×

For Broadway Plays, A Complex Calculus for Success

As "Vanya and Sonia" illustrates, celebrity is part but not all of the equation

It’s become a formula for Broadway success: Pick a well-known play, cast a star, limit the run to drive up demand and watch box office take off.

But as Broadway’s current crop of plays now achieve profitability (or fail to), the lineup of recent hits vs. misses serves as a stark reminder that star casting isn’t the only variable in the math of a nonmusical success.

When Tony winning new play “Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike” recouped earlier this week, it became the fifth non-tuner of the 2012-13 season to make it into the black so far. That’s an unusually high number, but one that’s balanced by the fact that the 2012-13 slate included a whopping 26 plays — a record, according to the Broadway League.

Take a look at what worked and what didn’t last season, and it becomes obvious that in most cases it requires more than just a big name on the marquee to draw crowds. For proof, look no further than Alec Baldwin starrer “Orphans,” Scarlett Johansson topliner “Cat on a Hot Tin Roof,” Katie Holmes outing “Dead Accounts” and Paul Rudd project “Grace,” all of which closed in varying shades of the red.

Admittedly, some of the shows that succeeded hewed close to the formula, starting with “Glengarry Glen Ross,” the $3.3 million offering that cast proven sales juggernaut Al Pacino in a well-known David Mamet play with which the actor was already associated thanks to his starring role in the 1992 movie. The revival’s mixed reviews didn’t matter to the auds who made it one of the breakout sellers of the fall.

Popular on Variety

This spring, Tom Hanks topliner “Lucky Guy” (capitalized at $3.6 million) and Bette Midler vehicle “I’ll Eat You Last” ($2.4 million) tweaked the standard recipe, in that both titles were new plays rather than revivals with familiar titles.

That’s a risk, as underscored by “Dead Accounts” and “Grace,” both new works with casts that featured seemingly bankable stars. It turns out only a few thesps can spur boffo box office regardless of the play and its critical reception, and in steering their respective shows into profit, Hanks and Midler join an elite group that also includes Julia Roberts, Denzel Washington and Hugh Jackman.

Even though the fall revival of “The Heiress” (price tag: $3 million) also made it into the black, topliner Jessica Chastain hasn’t yet broken into that circle. The show, which generally posted middling sales, seemingly benefited not only from being a revival of a play based on a classic novel (Henry James’ “Washington Square”), but also from a coincidence of timing: The production’s final weeks coincided with a burst of “Zero Dark Thirty” Oscar publicity for then-nominee Chastain, who simultaneously attracted press as the star of “Mama,” the horror pic that opened surprisingly strong in January.

Making back its $2.75 million capitalization in 17 weeks, “Vanya and Sonia” might have been the riskiest proposition of the bunch. It’s a new title — the latest by Christopher Durang, beloved in the legit world but not well-known outside of it — and while its stars David Hyde Pierce and Sigourney Weaver are familiar to TV and bigscreen auds, neither is a box office powerhouse.

But “Vanya and Sonia” benefited from a principle proven the prior season by “The Best Man”: Sometimes you don’t need a single, big-ticket thesp when you’ve got a critical mass of well-known faces.

“Best Man” turned into a solid hit with a cast that included Candice Bergen, Eric McCormack, Angela Lansbury, John Laroquette and, later in the run, Cybill Shepard, John Stamos and Kristin Davis. Similarly, both Hyde Pierce, star of rerun staple “Frasier,” and former “Alien” badass Weaver have achieved a degree of pop-culture prominence that, when combined, helped attract theatergoers to a new title even before the strong reviews came in.

Figure in the Tony win for new play, and “Vanya and Sonia” had a number of factors beyond its cast contributing to the show’s success.

Although stars aren’t solely responsible for any show’s sales, it seems likely that none of the hit plays of 2012-13 could have done it without a familiar name or two.

With the 2013-14 lineup of plays including Orlando Bloom in “Romeo and Juliet,” Daniel Craig and Rachel Weisz in “Betrayal,” Billy Crystal in “700 Sundays” and Patrick Stewart and Ian McKellen in “Waiting for Godot” and “No Man’s Land,” that seems to be a fact Broadway producers know well.

More Legit

  • West Side Story review

    'West Side Story': Theater Review

    Whittled down to one hour and forty-five minutes, “West Side Story” – with book by Arthur Laurents, music by Leonard Bernstein, lyrics by Stephen Sondheim, and choreography by Jerome Robbins — has grown exceedingly dark and mislaid some of its moving parts in the new Broadway revival from edgy Belgian director Ivo Van Hove. (Can [...]

  • The Inheritance review

    'The Inheritance' Closing in March After Box Office Struggles

    “The Inheritance,” a sprawling and ambitious epic that grappled with the legacy of the AIDS epidemic, will close on March 15. The two-part play has struggled mightily at the box office despite receiving strong reviews. Last week, it grossed $345,984, or 52% of its capacity, a dispiriting number for a show that was reported to [...]

  • MCC theater presents 'Alice By Heart'

    Steven Sater on Adapting 'Alice by Heart' From a Musical to a Book

    When producers approached lyricist Steven Sater (“Spring Awakening”) to adapt Lewis Carroll’s “Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland” into a musical, his initial reaction was to recoil. His initial thought was that the book didn’t have a beginning, middle and an ending. But Sater pulled it off with his production of “Alice By Heart.” After an off-Broadway [...]

  • The Lehman Trilogy review

    Sam Mendes' 'Lehman Trilogy' Kicks off Ahmanson's New Season

    Sam Mendes’ “The Lehman Trilogy,” which took London’s West End by storm will be part of the Ahmanson’s lineup for the 2020-21 season. It will be joined by Broadway hits “Hadestown” and “To Kill a Mockingbird.” Artistic director Michael Ritchie announced the season that will also feature four fan favorites and another production to be [...]

  • Zoe Caldwell Dead

    Zoe Caldwell, Four-Time Tony Winner, Dies at 86

    Zoe Caldwell, an Australian actress with a talent for illuminating the human side of imposing icons such as Cleopatra and Maria Callas in a career that netted her four Tony Awards, died on Sunday due to complications from Parkinson’s disease, according to her son Charlie Whitehead. She was 86. Caldwell occasionally appeared in television and [...]

  • Cambodian Rock Band interview

    Listen: How 'Cambodian Rock Band' Became One of the Most Produced Plays in the U.S.

    One of the hottest trends in American theater this season is Cambodian surf rock from the 1970s — and that’s thanks to “Cambodian Rock Band.” Listen to this week’s Stagecraft podcast below: Playwright Lauren Yee’s genre-bending stage show, part family drama and part rock concert, has become one of the most-produced plays in the U.S. this season. [...]

  • Revenge Song

    Vampire Cowboys' 'Revenge Song': L.A. Theater Review

    There’s highbrow, there’s lowbrow, and then there’s however you might classify Vampire Cowboys, the anarchic New York City theater company whose diverse productions . It’s radical, “good taste”-flouting counter-programming for the vast swaths of the population left unserved by high-dollar, stiff-collar theater options. Vampire Cowboys’ raucous new show, “Revenge Song,” is unlike anything else that’s [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content