You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Emmys: TV Needs to Get Over Its Inferiority Complex

With creatives frequently drawn to the smallscreen, Emmy voters need to know they can compete with film

F or years, the prevailing assumption has been that Emmy voters — and TV people in general — are positively ga-ga over movie stars. And if that’s still really the case, here’s a thought: Time to get over it.

Previewing the Emmys, the Los Angeles Times noted that “House of Cards” features talent imbued with “the kind of bigscreen cachet … that makes academy members weak in the knees,” including Kevin Spacey, Robin Wright and director David Fincher. And while Spacey and Wright came up short, Fincher — a two-time Oscar nominee — won for directing the first episode of “Cards.”

But if it’s true that members of the TV academy still feel like second-class-citizen status vis-a-vis movies — at least in the award-show context — then it’s more like they’re weak in the head.

Creatively speaking, TV has arguably become the dominant medium in pop culture — a passing of the baton even cinephiles increasingly acknowledge. Wall Street Journal film critic Joe Morgenstern even recently noted the trend in a piece titled “In Defense of the Movies.”

So while it’s fine for movie stars to come ply their trade in television — often because it offers them the opportunity to do the kind of character-driven work that might not be as readily available in features — those who work in TV should not be rendered speechless and wide-eyed by the prospect of having film luminaries attend their annual party. That’s for people living in the past.

Ever since HBO, in particular, started wooing movie talent, easing their misgivings in part with that brilliant old slogan “It’s not TV. It’s HBO,” there’s been a parade of marquee names finding their way to television. Invariably, stories are written each year documenting those Oscar winners and nominees recognized with Emmy bids, and the overlap between contenders who have an Academy Award on the mantle alongside their Emmy. Fincher’s Emmy win for drama series direction was one of the safer bets on Sunday, to the dismay of those who felt that Emmy voters’ knee-jerk tendency toward movie people came at the expense of impressive work from two seasoned female directors, Leslie Linka Glatter (nominated for “Homeland”) and Michelle MacLaren (“Breaking Bad”).

Yet few would dare suggest now that movie people are slumming when they come to TV. Rather they’re making a pragmatic choice, and potentially a more creatively rewarding one — unless you think there was a line of studios willing to give the big wide release treatment to HBO’s “Behind the Candelabra,” which scored Emmys Sunday for Michael Douglas and director Steven Soderbergh.

“TV is where it’s at,” Soderbergh said standing amid the splendor of HBO’s Emmy after-party (an annual display of the pay cabler’s gaudy riches unmatched by any other network or studio). “Something like (AMC’s) ‘Breaking Bad’ would never happen in the studio system.”

As anyone paying attention knows, TV’s influence also reaches far deeper than just what’s on screen. Executives from TV backgrounds — Disney’s Robert Iger, CBS’ Leslie Moonves, Time Warner’s Jeff Bewkes, NBCUniversal’s Steve Burke, Chase Carey at Fox (and before that Peter Chernin) — run the major studios.

Similarly, while there are select film actors who still collect massive paydays, in success, TV stars can command the kind of salaries and profit participation points that actors (and their agents) can only dream of in today’s movie landscape. Bobby Cannavale, a surprise winner on Sunday for his work on HBO’s “Boardwalk Empire” (a lavish period drama that Martin Scorsese helped bring to life), spoke of hitting the jackpot in cable drama the way actors once spoke of landing a career-making film.

“Movies aren’t making dramas anymore,” Cannavale said, echoing the sentiments of many a working actor. “Cable (is) the place where you go to do good work. I lucked out. I hit it at the right time.”

It’s equally telling that digital players like Netflix — this year’s Emmy upstart — have largely chosen to distinguish and brand their services with original content by ordering series.

Back in the late 1990s during a panel discussion of TV showrunners, sitcom producer Charlie Hauck sought to explain the notion that TV suffered from a sort of inferiority complex by saying, “Movies are bigger. They win.”

