×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Legit Review: ‘Peter and Alice’

Childhood haunts two famous muses in new John Logan play starring Judi Dench

“What is growing up, precisely?” That’s an unusually loaded question since it’s asked by the woman who inspired “Alice in Wonderland” of the man who inspired “Peter Pan.” Having issued the challenge, Judi Dench’s Alice and Ben Whishaw’s Peter then proceed to compare how their dominant — and possibly detrimental — gilded childhoods shaped their lives. Although John Logan’s speculative new play brims with ideas illustrated by Michael Grandage’s handsomely designed London production, its lack of a motor means that only at the very end does it deliver on its intriguing premise.

Although his protagonists are known to have met just once in a bookshop prior to a Lewis Carroll centenary exhibition in 1932, Logan has free rein. Nothing is known about what the two of them said to each other.

His invention starts with wary formality between them. Thirtysomething Peter attempts to disguise his nervousness while the 80-year-old Alice presents surface high status. But Peter’s dismissal of Alice’s easily trotted-out, idealized version of what Carroll’s fiction did for her own life — “I feel I was given a gift” — leads both to reconsider. Christopher Oram’s dusty bookshop backroom flies out to reveal a gaily colored toy theater of their imagination.

Between them, they conjure up not only their respective authors Carroll (Nicholas Farrell) and J.M. Barrie (Derek Riddell) but their fictional selves. Olly Alexander darts about as bright-eyed, sharp-edged Peter with Ruby Bentall’s self-composed Alice in Wonderland forever trapped in the iconic dress supplied by Tenniel’s original illustration.

At its best, this art/life animation of figures in a landscape transcends its echo of Sondheim’s “Sunday in the Park With George.” It rings particularly true that while Peter and Alice can interrogate each other’s version of their past, they find it far harder to square up to their own demons. Both of them deal in denial and the play consists of them peeling back layers of it.

Lurking behind what Carroll described as the “golden gleam” of idealized memory are inchoate desire and the death of innocence. It’s to Logan’s credit that as they each face up to the dangerously mixed motives of the men who shaped them, there is no easy revelation of a single unified “truth.” Mercifully, the play refuses an overly neat conclusion about how one should deal with a painful past and grow up.

There is, however, no imperative or urgency to the encounter. Using the potency of these fabled childhoods as a framework, Logan is examining erotic obsession and its suppression, self-determination, the consolations and casualties of fantasy and more. But without gathering momentum to hold the audience, it becomes a fantasia on themes rather than a developing drama. There are touching moments — death stalks both Peter and Alice’s lives — but too much is patiently explained. Subtext is replaced by hints of withheld information, the uncovering of which feels predictable.

Initially amusingly impervious, Dench deftly shows Alice using shrewdness as a defense. Released into the world of memory, she effortlessly suggests girlhood and, best of all, listens like a hawk. So too does hangdog Whishaw, his arms awkwardly clamped to his thin frame, his hands neurotically scrabbling in his dowdy jacket pockets. His eyes darting about, he looks exhausted and victimized by his past, an affecting contrast to Dench’s Alice who steers a path through life’s difficulties to self-acceptance.

The nostalgic Victorian world created by the design team is highly evocative. At the end of the penultimate scene, hard-won adulthood returns as the childhood landscape is replaced by the lowering return of the dowdy bookshop set. The effect of childhood disappearing is unexpectedly moving, but that physical image underlines the feeling that the evening is theatrical rather than dramatic.

Peter and Alice

Noel Coward Theater, London; 946 seats; £57.50 ($87) top

A Michael Grandage Company presentation of a play in one act by John Logan. Directed by Michael Grandage.

Sets and costumes, Christopher Oram; lighting, Paule Constable; sound and music, Adam Cork; production stage manager, Sophie Gabszewicz. Opened, reviewed March 25, 2013. Running time: 1 HOUR, 25 MIN.

With Ben WhishawJudi Dench, Nicholas Farrell, Derek Riddell, Olly Alexander, Ruby Bentall,  Stefano Braschi.

Legit Review: 'Peter and Alice'

More Legit

  • Bryan Cranston on the Exhausting Joys

    Listen: Bryan Cranston on the Exhausting Joys of Broadway

    For anyone who doubts that being a Broadway actor can be grueling, let Bryan Cranston set you straight. Listen to this week’s podcast below: “There is a cumulative effect of fatigue that happens on the Broadway schedule that no amount of sleep the night before is going to wash away,” the Emmy and Tony-winning actor [...]

  • Jeff Daniels Variety Broadway to Kill

    How 'To Kill a Mockingbird' Beat the Odds to Deliver a Broadway Smash

    Jeff Daniels slumps into a chair in the Shubert Theatre, grasping an oversize Starbucks and looking bone-crushingly exhausted. His eyelids are heavy, and he seems like a man in desperate need of rest. It’s easy to understand why. It’s late March, and Daniels has just given his 100th Broadway performance as Atticus Finch, the small-town attorney [...]

  • ZZ Top, Caesars Entertainment Team on

    ZZ Top, Caesars Team for Jukebox Musical 'Sharp Dressed Man' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Rock and Roll Hall of Fame inductees ZZ Top and Caesars Entertainment are developing “Sharp Dressed Man,” a jukebox musical set to open next year in Las Vegas featuring the band’s greatest hits. Members Billy Gibbons, Dusty Hill and Frank Beard are all serving as executive producers. “Sharp Dressed Man” is described as an “outrageous, [...]

  • Williamstown Theater Festival 2016 season

    Marisa Tomei Starring in Broadway Revival of 'The Rose Tattoo'

    Marisa Tomei will star in the Broadway revival of Tennessee Williams’ “The Rose Tattoo.” The Oscar-winning actress will play Serafina, a part previously performed by the likes of Maureen Stapleton and Anna Magnani. It’s also a role that Tomei is familiar with, having starred in a Williamstown Theatre Festival production in 2016. “The Rose Tattoo” [...]

  • White Pearl review

    London Theater Review: 'White Pearl'

    Playwright Anchuli Felicia King dismantles the Asian market in this misfiring satire at London’s Royal Court Theatre. “White Pearl” makes a case that those seeking to make inroads into the Far East, perceiving a new El Dorado, are no better that colonial conquistadors of an earlier age — and entirely unequipped to understand the specifics [...]

  • Signature Theatre Celebrates Millionth Subsidized Ticket

    Signature Theatre Offers $35 Subsidized Tickets, Celebrates Millionth Sold

    Just the other night, a Manhattan cab driver told Signature Theatre executive director Harold Wolpert that he couldn’t afford to take his girlfriend to a show. In response, Wolpert motioned to his theater, saying that they offer $35 subsidized tickets. The driver said he’d try it out. “It was a great moment,” Wolpert said. “We’re [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content