You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Why Take the Emmys Seriously?

Despite quibbles, TV Academy deserve kudos for many picks

Not gonna lie to you: More than once, I’ve heard people around the office say (cue voice of J. Walter Weatherman), “And that’s when I learned not to take the Emmys seriously.”

More than once, I’ve even had the same thought myself.

It’s easy to slide into cynicism about the Primetime Emmy awards during the moments when personal favorites go unrewarded in favor of the seemingly inexplicable or unconscionable. But largely speaking, the Emmys do serve as a worthy barometer of the best in television, and in the end (heck, in the beginning and the middle, too), I take them pretty damn seriously.

What stands out, above all else, is this: The playing field, if not completely level, passes the eyeball test. The size of your distribution doesn’t dictate your Emmy chances.

Showtime’s Homeland won last year’s drama series Emmy, after AMC’s Mad Men won the previous four, with typical hourly audiences roughly a tenth of what NCIS averages on CBS. The Academy of Television Arts & Sciences might be accused of elitism, but when it comes to celebrating the best, that should be a badge of honor.

Three-time defending comedy series champ Modern Family, on the other hand, is a ratings Andre the Giant, but there was little question about its critical appeal out of the gate. With its 2012 victory, you could hear some grumbling that the ABC comedy no longer deserved such laurels, but many of the murmurs came from such diverse and niche fan clubs — Louie, Parks and Recreation, Veep — that you could explain the Modern victory as one of plurality.

More to the point, as you look ahead to possible successors to Modern in comedy, you’d be hard-pressed to predict which of the following has the better shot: good-humored CBS ratings machine The Big Bang Theory or the ultimate small-aud bee in everyone’s bonnet, HBO’s Girls.

Perhaps the biggest argument against the Emmys is that they force the TV Academy to walk a tightrope that in many ways is doomed to unravel. On one side are those who believe the Acad hasn’t been bold enough with its selections, whether it’s ignoring a Sons of Anarchy here or a Dan Harmon-era Community there. On the other come those who find the Academy getting too cute with its picks, at the expense of such popular but intelligent fare as The Walking Dead.

The credibility of the Emmys will forever be haunted by never giving The Wire a single nomination of note — the belief that there were at least five dramas better than the landmark HBO series each year is TV’s version of WMDs in Iraq. The truth is the truth, and a single mistake of this magnitude is enough to permanently discredit a body in the eyes of the betrayed.

But since the Emmys aren’t literally life or death, I can forgive, rather than forget how often the Emmys do recognize a TV underdog.

It was the Emmys that made Hill Street Blues a program that NBC couldn’t possibly dispense with, that gave The Ben Stiller Show post-cancelation validation, who, better late than never, found Friday Night Lights worthy of awards.

It is rare that the TV Academy makes a truly bad choice, rare enough that when it happens, I’m genuinely surprised and dismayed. Never giving Steve Carell an Emmy for The Office is as big a comedy sin as you can find in the past decade, and I’ll bitch and moan until Amy Poehler gets her Parks and Rec kudo — but almost as often, their alternatives are sincerely defensible.

Even when the Emmys can’t seem to break free of a repeat winner, it makes sense. My daughter was born the night of the 2002 Emmys, and The Daily Show With Jon Stewart has won the variety-music-comedy series trophy every year since. With all respect to Stephen Colbert, I’ve never felt any of the wins were undeserved.

Given that you’re never going to validate everyone, the Emmys do an above-average job of validating the efforts of an industry that produces more above-average content than almost anyone could watch. The stakes are real.

More TV

  • Mergers and Deals Placeholder

    Tegna to Buy 11 TV Stations From Nexstar for $740 Million

    Tegna has set a deal with Nexstar to buy 11 TV stations — mostly Fox and ABC affiliates — serving eight markets for $740 million. The sale is contingent on Nexstar closing its $4.1 billion acquisition of Tribune Media, which will make Nexstar the nation’s largest TV station owner by far. Nexstar projects the Tribune [...]


    'Traitors' Producer 42 Hires Literary Manager Eugenie Furniss

    Eugenie Furniss is joining London- and Los Angeles-based management and production company 42 as literary manager, it was announced Wednesday. The company’s slate include movie “Ironbark,” a Cold War thriller starring Benedict Cumberbatch, and TV series “Traitors,” a spy thriller coming to Netflix in the U.S. at the end of the month. Furniss joins 42 [...]

  • Disney Fox Takeover Placeholder

    Fox Corp. Pays Disney Sale Dividend, Sets May 9 Investor Meeting

    Fox Corp. has handed over an $8.5 billion check to help Disney offset tax costs related to the 21st Century Fox acquisition. As spelled out in the Disney-21st Century Fox merger agreement, the Murdoch clan’s newly established Fox Corp. was on the hook to pay a special dividend to 21st Century Fox on the latter’s [...]

  • Stranger Things

    Netflix Drops 'Stranger Things' Season 3 Trailer (Watch)

    The “Stranger Things” kids are done playing board games in the basement. From the new trailer for season three, which Netflix just dropped, and The Who song “Baba O’Riley” blasting throughout, it would appear that the gang of Eleven, Mike, Lucas, Dustin and co. are about to experience their “teenage wasteland.” The trailer opens with [...]

  • Tim Roth Series ‘Tin Star’ Gets

    Tim Roth Series ‘Tin Star’ Gets Third and Final Season on Sky

    Tim Roth will star in a third and final season of “Tin Star,” the Sky original drama. Like earlier seasons, it will play on Amazon outside the U.K. Genevieve O’Reilly and Abigail Lawrie also return in the final chapter of the story, which is produced by Endemol Shine’s Kudos alongside Gaumont U.K. Rowan Joffe created [...]

  • Little Mix Star Jesy Nelson Making

    Little Mix's Jesy Nelson Making BBC Documentary About Mental Health and Body Image

    Little Mix star Jesy Nelson is making a one-off documentary for the BBC in which she will explore issues surrounding body shaming and mental health in the age of social media. “Jesy Nelson: My Story” will launch on the BBC’s youth-skewed online channel BBC Three and then play on BBC One. Girl band Little Mix [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content