Film Review: ‘My Father and the Man in Black’

This uniquely intertwined dual portrait of a country music icon and his Jewish-Canadian promoter should attract a diverse audience.


Jonathan Holiff, Gary Holiff, David Disher, Joshua Robinson, Dan Champagne, Elli Hollands.

Providing proof of the power of archival artifacts, “My Father and the Man in Black” is Jonathan Holiff’s documentary about his father, Saul, Johnny Cash’s manager for much of the singer’s checkered career. Holiff Sr.’s extensive audio diaries and taped phone conversations with Cash give authentic voice to the film’s otherwise stodgy re-creations of this true odd couple’s stormy relationship. Plus, legal documents attesting to the weirdness of Saul’s relationship with his son lend poignancy to the now-hackneyed trend of directors making documentaries about their deceased parents. Opening theatrically Sept. 6 after a lengthy fest tour, this uniquely intertwined dual portrait of a country music icon and his Jewish-Canadian promoter should attract ethnically diverse audiences.

Helmer Holiff dramatically opens the film with his father’s suicide. In a color re-creation, a septuagenarian passes in front of a black-and-white-filmed backdrop of a canceled Cash concert, swallows pills and pulls a black plastic bag over his head. Years later, the director, who barely knew his workaholic dad, discovers a storeroom full of tapes, documents, scrapbooks, photographs and gold records, poring over the accumulated materials in theatrically restaged scenes.

As Holiff listens to his father’s taped diary, the story of a symbiotic partnership unfolds. Stand-ins playing Cash and Saul at various stages of their evolution are interspersed with contemporaneous archival footage. Saul recounts how he nudged Cash’s career toward more prestigious, less narrowly “countrified” venues and first brought June Carter into the act.

Superstardom beckoned. Cash co-starred in a Kirk Douglas Western and headlined triumphant world tours that garnered VIP treatment for star and manager alike.  But Cash’s runaway success triggered runaway drug abuse, and his subsequent out-of-control behavior, which formed the nucleus of 2005’s “Walk the Line,” is here represented by an actor drunkenly driving down rainswept roads when he’s not being arrested for various crimes and misdemeanors (including starting a forest fire).

Because this is Saul’s story, though, pride of place is given to angry telegrams from canceled bookings, which the promoter had to reimburse. His own career soon tanked, since nobody wanted to hire Mr. No-Show. Paralleling Cash’s downward spiral into addiction, Saul’s drinking escalated, scenes of his restless tossing and turning and non-stop alcohol consumption enacted under audio diary excerpts.

After Cash kicked his habit, Saul proved instrumental in arranging his career-changing Folsom and San Quentin concerts. Saul stuck around for Cash’s subsequent religious rebirth, even accepting the role of Caiaphas, the Jew allegedly responsible for the plot against Christ, in Cash’s self-financed film “Gospel Road.”  Meanwhile, he attempted to steer his client away from the non-musical proselytizing that would cost Cash his TV show and much of his fanbase. When the born-again Cash tried to convert his faithful manager, Saul finally quit.

Saul’s memorabilia also attests to matters more personal to the filmmaker, like his oft-repeated desire to spend quality time with his two sons and “toss a ball around.” But an itemized list of every penny spent on Jonathan’s upbringing since birth, used by Saul to justify cashing in the kid’s trust fund, tells a different story.

Documentaries as expressions of filial trauma usually fail to generate audience empathy. But with its posthumous, anguished, first-person confessional revolving around the larger-than-life Man in Black, this one partly transcends its inherent self-indulgence.

Popular on Variety

Film Review: 'My Father and the Man in Black'

Reviewed on DVD, New York, Aug. 21, 2013.  Running time: 87 MIN.


(Documentary — Canada) A New Chapter production. Produced by Tanya Lyn Nazarec, Jennifer Phillips, Jonathan Holiff. Executive producer, Jeff Paikin.


Directed by Jonathan Holiff. Camera (color/B&W, HD), Rene Ohashi; editors, Rob Ruzic, Nick Harauz; music, Michael Timmins; production designer, Adam Weir; art director, Matt Middleton; costume designer Robyn Rosenberg; sound designer, Daniel Pellerin.


Jonathan Holiff, Gary Holiff, David Disher, Joshua Robinson, Dan Champagne, Elli Hollands.

More Film

  • Michael Shannon Benedict Cumberbatch Tuppence Middleton

    How Martin Scorsese Saved 'Current War' From Harvey Weinstein

    Director Alfonso Gomez-Rejon finally gets to release his version of his long-in-the-making “The Current War.” The film, about the competition between Thomas Edison and George Westinghouse, was originally set to be distributed by the Weinstein Company after Harvey Weinstein recut it, much to Gomez-Rejon’s chagrin. To make matters worse, Weinstein premiered the movie at the [...]

  • 42west logo

    42West Co-CEO Allan Mayer Hospitalized After Car Accident

    42West Co-CEO Allan Mayer is in the hospital due to injuries from an Oct. 17 car accident, Variety has confirmed. The public relations firm described the crash as “serious” and said that he had surgery on Oct. 20 to help repair multiple broken bones. “Allan and his family thank everyone for the outpouring of love and [...]

  • Iron Man Martin Scorsese Francis Ford

    Directors vs. Marvel: A Breakdown of the Criticism

    Despite being the highest-grossing film franchise of all time, the Marvel Cinematic Universe has not been getting any love from critically renowned auteurs, like Martin Scorsese and Francis Ford Coppola. The Marvel pile-on started at the beginning of October and has impassioned many supporters and detractors to give their two cents on whether or not [...]

  • Linda Hamilton, left, and Arnold Schwarzenegger

    Film Review: 'Terminator: Dark Fate'

    Back in 1984, seven years before “The Terminator” spawned a sequel that was big, sprawling, and James Cameron-y enough to elevate the franchise into what felt like the dystopian Marvel spectacle of its day, it’s worth noting that Cameron’s original film was a ruthlessly efficient post-apocalyptic B-movie — a proto-video-game sci-fi nightmare that took its [...]

  • Mountaintop

    Film Review: Neil Young's 'Mountaintop'

    If you ever wished you could be a fly on the wall at a Neil Young recording session, his new film “Mountaintop” may put that desire to the test. Or at least it’ll severely try the patience of any unsuspecting dates who get dragged along by Young fanatics to the movie’s one night in North [...]

  • Universal Screens 'Bride of Frankenstein,' Releases

    Universal Screens 'Bride of Frankenstein,' Releases Franz Waxman Score for First Time

    Halloween is only days away, and what better way to celebrate than with a classic monster movie that’s been fully restored and whose original score has, 84 years later, finally been issued as a soundtrack album? Universal screened its 1935 “Bride of Frankenstein” Monday night to an appreciative audience on the studio lot, following a [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content