Off Broadway Review: ‘The Old Friends’

Posthumous premiere of this Horton Foote play eventually hits its stride with a strong cast


Veanne Cox, Adam LeFevre, Lois Smith, Betty Buckley, Cotter Smith, Novella Nelson, Hallie Foote, Sean Lyons, Melle Powers.

Going to a Horton Foote play is like catching up with good friends and friendly enemies at a family reunion. His posthumous debut “The Old Friends” is only now having its world premiere (earlier versions date back almost half a century) with a formidable cast led by Betty Buckley, Veanne Cox and Hallie Foote as three of these unruly characters. There’s a lot of exposition to get through before the festivities can begin, but once the awkward preliminaries are over and the cast hits its stride, we can relax and enjoy the endearing monsters that Foote has created.

All the elements are in place for another bittersweet chapter in the playwright’s continuing saga of life in Harrison, Tex., with a cast of characters we’ve met or at least heard of elsewhere in the scribe’s plays.  Two families bound by blood, marriage and ancient feuds come together in the fall of 1965 for a happy occasion — the return of a prodigal son and his wife — and end up in mortal combat.

The basic storytelling chores of identifying the characters and accounting for their past and present relationships take up so much of the lengthy first scene that the news of a sudden death lands with a thud.   Although the problem is built into the text, helmer Michael Wilson, Foote’s longtime go-to director, might have taken bolder measures to resolve it. Eventually, though, strong characterization and thesping prevail in this story of three women locked in romantic battle over the same man.

The titular head of the Borden-Price household, Mamie Borden (Lois Smith — who else?), is but a shadow of the heartless landowner and manipulative matriarch we’ve heard about.  Having signed over the family estate to her grasping daughter Julia (viciously funny Veanne Cox) and Julia’s cloddish husband, Albert Price (Adam LeFevre, master of the slow burn), the widowed Mamie has lost the last bargaining chip that once made her word law in this house.

Smith plays Mamie with a touch of vagueness, suggesting she may be losing her mental faculties along with her money and political capital.  But this veteran thesp shrewdly allows Mamie to rally when someone asks whatever became of a certain local beauty queen.  “She was burned to death in a New Orleans rooming house,” she snaps.  “She had no money left.”

It’s a brilliant line, not only a penetrating look into Mamie’s character and materialistic values, but also a telling example of the matter-of-fact fatalism reflected in Foote’s deadpan humor.

Having bullied her mother and her brother Hugo out of the family fortune, Julia is the new queen of the manor, and in Cox’s comically caustic perf, she’s every bit her mother’s daughter — bossy and bitchy and ruthless about money.  But Julia’s fatal flaw is her vanity, which makes her a figure of ridicule when she struts around (in gaudy outfits designed with sweet savagery by David C. Woolard), trying to seduce every man in sight.

Foote’s unforgiving character study of Julia is matched and outclassed by his even nastier portrait of her “friend” and nemesis, Gertrude Hayhurst Sylvester Ratliff.  Played by Buckley in bravura style and with great gusto, Gertrude is the prima diva in this crowd, a not-so-subtle caricature of a Texas matron of a certain age and social class: recently widowed, seriously alcoholic, and indecently rich — so rich that she’s grown accustomed to getting whatever she wants just by pointing at it.  Buckley takes this marvelous monster to her heart, giving free rein to her acquisitive greed and making no apologies for her vulgarity.

Assuming (for the most part, rightly) that she can buy people with the same ease that she purchases jewelry, Gertrude is determined to acquire her brother-in-law, Howard (Cotter Smith), for her charm bracelet.   She’s already made him her constant companion, as well as the manager of her vast farming interests, and is now aiming to make him her next husband.  And the drunker she gets, the more demanding, so it looks like curtains for poor Howard.

But Foote has one more wild card to play in this pack of Jokers, a hand that saves the play from tipping over into total pessimism.  This plot twist involves the just-widowed Sibyl Borden and engages the professional skills of the ever-amazing Hallie Foote, the playwright’s daughter and still the finest interpreter of his work.  Nobody plays stillness the way Foote does, with her hands folded quietly in her lap and her huge eyes open to danger.

It’s impossible to look away from the outrageous antics of Gertrude and Julia and their hapless male consorts, but this is the character you really want to watch to understand the subtle dynamics of a Horton Foote play.

Popular on Variety

Off Broadway Review: 'The Old Friends'

Signature Theater Company; 294 seats; $25 top  Opened Sept. 12, 2013.  Reviewed Sept. 7.  Running time:  TWO HOURS, 5 MIN.


A Signature Theater company presentation of a play in two acts by Horton Foote. 


Directed by Michael Wilson.  Sets, Jeff Cowie; costumes, David C. Woolard; lighting, Rui Rita; original music & sound, John Gromada; wigs & hair, Paul Huntley;  dialect coach, Gillian Lane-Plescia; choreographer, Peter Pucci; fight direction, Mark Olsen; production stage manager, Cole P. Bonenberger.


Veanne Cox, Adam LeFevre, Lois Smith, Betty Buckley, Cotter Smith, Novella Nelson, Hallie Foote, Sean Lyons, Melle Powers.

More Legit

  • The Sound Inside review

    Broadway Review: 'The Sound Inside' Starring Mary-Louise Parker

    Mary-Louise Parker will take your breath away with her deeply felt and sensitively drawn portrait of a tenured Yale professor who treasures great literature, but has made no room in her life for someone to share that love with. The other thesp in this two-hander is Will Hochman, endearing in the supportive role of a [...]

  • Little Shop of Horrors review

    Off Broadway Review: 'Little Shop of Horrors'

    With its strains of kitschy doo-wop and its sci-fi B-movie inspirations, the quaint 1982 musical “Little Shop of Horrors” hardly seems a thing of modern-day revivalism, even despite its touches of S&M. Yet this year alone, not only is there an Off Broadway production of the blackly comic “Little Shop” featuring Jonathan Groff of Netflix’s [...]

  • The Lightning Thief review musical

    Broadway Review: 'The Lightning Thief,' The Musical

    “It’s a lot to take in right now,” says Percy Jackson, the teen hero of “The Lightning Thief,” the kid-centric fantasy musical (based on the popular Y.A. novel) that’s now on Broadway after touring the country and playing an Off Broadway run. You could say that’s a bit of an understatement from contemporary teen Percy [...]

  • The Rose Tattoo review

    Broadway Review: 'The Rose Tattoo' Starring Marisa Tomei

    “The Rose Tattoo” is what happens when a poet writes a comedy — something strange, but kind of lovely. The same might be said of director Trip Cullman’s production: Strange, if not exactly lovely. Even Marisa Tomei, so physically delicate and expressively refined, seems an odd choice to play the lusty and passionate protagonist, Serafina [...]

  • Obit-Roy-B

    Former NATO President Roy B. White Dies at 93

    Roy B. White, former president and chairman of the National Association of Theater Owners, died of natural causes Oct. 11 in Naples, Fla. He was 93. White ran the 100-screen independent theater circuit, Mid–States Theaters Inc. In addition to his career, he did extensive work on behalf of charities and non-profits. He was vice president [...]

  • Soft Power review

    Off Broadway Review: 'Soft Power'

    The “culture-clash musical” is a familiar template, in which a white American protagonist — waving the flag of individuality, optimism and freedom — trumps and tramps over the complexities of that which is foreign, challenging or “other.” David Henry Hwang and Jeanine Tesori’s “Soft Power,” the new “play with a musical” at Off Broadway’s Public [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content