That was before “The Sopranos,” though, and before AMC and FX decided they wanted in on the prestige action. Any inherent advantage conferred on “bigger” has thus blurred in terms of quality, perception and even delivery systems and technology, which has further narrowed differences in how various media are consumed.

Sure, there’s still nothing quite like an Imax 3D sensual assault, if you’re into that sort of thing. But for movies that don’t require that visceral experience, a 47-inch high-definition set and homemade popcorn will do just fine.

By all means, if people principally known for movies venture into TV and do yeoman’s work, they should be honored and applauded, patted on the back and sent home with trophies. And yes, there is something nifty for those weaned on “The Godfather” saga about rubbing shoulders with nominees like Al Pacino, or Helen Mirren, a dame who’s really a Dame.

But if the motivation to recognize movie players still stems from a starry-eyed desire to class up the place, Emmy voters should take a deep breath and look around. Because at its best, TV circa 2013 is already pretty damn classy.

More TV

  • Crazy Rich Asians

    Singapore Sees Rise in Co-productions, Competes for Foreign Projects

    As Singapore’s stature continues to grow in the entertainment world, and with international producers forever on the lookout for exotic but affordable locations, the Asian country is once again in global sights as a major production hub. Singapore’s distinctive topography of cityscapes and countryside, coupled with its unique cultural blend of East and West, has [...]

  • Charlie Corwin and John Penotti SK

    S.K. Global Makes Mipcom Debut With 'Crazy Rich Asians' Under Its Belt

    “To me, it wasn’t like, ‘Oh, maybe we should wake up one morning and try something different. How about we try television?’” John Penotti, producer-financier and co-founder of GreeneStreet, one of New York City’s more long-lived independent film companies — it was acquired in 2013 after 16 years — is explaining just how he ended [...]

  • singapore Skyline

    Netflix, HBO, Other Global Content Creators Set Up Asian Bases in Media-Friendly Singapore

    Netflix runs its Asian operations from the swanky Marina One mixed-use development in Singapore, an architectural masterpiece that fits in with the streaming giant’s dedication to Instagrammable real estate. Netflix’s presence in Singapore follows other major media names over the years, including HBO Asia, Vice Media and HOOQ, all of whom have Asian headquarters in [...]

  • Sidney Kimmel film financier

    Television — Sidney Kimmel's Next Act Bows at Mipcom

    During the course of his 91 years, Sidney Kimmel has accomplished a lot. That includes making a few videos for web series “Old Jews Telling Jokes.” “John’s fault,” he says. “He dragged me over there and said, ‘You’ll get a free drink and a dinner out of it.’” John is independent movie producer-financier John Penotti, [...]

  • The Outpost -- "One is the

    Electric Entertainment Launching OTT Channel Electric Now (EXCLUSIVE)

    U.S.-based producer and distributor Electric Entertainment is launching Electric Now, a linear OTT channel that will feature its top series and library content. The channel will have episodes of “The Outpost,” the fantasy-adventure series that has just had its third season greenlit by U.S. network The CW. The new season will head into production in [...]

  • American dollars bills and coinsAmerican cash,

    Entertainment Biz Comes Under Fire for Assistants' Low Wages, Working Conditions

    It’s no secret that many assistants in Hollywood bear heavy workloads for low pay. But the entertainment industry’s labor practices when it comes to those workers have now become the subject of intense social-media scrutiny. TV writer and WGA board member Liz Alper shone a light on the issue Monday with the creation of the [...]

  • Megyn Kelly

    Tucker Carlson Plans Megyn Kelly Interview on Fox News Channel

    Megyn Kelly is returning to Fox News Channel – briefly. Tucker Carlson has scheduled an interview Wednesday with the former Fox News and NBC News anchor, who will make her first appearance on her former employer’s programming since leaving in early 2017. The “Tucker Carlson Tonight” segment would also mark Kelly’s first appearance on a [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content