Emmys: Why Some Iconic Performances Don’t Win

Perception isn’t always the same as reality. That’s true in life, and it’s certainly true in Emmys

Perception isn’t always the same as reality. That’s true in life, and it’s certainly true in Emmys.

Many people think that Jon Hamm has won an Emmy for “Mad Men.” Not true. But the show’s four consecutive victories in drama series make people assume everyone with the “Mad Men” universe has been honored, including all the actors and costume designers. Oddly, none of them have.

Hamm is an especially interesting case, because he’s helped make a household name the character that evokes a certain style of man, clothing and era. Op-ed pieces talk about the Don Draper syndrome, fashion pages talk about the Don Draper look. But is it possible Hamm’s shutout is not despite his iconic work, but because of it?

Exhibit A: Jackie Gleason as Ralph Kramden, Leonard Nimoy as Mr. Spock, Larry Hagman as J.R. Ewing, Bill Cosby as Dr. Cliff Huxtable, Kim Cattrall as Samantha Jones, Jerry Orbach as Lennie Briscoe, Angela Lansbury as Jessica Fletcher, Garry Shandling as Larry Sanders and Stephen Colbert as Stephen Colbert. All of them nominated, but none have won.

Exhibit B, work that was not even nominated: John Cleese as Basil Fawlty, Colin Firth as Mr. Darcy,  Lorne Greene as Ben Cartwright, Dave Chappelle on “Chappelle’s Show,” S. Epatha Merkerson on “Law & Order,” and let’s not forget David Tennant and Matt Smith as Doctor Who.

However, there were definitive blendings of actor and role who did end up in the winners circle, including Lucille Ball as Lucy Ricardo, Carroll O’Connor as Archie Bunker and James Gandolfini and Edie Falco as Tony and Carmela Soprano.

Why do some win while others don’t? In the Emmy world, one factor is repetition. With a film role, you usually have only one chance; with TV, you get nominated multiple times for indelible work. So a lot of the classic characterizations (Bea Arthur, E.G. Marshall, Ed Asner, Peter Falk, Ray Romano, etc.) did not win regularly, but they did win, sooner or later.

And often it’s that indefinable buzz. HBO’s “Oz” never gained enough Emmy love. In its entire run “The Wire” earned a meager two nominations for writing (winning neither) but was recently voted by Entertainment Weekly as the greatest series of all time, echoing the 2006 pronouncement by Brian Lowry of Variety that it is “one of the most demanding and thought-provoking series ever to grace television.”

“NCIS,” “Sons of Anarchy,” “Treme,” “The Walking Dead” as best series? Nope. The list goes on and on.

But the main culprit might simply be the other contenders. Jackie Gleason, for example, lost to Phil Silvers as Sgt. Bilko, another classic perf. In Nimoy’s case: Don Knotts as Barney Fife. Can’t argue with that one either, despite Emmy’s odd practice in those days of lumping all supporting work together.

These mysterious twists of awards fate are hardly limited to Emmy. When you talk about iconic performances, the film world has given us Sean Connery as James Bond, Humphrey Bogart as Sam Spade, Boris Karloff as Frankenstein’s monster, Peter Sellers as Inspector Clouseau, Anthony Perkins as Norman Bates. None was even nominated for an Oscar.

Does Hamm lose sleep over the Emmys? Let’s hope not. Should we lose sleep on his behalf? It’s hard to pity someone who’s talented, is liked and respected, who looks that great, does a lot of philanthropic work and who has a long career ahead of him.

This column isn’t really for him; it’s for all of you contenders, in all the endless categories. Four-fifths of you will go home empty-handed. So if you feel slighted, think about Mr. Hamm (who, fingers crossed, will win this year, but maybe not). Think about Greta Garbo, Peter O’Toole, Barbara Stanwyck and Steve McQueen, who never won Oscars. Think about all those poor suckers who work for years in good TV shows but never manage to even get nominated. Think of your fellow nominees who were shut out. Think about yourself, and realize that even if you go home empty-handed, you can tell people that you won, and sooner or later they will believe you.

As we said, it’s all a matter of reality vs. perception.

More TV

  • 'Lincoln Lawyer' Series in Development at

    'Lincoln Lawyer' Series in Development at CBS from David E. Kelley

    David E. Kelley is returning once more to the court of legal dramas. CBS has issued a series production commitment for “The Lincoln Lawyer,” with Kelley in position to pen and executive produce. Based on the series of bestselling novels by Michael Connelly, the show hails from A+E Studios in association with CBS TV Studios. [...]

  • Patrick Somerville'Maniac' TV Show premiere, London,

    'Maniac' Creator to Helm 'Made for Love,' 'Station Eleven' for WarnerMedia

    “Maniac” creator Patrick Somerville has signed on to helm two new series, “Made for Love” and “Station Eleven,” for WarnerMedia’s upcoming streaming service. “Made for Love,” which will be executive produced and directed by S.J. Clarkson, is a 10-episode, straight-to-series adaptation based on the novel of the same name by Alissa Nutting. The half-hour comedy [...]

  • Naomi Watts and Gretchen Carlson'The Loudest

    ‘The Loudest Voice’ Stars Naomi Watts, Russell Crowe Talk Roger Ailes

    Roger Ailes may have been the force behind the creation of Fox News, but the late newsman’s legacy will forever be his atrocious sexual harassment of several of the network’s female anchors and producers. Showtime premiered its new limited series “The Loudest Voice,” which chronicles Ailes’ rise and fall, on Monday night at the Paris [...]

  • Steve McQueen VSS

    Amazon to Launch Steve McQueen's Anthology Series ‘Small Axe’ in the U.S.

    Amazon has boarded “Small Axe,” the upcoming anthology series from “12 Years a Slave” director Steve McQueen, and will launch the series in the U.S. It will bow on the BBC in the U.K. and BBC Studios is selling it internationally. Amazon’s European content chief Georgia Brown revealed its involvement in the series, Tuesday, at [...]

  • Paula Pell

    Quibi Orders Comedic Murder Mystery From Lorne Michaels, 'SNL' Alums

    Quibi keeps shelling out cash for content: Jeffrey Katzenberg’s richly funded startup has ordered a short-form murder-mystery comedy written by and starring former “Saturday Night Live” writers Paula Pell and John Lutz, and executive produced by Lorne Michaels’ Broadway Video alongside Seth Meyers and Mike Shoemaker. In “Mapleworth Murders,” Pell (pictured above) is Abigail Mapleworth, [...]

  • Sky

    Comcast Expected to Appoint Maximo Ibarra as New Sky Italia CEO

    Colombian-Italian executive Maximo Ibarra is expected to be appointed CEO of Comcast-owned pay-TV operation Sky Italia, which has been without a chief executive for the past seven months, a source close to Sky Italia tells Variety. An announcement is believed imminent that Ibarra will be the Italian paybox’s new chief after it was announced Tuesday [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content