×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘The Rooftops’

Considered Algeria's most important living director, Merzak Allouache delivers one of his best films with this multi-stranded tale.

With:

Nassima Belmihoub, Adila Bendimerad, Aissa Chouat, Mourad Khen, Akhram Djeghim, Amal Kateb, Djemil Adlan, Ahmed Dahane, Mohammed Jouhri, Hamid Remas, Ahcene Benzerari, Hamza Boukrif, Yasmine Abdelmoumen, Abderrahmane Ikariouane, Nabil Asli, Myriam Ait el Hadj, Aida Kechoud, Kader Affak, Rachid Benalal, Mohammed Ghouli, Djamil Ghouli, Fethi Nadjem, Meriem Medjkane, Mohamed Takiret, Redouane Merabet, Mebarek Faradji, Salima Abada, Nadjib Oulebsir, Mohamed Bendaoud. (Arabic, French dialogue)

Following the 2012 Cannes-preemed “The Repentant,” the man considered Algeria’s most important living director is on a roll with “The Rooftops,” easily one of Merzak Allouache’s best. Encompassing five different Algiers neighborhoods organized according to the five calls to prayer, Allouache presents a microcosm of Algerian society to expose the nation’s sharp class and religious divides, including a metaphoric representation of the country itself that’s astonishingly bold even if the symbolism borders on the heavy-handed. While some nuances will work best for locals, “Rooftops” combines choral complexity with accusatory critique, and deserves fest attention along with Francophone theatrical play.

After years in the director’s seat, Allouache has earned the right to tackle multiple stories, proving he can juggle them all in a manner that satisfies each point and every character. Like most of his best works, this is without question an issue film, and rather than limiting himself to fundamentalism or the legacy of the civil war, he’s incorporated the entire spectrum, crucially foregrounding his despair at a nation so inured to violence that it no longer means anything.

In the Notre Dame d’Afrique section of the city, Adlan (Mohamed Takiret) is being tortured by order of Hamoud (Mourad Khen) in a half-finished apartment block. He’s promised he can go back to France if he’ll just sign a paper; Allouache doesn’t explicitly reveal the nature of the dispute, though it clearly has to do with underhanded real-estate dealings. They have to hide when a director (Salima Abada) and two crewmen come to scout the view from the roof for their docu “Algiers, Jewel of the Arab World.”

Popular on Variety

In the Bab el-Oued district, Selouma (Nassima Belmihoub) has a squat on the roof of an upscale apartment complex with her drug-addled great-nephew, Krimo (Djemil Adlan), and his half-crazed mother, Aicha (Amal Kateb). When the landlord (Hamid Remas) comes to evict them, Krimo takes desperate action.

Uncle Larbi (Rachid Benalal) lives shackled in a wooden cage on the roof of a building in the Casbah, telling stories, through the slats, of Independence War heroics to young Layla (Myriam Ait el Hadj). Toward evening the roof is taken over by an Islamist prayer meeting during which a preacher (Kader Affak) praises the late Muammar Gaddafi as a martyr to the Muslim cause.

A band meets on a rooftop downtown to practice and hash out ideas for future gigs. Assia (Adila Bendimerad) is spooked by Neila (Meriem Medjkane), a scarved woman on a neighboring terrace who’s been staring at her all day. When a man comes out and beats Neila in full view, Assia demands they do something but her male colleagues tell her it’s not their business, and besides, he may be a brother or husband.

The final rooftop is in Belcourt, where alcoholic Halim (Aissa Chouat) has a squat in a grungy washroom and charges people for occasional use of the space. Sheikh Lamine (Ahcene Benzerari) arrives, renting a room where he pretends to offer pastoral care to Fatiha (Yasmine Abdelmoumen), though he’s really getting his jollies by having her take off her niqab and beating out her evil influences.

Each story begins with the first call to prayer and ends by the day’s last chant of the muezzin, shuttling back and forth between characters without dropping the threads and providing just enough information to keep interest piqued. Though each person is a bit too much of a stand-in for a type or concept, they’re all developed just enough to feel real. Corruption is an inescapable undercurrent, tied to real-estate speculation and absentee landlords.

Class is also a key; many rooftops have illegal constructions where the working class live, tolerated by their bourgeois neighbors but treated as lesser creatures. Gender relations are equally frayed, even among Westernized middle-class young people like the band members. Allouache has a healthy, if biting, sense of humor, enjoyably apparent in how he draws the entitled movie director, boasting of her prize at the Oran Film Festival and demanding her cameraman bypass the Christian and Jewish cemeteries while panning over the city; as she tells her crew, why include such “foreign” places in a film about the Algerian capital? There’s also a terrific, unexpected scene when a police chief (Mohammed Jouhri) pays Selouma a call.

However, the most audacious figure of all is Uncle Larbi, living off the past with grand stories of questionable accuracy, chained up by Islamists yet unwilling to escape once freed. Uncle Larbi, of course, is Algeria itself, so used to violence that the value of human life has become cheapened. “The Rooftops” ranks alongside Allouache’s “Bab el-Oued City” and “The Repentant” as some of the most forceful self-critiques to come out of Algeria, and while the latter is more focused, and arguably a better film, the director’s latest has plenty of muscle.

