Opera Review: ‘Tosca’

If ever there’s an opera that resists wild interpretations, it’s Puccini’s tale of revolution, authoritarianism and unbridled lust in old Rome.

With: Joshua Bloom, Philip Cokorinos, Marco Berti, Sondra Radvanovksy, Lado Ataneli, Rodell Rosel, Daniel Armstrong, Eden McCoy, Hunter Phillips.

John Caird is best known to Broadway and L.A. auds for his staging of “Nicholas Nickleby” and “Les Miserables,” but he also helms operas, such as “Tosca,” now on display at LA Opera. If ever there’s an opera that resists wild interpretations, it’s Puccini’s tale of revolution, authoritarianism and unbridled lust in old Rome. Caird tries to half-reinvent this warhorse, and he only half succeeds thanks to a vocally robust cast.

Tosca” takes place in three very real Roman locales: the Church of Sant’Andrea delle Valle (act one), the Palazzo Farnese (act two) and the Castel Sant’Angelo (act three). Caird wisely sticks to the church to set up the action that has the jealous diva Tosca (Sondra Radvanovsky) bickering with her lover-revolutionary Cavaradossi (Marco Berti) while fending off the unwanted advances of police chief Baron Scarpia (Lado Ataneli).

Instead of a well-appointed study in the palazzo, however, Caird has Scarpia operating from a storage room in act two, as if this chief of police has fallen on hard times. And in act three, the roof of the castle has been converted to a prison yard. Which must be the reason Tosca slits her own throat before she jumps to her death only a story or two below.

Much more confusing is the little girl decked out in her white communion dress who wanders around the sets and ultimately beckons Tosca to commit suicide. If she’s to represent Tosca’s Roman Catholic conscience, Caird hasn’t read his Catechism lately.

Even more than the locales, Puccini’s music resists reinterpretations of the text. Like a movie score, it signals very specific action: Tosca’s entrance in the church, Tosca’s spotting of the knife that she’ll use to kill Scarpia, Tosca’s frightened departure from Scarpia’s study.

Caird doesn’t ignore these music cues; he just comes up with different visuals. For example, the expansive music that cues Cavaradossi’s entrance in act three now accompanies the hoisting of a dead revolutionary, and so on. None of these are improvements on the original; they’re just different and, for the most part, slightly less effective and extraneous.

“Tosca,” fortunately, lives or dies on its three principal singers. And this “Tosca” lives victoriously.

Radvanovsky’s “Vissi d’arte” incited an extended ovation. High C holds no terror for Berti. And Ataneli brings real elegance to fascism. In the pit, Placido Domingo is a most supportive conductor — he never swamps his singers with Puccini’s lush orchestrations — but sometimes he’s too supportive. He could shape the score more rather than follow his singers’ lead.

Popular on Variety

Opera Review: 'Tosca'

An LA Opera presentation of an opera in three acts, music by Giacomo Puccini, libretto by Giuseppe Giacosa and Luigi Illica.

Production: (Dorothy Chandler Pavilion, Los Angeles; 3,000 seats, $270 top)

Crew:  Conducted by Placido Domingo. Directed by John Caird. Sets and costumes, Bunny Christie; lighting, Duane Schuler. Opened on May 18, 2013. Reviewed May 30. Running time: 2 HOURS, 40 MIN.

Cast: With: Joshua Bloom, Philip Cokorinos, Marco Berti, Sondra Radvanovksy, Lado Ataneli, Rodell Rosel, Daniel Armstrong, Eden McCoy, Hunter Phillips.

More Music

  • Kendrick Lamar House Manhattan Beach

    Kendrick Lamar Drops Nearly $10 Million on Manhattan Beach Mansion

    When he’s not performing to packed arenas worldwide — the international “Damn” tour wrapped up last year with over $62 million in gross receipts — Kendrick Lamar has long resided in L.A.’s South Bay region, specifically in the posh seaside city of Manhattan Beach. And after a reported long spell as an area home renter, [...]

  • Benjamin Wallfisch - scoring session, Abbey

    Composer Benjamin Wallfisch Signs With Gorfaine/Schwartz Agency

    Composer Benjamin Wallfisch has signed with the Gorfaine/Schwartz Agency (GSA) for worldwide representation, in partnership with London-based agency COOL Music Ltd. A top composer, whose scoring credits include “It Chapter Two,” Shazam!” Hellboy,” “Hidden Figures” and “Hostile Planet,” among others, Wallfisch has worked on over 75 feature films and is a member of the BAFTA [...]

  • Spotify logo is presented on a

    Spotify VP Paul Vogel Talks Subscription Prices, Label Licenses, Podcasts

    The annual Goldman Sachs Communacopia Conference gives representatives from major companies the opportunity to present to the investment community, and Paul Vogel, Spotify’s VP and head of financial planning & analysis, treasury and investor relations, spoke on the streaming giant’s behalf on Tuesday morning. While many of his comments were statements frequently heard in the [...]

  • Def Jam, Astralwerks Launch Label Divisions

    Def Jam, Astralwerks Launch Label Divisions in South East Asia

    Universal Music Group today announced what it calls a significant expansion of its recorded music operations across South East Asia with the launch of two new label divisions: Def Jam South East Asia, to focus on the hip-hop scene within the region, and Astralwerks Asia, a label “with a true focus on nurturing talent within Asia across [...]

  • WME Nashville Promotes Becky Gardenhire to

    WME Nashville Promotes Becky Gardenhire to Co-Head

    Becky Gardenhire has been elevated by WME to the role of co-head of the Nashville office, making her the woman holding the highest rank at any agency rooted in the city. Gardenhire joins three other co-heads of WME Nashville, Scott Clayton, Joey Lee and Jay Williams. While Nashville agencies have been caught up in a [...]

  • Kane Brown 52nd Annual CMA Awards,

    CMT Boosts Kane Brown, Luke Combs, Dan + Shay as 'Artists of the Year'

    Country music’s youngest superstars don’t always catch a break with the CMA Awards. When the latest slate of nominations was announced, Kane Brown had none, and Luke Combs had a far-from-leading three. But CMT is making up the difference by including these two ascendants as part of their annual “CMT Artists of the Year” slate, [...]

  • Mandy Moore Drops New Single and

    Mandy Moore Drops New Single and Video, First Album in a Decade Due Early 2020

    Just days before the season premiere of her NBC show “This Is Us,” Mandy Moore dropped a new song and video called “When I Wasn’t Watching.” The song is the lead single from her first album in a decade, which is slated for release early next year. The song was produced by longtime collaborator Mike [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content