth in adults 18-49 this season. And since it has music contests eating up Wednesday and half of Thursday, Fox can improve on Monday and Tuesday only by rolling the dice on new stuff — adding perhaps as many as four new shows on the two nights alone.

Monday, where “The Following” has performed pretty well this spring but won’t be back until next year, could see a pair of new dramas aimed at men. The possibilities include police-themed “Gang Related,” U.S. marshal tale “The List” and an untitled futuristic buddy cop show from J.J. Abrams.

If at least one of those shows manages to click in the fall, it could pair with “The Following” at midseason.

The possible comedy nights of Tuesday and Thursday are difficult to predict for Fox, and could well depend on what the competition does on Thursday. NBC’s “The Office” is ending its run, so there will be no incumbent Thursday 9 p.m. comedy — an opening that Fox or CBS may seize upon.

Fox has a solid young Tuesday comedy hour in “New Girl” and “The Mindy Project,” and may want to move them to Thursday at 9 after “The X Factor” results show — although that plan would certainly go out the window if CBS shifted “The Big Bang Theory” to 9.

But if the comedies move to Thursday, where does “Glee” go? Weeknight options are limited if you want to keep it away from “The Voice.”

If Fox kept “Glee” on Thursdays and the comedy hour at 9 on Tuesday in the fall, it could go open Tuesday with a pair of new comedies — perhaps something loud and male, like the still-untitled Andy Samberg cop comedy, that could counter “Voice” and provide a decent leadin for “New Girl.”

Another possibility Fox might consider to get more comedy in its lineup is slimming “X Factor” down to 90 minutes at some point and sliding “Raising Hope” or another show behind it at 9:30.

Elsewhere, crime drama “Bones” isn’t doing the net much good leading off Monday because its numbers don’t figure to grow in season nine. It may opt for a block of dramas on Friday — another night on which Fox ran fourth this season — and have “Bones” to lead into a new drama that is tonally similar — perhaps the Greg Kinnear legal vehicle “Rake.”

With Fox among the first of the Big Four to unveil its lineup during upfront week — its presentation is set for Monday, May 13, after NBC’s morning sesh — the net really has no time to react to the sked moves unveiled by the competition.

The best-case scenario for Fox would be that “Big Bang” stays put Thursdays at 8, allowing “New Girl” and “Mindy” to follow “X Factor” on the night. It could then air “Glee” Tuesdays at 9 following a pair of new comedies.

Sunday will remain home to the net’s animated comedy block, where vets “The Simpsons,” “Family Guy” and “American Dad” still do solid business. At this point, it seems unlikely that a live-actioner would shift to Sunday or one of the toons would move to a weeknight.

Overall, Fox has not had a great season, but counting regular programs only (eliminating unfavorable year-to-year sports comparisons), it is just a little behind CBS in adults 18-49. This is because some of Fox’s biggest scripted shows — “New Girl,” “Following” and “Glee” — look a lot more competitive in full-week DVR playback numbers than they do in next-day ratings.

But time-shifting or not, Fox needs to add new tunes to its repertoire next season — and that means new scripted hits and a little less reliance on wannabe pop stars.

More TV

  • Tom Papa Netflix special

    TV News Roundup: Netflix Reveals Premiere Date for Tom Papa's Standup Special

    In today’s TV news roundup, Netflix announced the premiere date for “Tom Papa: You’re Doing Great!” and Quibi unveiled the title and artwork for its upcoming series starring Liam Hemsworth and Christophe Waltz.  DATES “Tom Papa: You’re Doing Great!” will launch globally on Feb. 4, Netflix announced. The veteran comedian aims to remind viewers to [...]

  • Alex Okosi

    YouTube Hires Viacom Exec Alex Okosi to Bolster EMEA Growth

    YouTube has tapped ViacomCBS Networks International exec Alex Okosi as managing director of emerging markets in Europe, the Middle East and Africa (EMEA), the company announced Tuesday. Okosi will be responsible for running YouTube’s business and partnership teams in Russia, the Middle East, and Africa, and will report to the head of YouTube EMEA, Cécile [...]

  • Any Given Wednesday With Bill Simmons

    HBO Teaming With Bill Simmons on Music Docuseries

    Bill Simmons’ The Ringer is continuing to expand its relationship with HBO. The company, which already produced the “Andre The Giant” doc at the cabler, is teaming with HBO on a six-part docuseries about the world of music. The project is slated to air on the network in 2021 and will center on pivotal moments [...]

  • Frida Torresblanco

    Viacom International Studios, Braven Films Sign First-Look Deal

    At Miami’s NATPE market, Viacom Intl. Studios (VIS) announced an exclusive development and production first-look agreement with Spanish-American film and TV producer Frida Torresblanco’s production company Braven Films. Braven films is run by Torresblanco and her partners Eric Laufer and Giovanna Randall and produces feature films, television series and documentaries. Torresblanco’s resumé is packed with [...]

  • Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer speaks

    TV Ratings: Trump Impeachment First Day Draws 11 Million Viewers

    The opening day of President Trump’s senate impeachment trial drew a substantial amount if viewers across the three cable news and major networks that broadcast the proceedings. In total, around 11 million people tuned in to see prosecutors from the House of Representatives and attorneys for the White House argue over exactly how the complicated [...]

  • ABC Logo

    ABC Picks Up Drama Pilot 'Harlem's Kitchen' From 'Scandal' Writer

    ABC has made their third drama pilot pick up and fourth pilot pick up overall for the 2020-2021 season. The broadcaster has ordered the drama pilot “Harlem’s Kitchen.” It is described as an ensemble family drama set in a fine dining restaurant in Harlem. Ellis Rice, Executive Chef and patriarch, runs a successful restaurant with [...]

  • Cate Blanchett Mrs. America

    'FX on Hulu' Shows Will Be Counted as FX at the Emmys (EXCLUSIVE)

    Upcoming original series “Devs,” “Mrs. America,” “A Teacher” and “The Old Man” won’t actually air on FX — but the network will still get credit when it comes to Emmy consideration. The Television Academy has said that all “FX on Hulu” shows — which will air exclusively on Hulu, and not on the linear network [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content