You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Of Broadway’s ‘American Idol’ Grads, Fantasia Is Most Likely to Succeed

Grammy winner and reality competition vet confirmed to make Broadway return this fall

With Fantasia Barrino’s toplining stint in upcoming stage musical “After Midnight” now confirmed, producers have locked in the Broadway return of the only “American Idol” alum to drive box office to the heights that matched producers’ hopes for the former stars of the Fox reality competish.

When “Idol” first became a ratings powerhouse in 2002, Rialto denizens saw a potential golden ticket: Here was a hugely popular TV show generating new batches of high-profile singers and releasing them into the world, at which point at least some of them could likely be lured to Broadway for B.O.-goosing musical bookings.

But with the supremacy of “American Idol” having crested in the recent years, Barrino has been the standout in the long list of new Broadway thesps yielded by “Idol” over the past decade.

The roster of former “Idol” contestants to land on the Main Stem has included Clay Aiken (“Spamalot”), Constantine Maroulis (“Rock of Ages”), Justin Guarini (“Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown”), Diana DeGarmo (“Hairspray”), Jordin Sparks (“In the Heights”), Tamyra Gray (“Rent”) and Taylor Hicks (“Grease”). Crystal Bowersox (“Always… Patsy Cline”) and Bo Bice (“Pump Boys and Dinettes”) have been announced for upcoming shows, but both of those have since been postponed.

Maroulis, who toplined the revival of “Jekyll and Hyde” on tour and on Broadway earlier this year, and Guarini, whose Rialto credits include “American Idiot” and the upcoming “Romeo and Juliet,” have both grown into regular Main Stem presences, but neither has lit any fires at the box office.

Of all of those past “Idol” entrants, the closest thing to a B.O. driver was Aiken, whose 2008 stint in “Spamalot” drove sales up the week he arrived and prompted a slump the week after he left. (His return engagement later that year yielded less notable sales jumps.)

It’s Barrino, however, who can take a lot of credit for rejuvenating a softening production. Before producers booked her to play the title role, the 2005 musical “Color Purple” had begun to show signs of aging, particularly during Broadway’s traditionally fallow winter weeks. But when Barrino joined the cast in April 2007, sales soared a whopping $365,000, or 40%, returning “Purple” to the millionaires’ club and keeping figures elevated all the way through the year-end holidays.

Whether she’ll show the same kind of box office muscle in “After Midnight” remains to be seen. But just as the diverse audience demo of tuner “Color Purple” seemed to share a generous overlap with Barrino’s own crowd of fans, “After Midnight,” a revue centering on the Duke Ellington years at Harlem’s Cotton Club, also seems a snug fit.

Barrino’s “Color Purple” gig was tubthumped by an announcement on “Idol” and a seg on “Oprah.” The performer, a 2011 Grammy winner who released her fourth studio album in April, hasn’t made any similar publicity moves for “Midnight” yet, although she did tease her upcoming Rialto gig (without naming the show) in an interview on “The Today Show.” Her stint in “After Midnight” begins with the start of previews Oct. 18 and runs through Feb. 9, when producers intend to announce another notable name to fill her shoes.

Although few “Idol” alums have driven Main Stem business at individual titles, many legiters would argue that Broadway overall has benefited from the surge of pop culture prominence for performance-oriented series such as “Idol” and, later, “Glee.” But this fall industry types will nonetheless be watching to see whether Barrino still has the “Idol”-spawned box office power she once did.

More Legit

  • A Christmas Carol review

    Broadway Review: 'A Christmas Carol'

    Those expecting a traditional take on Charles Dickens’ classic holiday perennial may be in for a shock at the new Broadway version of “A Christmas Carol.” Or at least they might be terribly perplexed by this dour production, whose additions only subtract from the potency of the transformative tale. While there have been many adaptations [...]

  • Timothee Chalamet poses for photographers at

    Timothée Chalamet to Make London Stage Debut With Eileen Atkins in '4000 Miles'

    Timothee Chalemet is set to take to the London stage for the first time, appearing next spring in Amy Herzog’s Pulitzer Prize-nominated play “4000 Miles.” Matthew Warchus will direct the production at The Old Vic, which will also star Eileen Atkins (“The Crown,” “Gosford Park”). The play opens April 2020. It turns on the story [...]

  • Jonathan Groff

    Listen: Jonathan Groff Knows He's a Spitter

    If you’ve seen “Little Shop of Horrors” — the starry revival headlined by Jonathan Groff in a small Off Broadway theater — you probably noticed that Groff spits a lot when he speaks onstage. He’ll be the first to tell you that he’s been a spitter as long as he can remember, but “Little Shop” [...]

  • Key Largo

    L.A. Theater Review: Andy Garcia in 'Key Largo'

    Would “Casablanca” make a good play? Guess what: It was first produced on stage as “Everybody Comes to Rick’s.” How about “Key Largo,” the black-and-white Bogie-and-Bacall vehicle in which a handful of misfits find themselves trapped in a South Florida hotel while a hurricane rages outside? In fact, the 1948 John Huston film was adapted [...]

  • Sophia Anne Caruso and Alex Brightman'Beetlejuice'

    How 'Beetlejuice: The Musical' Became a Broadway Turnaround Story

    Christopher Kuczewski is what you’d call a Netherling. It’s a reference to the netherworld inhabitants who populate “Beetlejuice: The Musical,” the off-beat adaptation of the 1988 hit film that’s becoming an unlikely Broadway turnaround story. And that designation, which has been given to superfans of the show, goes a long way towards explaining how a [...]

  • Lena Waithe'The Inheritance' Broadway play opening,

    Lena Waithe, Anderson Cooper Attend Broadway Opening of 'The Inheritance'

    “The Inheritance” pulls viewers in many directions — toward pain and hope, trauma and healing. It’s what brought stars like Andy Cohen, Anderson Cooper, Sarah Jessica Parker, Matthew Broderick and Lena Waithe to Broadway on Sunday — a chance to heal, to remember and grieve. Also in attendance for the premiere at the Barrymore Theater [...]

  • Touching the Void review

    West End Review: 'Touching the Void'

    It shouldn’t work. Attempting to make effective theatre out of scaling a mountain, facing disaster thousands of feet up in the freezing cold and enduring a drawn-out facedown with death is surely a preposterous idea. Yet that is exactly what playwright David Grieg and director Tom Morris and his ideally meshed creative team have done. [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content