×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Zimmerman Trial Turns MSNBC/Fox Divide From Blue/Red to Black/White

Political polarization turns toward race as channels analyze controversial verdict

MSNBC and Fox News have long been divided into blue and red camps. But since the verdict in the Trayvon Martin case, the color palette has increasingly been reduced to black and white.

Ugly and quarrelsome in the best of times, this polarization between the two talk-oriented cable networks has felt even more pronounced this week, as the two gravitate toward diametrically opposed – and racially divided – poles in reaction to the verdict in the George Zimmerman trial.

MSNBC’s progressive hosts have featured a number of African-Americans expressing their dismay and outrage over Zimmerman’s acquittal in the killing of Martin, including the Rev. Al Sharpton, an activist before he joined the network, who has announced plans to orchestrate vigils this weekend pertaining to the case.

On Thursday, Sharpton could be seen all across the network’s lineup, repeating portions of an interview he conducted with Martin’s parents.

The tone at Fox, meanwhile, has been set by its most prominent hosts, Sean Hannity and Bill O’Reilly, who have dismissed the contention blacks face inequalities within the criminal-justice system. Other lesser lights – such as Eric Bolling – have been even more strident, particularly in regard to defending Florida’s permissive gun laws.

MSNBC officials have been criticized in the past for Sharpton’s dual pursuits – including his involvement with the Martin case — and the inherent conflict in the fact he continues functioning as a civil-rights leader while working for the channel.

As for Fox, Hannity’s softball interview with Zimmerman essentially provided much of the testimony he declined to give on the witness stand, albeit without having to face anything that resembled cross-examination.

Having committed itself to being “The Place for Politics,” MSNBC is awkwardly positioned to pivot into a reporting mode, inasmuch as everything seems filtered through a political prism. CNN is generally the beneficiary during breaking-news events, but has consistently struggled to maintain the audience that tunes in at those moments, which explains current attempts to inject more pizzazz into its presentation.

One of the principal achievements of Fox News under Roger Ailes, by contrast, has been its ability to weave the DNA of a partisan political operation into the framework of a news channel, despite a posture that during key parts of the day more closely resembles talkradio. It’s a trick MSNBC hasn’t fully mastered.

Conservative antipathy toward the Obama administration has been highly beneficial for Fox, setting the network up as perhaps the most formidable and cohesive voice of the opposition. Yet even with that, Fox’s response to the Zimmerman verdict appears to be doubling down on speaking to (and for) an older, predominantly white and conservative-tilted audience.

Some moderate and conservative commentators have suggested such an approach is likely a losing one for the Republican Party because of the nation’s shifting demographics. In a recent column about immigration reform, for example, the New York Times’ David Brooks wrote “this country is heading toward a multiethnic future. Republicans can either shape that future in a conservative direction or, as I’ve tried to argue, they can become the receding roar of a white America that is never coming back.”

Still, issuing that roar appears to be a perfectly viable formula for Fox, which doesn’t need to gain support from 51% of registered voters but merely attract enough viewers to dominate the cable ratings race. And despite cosmetic changes to the network’s talent lineup, those marching orders are unlikely to change.

Where does that leave us? As usual, with two so-called news networks that have largely cast aside any pretense objectivity and can’t even agree on a set of facts, much less the terms for a constructive debate. And the oddities never seem to end, such as MSNBC’s Chris Matthews taking it upon himself to apologize on behalf of “all white people.”

In showbiz terms, it’s a more colorful way of receiving news — and one reason CNN has struggled to compete by occupying a middle ground.

When it comes to the rancorous tone, though, watching this white-black divide unfold over the past week has bled into a thoroughly depressing shade of gray.

More Columns

  • A Love Letter to Video Games

    A Love Letter to Video Games

    As a relatively new father, I’m trying to indulge my inner optimist more often, if only to model the kind of joyful life untainted by default cynicism I wish for my son. The community of games is too commonly sunk by the urge, by some, to drag others into their own self-loathing mire. I’ve been [...]

  • Cindy HollandNetflix Executive Address, TCA Summer

    Is It Time for Some Networks to Skip TCA? (Column)

    That Television Critics Assn. press tour — concluding Wednesday with a suite of cable and streaming panels, including those for Amazon — does a remarkably effective, even exhaustive job of conveying to participants the sweep of television in this moment of sprawl. From high-class cable and streaming outlets such as HBO, FX, Amazon and Hulu [...]

  • FX Confronts Streaming Thanks to Disney

    Kicking and Screaming, FX Is Forced to Confront Future in the Stream (Column)

    During his network’s presentation at the winter Television Critics Assn. press tour, FX chief John Landgraf made waves — and headlines — by mounting perhaps his most direct criticism yet of Netflix. Landgraf, whose briefings to the press tend to rely heavily on data about the volume of shows with which FX’s competitors flood the [...]

  • Dear Academy: For Your Consideration...

    Dear Academy: Please Consider These Standouts

    On Feb. 12, members of the Motion Picture Academy will begin voting to determine winners of the 91st Oscars. Each campaign has primed its final push, zeroing in on messaging aimed at bringing home the gold. On Feb. 19, balloting will close and it will then be what feels like (for the nominees) an interminable [...]

  • A still from Leaving Neverland by

    HBO's Michael Jackson Documentary Deserves Our Attention (Column)

    HBO’s two-part documentary “Leaving Neverland” — which has been making news since its first public viewing at the Sundance Film Festival earlier this year — is a remarkably effective, methodically built case alleging that the late Michael Jackson was a systematic predator and rapist of young children. And its airing on HBO on March 3 [...]

  • Mahershala Ali25th Annual Screen Actors Guild

    A Wild Oscar Race Is (Mostly) Taking Shape

    It’s by no means time to start packing it in this awards season. Final ballots won’t even go out to Academy members until Feb. 12. But in the major categories, examining how the guilds have voted so far, some interesting battles appear to be taking shape. Underdogs are lurking and surprises can (and will) happen, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content