Fox brings out barbs in brief vs. Dish

Legal filing blasts satco's characterization of AutoHop dispute

The networks’ frustrations with Dish Network’s ad-skipping AutoHop are apparent in the first line of a brief that Fox filed with the Ninth Circuit on Thursday.

“This case is not about time-shifting, the Sony-Betamax, consumer ‘choice,’ technological innovation, the right to get a sandwich during a commercial, roosters, henhouses, or anything Jack Valenti said in 1982,” Fox’s attorneys said in their brief.

Fox is appealing U.S. District Judge Dolly M. Gee’s refusal to put a stop to AutoHop as well as the service to which it is connected, PrimeTime Anytime. Dish’s offerings allow subscribers to record an entire night’s worth of programming on all four networks in one fell swoop and then decide what to watch, and the AutoHop feature makes the shows available with the commercials cut out.

The networks are irked that Dish is trying to cast them as old media out to slow or stop the march of new technology, and that Dish has compared the battle to the legal effort to prevent consumers from recording on videocassette recorders. That led to the Supreme Court’s landmark Sony Betamax decision in 1984, which declared that recording of TV shows for home use was not infringement.

In its brief, Fox, represented by Jenner & Block, said “Dish’s colorful allusions, over-the-top mockery, and baseless accusations that Fox is attempting to relitigate the 30-year-old Sony case have one purpose: to draw the Court’s attention away from the fact that Dish is directly infringing Fox’s copyrights and breaching its license agreement with Fox.”

Fox contends that Dish merely requires subscribers to press an “on” button to activate PrimeTime Anytime as an “artifice that it is really the subscriber ‘doing’ the recording.”

They also took aim at Gee’s reasoning, writing that she “created a standard for direct infringement more restrictive than any court has ever adopted.” They argue that she “effectively nullified” contractual protections they had with Dish restricting the satcaster’s copying and commercial free video-on-demand,

“Dish’s pro-consumer bluster is phony,” Fox said. “Dish is offering ‘commercial-free TV’ because it helps Dish sell subscriptions. But behind the scenes. Dish is planning to eventually substitute Fox’s obliterated ads with its own advertisements.”

In a Jan. 17 reply to Fox’s initial appellate filing, Dish pointed to the “dire prophecy” that the networks issued regarding the VCR and then the DVR, and said, a bit flippantly, “Here we go again.” Dish is represented by Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe.

“The Hopper is a souped-up DVR,” Dish said in its filing. “The Hopper still performs the same functions VCRs did in 1984 — just more easily. The Hopper’s PrimeTime Anytime feature gives consumers a simpler way to record blocks of programming, and AutoHop provides a more efficient way to skip ads.”

More TV

  • Editorial Use OnlyMandatory Credit: Photo by

    TV Ratings: NFL's AFC, NFC Championship Games Down From 2019

    The NFL’s AFC and NFC championship games made for a blockbuster Sunday of football for CBS and Fox, but viewership of the games that determine the contenders for the Super Bowl was down from 2019 levels. CBS’ AFC championship in the 3 p.m. ET afternoon slot delivered 41.1 million viewers as the Kansas City Chiefs [...]

  • Medici TV Show

    Vuulr Online Rights Market Makes Global Expansion at NATPE

    Singapore-based Vuulr, an online content marketplace for film and TV rights, is expanding from regional to global operations. The move was announced ahead of NATPE, one of the oldest face-to-face TV rights markets, this week launching its tenth edition in Miami, Florida (Jan 21-23). The Vuulr platform is free to use for buyers and for [...]

  • What to Watch on TV This

    What to Watch on TV This Week: ‘Picard' Premieres and 'Shrill' Returns

    Welcome back to Tune In: our weekly newsletter offering a guide to the best of the week’s TV. Each week, Variety’s TV team combs through the week’s schedule, selecting our picks of what to watch and when/how to watch them. This week, “Star Trek: Picard” beams into existence on CBS All Access and “Shrill” returns [...]

  • SAG Awards 2020: What You Didn't

    SAG Awards 2020: From Charlize Theron to 'Parasite,' What You Didn't See on TV

    Brad Pitt made a crack about his marriages. Robert De Niro got political. And Jennifer Aniston talked about appearing in a commercial for Bob’s Big Boy. Those were just some of thing that happened on stage at the SAG Awards that were broadcast on TNT/TBS on Sunday night. However, Variety was inside the Shrine Auditorium [...]

  • Edges Unknown

    TCB, Cineflix, All3Media Announce Sales Ahead of NATPE Miami

    Miami’s NATPE market kicks off on Tuesday, but deal announcements are already landing. London-based TCB Media Rights has sold 130 hours of content to Latin America, Cineflix and National Geographic Latin America closed a deal for four titles, and Discovery Latin America picked up popular makeover format “10 Years Younger” from All3Media. TCB’s 130 Hours [...]

  • U.K. Broadcaster Channel 5 Readies Thomas

    U.K. Broadcaster Channel 5 Readies Thomas Markle Documentary

    ViacomCBS-backed U.K. broadcaster Channel 5 will air a 90-minute documentary on Meghan Markle’s father Thomas Markle. Markle and her husband Prince Harry sparked a global media frenzy earlier this month with their decision not to continue as senior members of the British Royal Family. Buckingham Palace announced that the couple are to lose their royal [...]

  • Tony Hall BBC Director General

    BBC Boss Tony Hall Lands at U.K.'s National Gallery

    BBC director general Tony Hall has been appointed chair of the board of trustees of the National Gallery. The executive, who has served on the Gallery’s board since November, takes over as chair from Sir John Kingman, who has been interim chair since Hannah Rothschild stood down from the role in September. Hall said: “The [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content