Visuals are well balanced between edgy handheld and beautiful panoramas that take in the city in all its variety, from well-to-do Mediterranean apartments on the Corniche to the higgledy-piggledy layers of the Casbah. The use of space outside the frame is notable, and editing is first-rate.

Film Review: 'The Rooftops'

Reviewed at Venice Film Festival (competing), Sept. 6, 2013. (Also in London Film Festival – Debate.) Running time: 91 MIN. Original title: "Es-Stouh"

Production:

(Algeria-France) A Baya Films, JBA Prod. production, with the participation of Fdatic Ministere Algerien de la Culture, Aide aux Cinema du Monde, Cine plus. (International sales: Elle Driver, Paris.) Produced by Merzak Allouache, Marianne Dumoulin, Jacques Bidou.

Crew:

Directed, written by Merzak Allouache. Camera (color), Frederic Derrien; editor, Sylvie Gadmer; music, Allouache; sound, Philippe Bouchez, Xavier Thibault, Julien Perez; assistant director, Nadjib Oulebsir.

With:

Nassima Belmihoub, Adila Bendimerad, Aissa Chouat, Mourad Khen, Akhram Djeghim, Amal Kateb, Djemil Adlan, Ahmed Dahane, Mohammed Jouhri, Hamid Remas, Ahcene Benzerari, Hamza Boukrif, Yasmine Abdelmoumen, Abderrahmane Ikariouane, Nabil Asli, Myriam Ait el Hadj, Aida Kechoud, Kader Affak, Rachid Benalal, Mohammed Ghouli, Djamil Ghouli, Fethi Nadjem, Meriem Medjkane, Mohamed Takiret, Redouane Merabet, Mebarek Faradji, Salima Abada, Nadjib Oulebsir, Mohamed Bendaoud. (Arabic, French dialogue)

More Film

  • NENT Group to Focus on Scripted

    Scandinavia's NENT Group to Focus on Scripted Content Production, Distribution

    Nordic Entertainment Group (NENT Group), one of Scandinavia’s biggest media groups, is set to reorganise and focus on scripted drama and film production and distribution. The company is looking to bring in a minority equity partner on board to bolster its scripted drama production business. As part of the reorg, NENT Group will divest its [...]

  • Goteborg Film Festival The Gynecological Cinema

    Anna Odell Puts Men in a Gynaecological Chair

    After William Castle’s “Percepto!” or John Waters’ “Odorama,” it seems like the time has come for Swedish provocateur Anna Odell’s “The Gynaecological Cinema Chair” – an interactive experience created specially for this year’s Göteborg Film Festival. A concept that’s more than just an attention-grabbing gimmick, however, as the director behind 2013’s “The Reunion” was quick [...]

  • The-Intruder

    Watch the Trailer from Just Announced Berlin Competition Entry ‘The Intruder’ (EXCLUSIVE)

    MADRID  —  Just minutes after the Berlinale confirmed on Wednesday its selection in main competition, the pedigree producers of Argentine Natalia Meta’s “The Intruder” (“El Prófugo”) have dropped a first teaser-trailer for what has been described as a “pyscho-sexual fantastic thriller.” They have also confirmed more details of one of the buzziest new titles from [...]

  • Roman Polanski’s ‘An Officer and a

    Roman Polanski’s ‘An Officer and a Spy’ Leads Cesar Awards Nominations

    Roman Polanski’s “An Officer and a Spy” is leading the race for the Cesar Awards, France’s top film honors, with 12 nominations, followed by Ladj Ly’s Oscar-nominated “Les Miserables.” “An Officer and a Spy” earned nominations for best film, director, actor (Jean Dujardin), cinematography, set design, costume and music, among others. Although he’s been at [...]

  • Berlin Competition Lineup Features Kelly Reichardt,

    Berlin Competition Lineup Revealed: Sally Potter, Kelly Reichardt, Eliza Hittman, Abel Ferrara

    The Berlin International Film Festival has unveiled its 2020 line-up, with 18 films playing in competition from directors such as Abel Ferrara, Sally Potter, Christian Petzold, Hong Sangsoo, Kelly Reichardt and Eliza Hittman. Abel Ferrara’s Willem Dafoe starrer “Siberia” is a world premiere in competition, as is Sally Potter’s “The Roads Not Taken.” Among the [...]

  • Amy Ryan appears in Lost Girls

    'Lost Girls': Film Review

    It’s exciting, and fascinating, to see a great director of documentaries try his or her hand at a dramatic feature, since in theory the essential skill set should all be there. The best documentarians possess an acute visual sense, and they are all, of course, potent storytellers. Yet for every attempt at this sort of [...]

  • "Jojo Rabbit" and "Schitts Creek" Win

    'Jojo Rabbit,' 'Masked Singer' and 'Maleficent' Win Top Honors at Costume Designers Guild Awards

    The Costume Designers Guild handed out its trophies for the 22nd annual CDG Awards with “Jojo Rabbit” and “Maleficent: Mistress of Evil” receiving top honors among the costumers. In the TV category, the hit “The Masked Singer” and designer Marina Toybina beat out reigning designer Zaldy (“RuPaul’s Drag Race”) for excellence in variety, reality-competition, live [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content