×

‘The Canyons’: Why Paul Schrader’s Reviled Thriller Merits a Closer Look

REARVIEW: In this controversy-seeking film starring Lindsay Lohan and porn star James Deen, your viewing pleasure is very much beside the point.

As preferable as it always is to see a film on the bigscreen — “the way it was meant to be seen,” if such an ideal still exists in the era of Netflix and YouTube — the conventional wisdom didn’t seem to apply to “The Canyons.” Given that Paul Schrader’s controversy-seeking erotic thriller represents an unusually high-profile test of IFC’s day-and-date digital distribution model, I accepted the latter of two options presented by the trailer (“in select theaters or in the privacy of your home”) and watched the film on my laptop just after 10 p.m. on Friday night — optimal conditions, really, for a movie that has been marketed for maximum trashy-porny appeal.

SEE ALSO: IFC’s ‘The Canyons’ Opens on One Gotham Screen, Nabs $15,200

And yet, despite its flat, airless style and sometimes less-than-adroit acting, its occasional full-frontal nudity and the prominent casting of adult-film star James Deen, “The Canyons” is decidedly not pornography. Its restraint in that department — or its timidity, depending on your taste — may well be its most perverse stroke, for this is a film that deliberately short-circuits the viewer’s pleasure in every way imaginable. Our entertainment, to say nothing of our edification, could scarcely be more beside the point.

As screenwriter Bret Easton Ellis recently noted with characteristic humility, “I think ‘The Canyons’ is about mood and a world and not plot points. The best movies are.” Without lending credence to the idea that “The Canyons” and “the best movies” belong in the same tweet, I’d say he makes a pretty fair point. Opening with a still-frame montage of various decrepit, long-abandoned movie houses, the film is less a Cinemax-style potboiler than a zombified mood piece set against a post-cinema wasteland. Scene by coolly drawn-out scene, Schrader and Ellis build a portrait of a world in decay that feels at once trashy and sterile, repellent and weirdly hypnotic, framed and edited so as to emphasize the dead space, visual and aural, that surrounds their characters.

This, they seem to be saying, is cinema’s future, and perhaps even its present: a creative and commercial dead zone overrun by not-so-bright young things who spend their free time spying on each other, shooting their own amateur porn movies, and generally exploiting their bodies for personal and professional survival. “Nobody has a private life anymore,” notes Deen’s character at one point, and if that sounds like a leaden attempt at commentary on The Way We Live Now, it’s also a clue as to how to watch a film that completely obliterates any notion of privacy, on or off the screen.

As anyone who has been following this troubled production knows, the film’s leads, Lindsay Lohan and James Deen — two celebrities who, for very different reasons, have suffered from what you might call overexposure — have been its primary liability as well as its chief selling point. In the new low-budget filmmaking economy of Kickstarter and VOD, public notoriety is its own tricky but valuable form of currency, and since the day Stephen Rodrick’s viciously entertaining New York Times Magazine piece appeared, the chaos behind the scenes — Lohan’s difficulty on the set; the infighting among her, Deen and Schrader; the four-way sex scene — has had the feel of a carefully orchestrated scandal.

What’s interesting about the film itself, and what compels at least a handful of critics (including Variety’s Scott Foundas) to take it seriously, is that its stunt casting also happens to serve a thematic purpose. Watching Lohan and Deen onscreen, it’s impossible not to feel the weight of the actors’ public personae pressing in — the professional train wreck and the boy-next-door porn star, respectively — and it’s precisely this blurring of on- and offscreen identities that makes Schrader’s experiment, for all its surface-level frustrations, an object of fascination. Our sense of who these people are doesn’t distract from the film’s sleazy simulacrum of reality; it completes it. That’s true of Deen, who brings a chilling opacity to the role of a murderous producer/pimp/sex addict, and it’s especially true of Lohan, striking the film’s sole chords of genuine emotion as she merges real and (hopefully) fictive demons, projecting a level of raw anguish, anxiety and personal torment that even naysayers have been hard-pressed to overlook.

Still the problem remains, as many have argued, that these characters are vacuous beyond belief, to which I would suggest they are holding “The Canyons” to a standard of dramatic humanism that it never once aspires to. This is a chilly slab of anti-entertainment, and the too-easy derision it’s received so far can’t help but remind me of the reactions to a far more benign study of industry malaise: Sofia Coppola’s “Somewhere,” a perceptive and eloquent film that was dismissed as empty because it dared to tackle spiritual emptiness as its very subject. “The Canyons” goes further still; at once embodying and interrogating a culture of vulgarity, degradation and compromise, it takes our worst nightmares about the future of cinema to a hideous yet revealing extreme. It won’t get you off, but you might have an awfully hard time looking away.

Popular on Variety

More News

  • Motherless Brooklyn Edward Norton

    Edward Norton Investigates Murder in 'Motherless Brooklyn' Trailer

    The trailer for Edward Norton’s forthcoming crime drama “Motherless Brooklyn” is officially out. Warner Bros.’ drama, based on the 1999 novel by Jonathan Lethem, follows Lionel Essrog, a young man who works for a small-time mobster in Brooklyn while struggling with an intense case of Tourette Syndrome. “Okay, listen, I got something wrong with me, [...]

  • Summer Box Office

    Box Office Report Card: Studios Get Their Summer Grades

    Studios got badly burned this summer. From May to August, popcorn season in movie speak, the film flops piled up and the big hits were few and far between for nearly every company except Disney. As a whole, summer did little to instill confidence in the state of moviegoing. To be sure, there were successes [...]

  • Former movie producer Harvey Weinstein (L)

    Harvey Weinstein to Be Arraigned on New Indictment

    Harvey Weinstein is set to appear in court on Monday for an arraignment on a new indictment, the Manhattan D.A.’s office said Thursday. Prosecutors announced last week that they would seek a fresh indictment, which would allow actress Annabella Sciorra to testify at Weinstein’s trial. The move came after Justice James Burke ruled on Aug. [...]

  • Port Authority

    Nate Parker's 'American Skin' to Play in Deauville

    Nate Parker’s politically charged drama “American Skin” is set to play at the 45th edition of the Deauville American Film Festival following its world premiere at Venice. “American Skin,” which tells the story of a Gulf War veteran whose son is killed by a police officer, marks Parker’s first feature film since the news resurfaced [...]

  • Haunting of Hill House

    'Haunting of Hill House' Writers Making Horror Series 'Red Rose' for BBC

    The BBC is teaming with Michael and Paul Clarkson, the twin brother writers behind the second season of Netflix series “The Haunting of Hill House,” for a new horror thriller, the U.K. pubcaster announced Thursday at the Edinburgh TV Festival. “Red Rose” is being produced for the BBC’s U.K. youth-skewing online platform BBC Three. The [...]

  • (L to R) Kristian Bruun, Melanie

    Box Office: 'Ready or Not' Finds $2 Million on Opening Day

    Horror movie “Ready or Not” scared up a $2 million opening day at 2,244 North American locations as Fox Searchlight got a two-day jump on the weekend. The figure includes $730,000 from Tuesday night previews. “Ready or Not” centers on a bride’s wedding night turning deadly when her new in-laws force her into a strange game [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content