Film Review: ‘Is the Man Who Is Tall Happy?’

Michel Gondry doodles while Noam Chomsky philosophizes in an inspired meeting of idiosyncratic minds.


Noam Chomsky, Michel Gondry.

In the toon documentary “Is the Man Who Is Tall Happy?,” conversations between helmer Michel Gondry and philosopher/linguist/political activist Noam Chomsky become very animated indeed, as the director’s rapidly moving pencil adapts Chomsky’s discourse — and Gondry’s own reactions to it — into images. Using a deliberately doodle-y, childish drawing style, Gondry frees up the relationship between a word and what it represents, either by transforming turns of phrase into absurdly literal visual gags, or by making free-form associations that illustrate Chomsky’s central ideas about language. Simultaneously light-hearted and thought-provoking, this felicitous meeting of minds should appeal to fans of both men. 

Though the term “animated documentary” might seem oxymoronic (Gondry admits that the project’s contradictory nature was largely what attracted him to begin with), the “real audio” docu, whereby cartoonists visually riff on prerecorded monologues and conversations, has become a commonplace toon subgenre. In the film, Chomsky often appears in a small square of live-action footage within the frame or is simply heard as voiceover, while Gondry’s interpretations of what Chomsky is saying are almost exclusively handled in reactive animated form.

The animation style initially employs varied artistic strategies, even incorporating yellowed snapshots (from Chomsky’s own photo album?). But Gondry quickly arrives at a fluid, pulsating linear technique that comes to dominate the proceedings. The use of outlines rather than filled-in forms emphasizes the drawings’ sketchy, improvisational nature, their wavering movements giving the impression of constant liveliness (particularly in the depiction of hair, which vibrates like thought waves). Also deft is Gondry’s use of “recycled” animation whenever a dropped subject is briefly recapped and taken up again.

Throughout, Gondry fancifully embroiders on Chomsky’s running commentary. Intellectual curiosity is personified as a homunculus toting a potted plant with question marks on its leaves, and Galileo’s questioning of accepted truths is represented as a stairway of “why’s.” Gondry might present ideas as rebuses, as Descartes’ philosophical “tools” are lifted from his treatise, or else embark on his own sentimental flights; when Chomsky first refuses to talk about his late wife, Gondry sketches a cartoon man and woman biking across the top of the frame.

While the lion’s share of the film deals with Chomsky’s passionate belief in the need to skeptically examine seemingly self-evident truths, due diligence is also given to his ideas on the early acquisition of language. Plato’s “Theory of Remembrance” is invoked, but the illustrations are inspired by Chomsky’s own childhood memories, freely and humorously interpreted as a gaggle of aunts dancing around the kitchen where an infant Noam sits on the counter. This playfulness contrasts mightily with the self-important solemnity usually surrounding studies of language and philosophy.

But not everything fits snugly into Gondry’s fairly apolitical worldview. The director gave whimsy a good name in offerings like “Be Kind Rewind” and “The Science of Sleep,” and as if acknowledging his shortcomings, he includes examples of his own fractured-English gaffes, and even audio of him interrupting Chomsky’s perfectly sane criticism of the French government.  Gondry dismisses the subject as too depressing, suggesting Chomsky instead return to reminiscing about his wife.

Some might be tempted to compare Gondry’s mix of philosophy and animation to certain segments of Richard Linklater’s “Waking Life,” but in many ways the French director’s style represents the exact opposite. Linklater’s artists, while encouraged to fly off on tangents, were basically locked down into a computer-enabled form of rotoscoping, a method of tracing from live-action film. That process suggests a close kinship between live-action “reality” and its cartoon manifestation  a relationship at odds with Chomsky’s theories about language, which presuppose a fundamental difference between words and the things they represent.

Gondry’s low-tech approach might even be said to expose the artistic limitations of the big-ticket, reality-based CGI that dominates today’s movie screens.  Equipped with only an old-time Oxberry animation stand, a portable lightbox to facilitate frame-by-frame rendering and the same do-it-yourself gear long accessible to students in animation courses, Gondry and his frisky hieroglyphs successfully convey Chomsky’s concept of language as the fleeting “meanings we impose on fragmentary experience.”

Popular on Variety

Film Review: 'Is the Man Who Is Tall Happy?'

Reviewed at IFC Center, New York, Oct. 30, 2013.  (In DOC NYC.) Running time: 88 MIN.


(Animated Documentary — France) An IFC Films (in U.S.) release of a Sundance Selects presentation of a Sleeping Train production. Produced by Georges Bermann, Michel Gondry, Raffi Adlan, Julie Fong.


Directed by Michel Gondry.  Camera (16mm/HD), Gondry; editors, Adam W. Weber, Sophie Reine; sound, Brent Lestage; sound editors, Gaultier de Faultrier, Susan Goldish; re-recording mixer, de Faultrier; animators, Gondry, Valerie Pirson, Timothee Lemoine.  


Noam Chomsky, Michel Gondry.

More Film

  • Love is the Monster

    Neto Villalobos’ ‘Love is the Monster’ Heads to San Sebastian Co-Pro Forum (EXCLUSIVE)

    Costa Rican director Ernesto “Neto” Villalobos’ third feature, “Love is the Monster,” will participate in September’s San Sebastian Europe-Latin America Co-Production Forum. Having found festival success with his first two features, “All About the Feathers” and “Helmet Heads,” both drama-comedies, Villalobos will head in a different direction with “Love is the Monster,” a psychological thriller [...]

  • Pinewood Atlanta Studios

    Pinewood Group to Exit Atlanta Studios Joint Venture

    The Pinewood Group is pulling out of its Atlanta facility as it refocuses its international strategy. The group announced Wednesday that it has sold its equity in Pinewood Atlanta Studios to River’s Rock, its joint venture partner in the facility. The joint venture was set up in 2013 with Pinewood Atlanta Studios now the second [...]

  • El Principe

    Storyboard Swoops on Seven Titles for 2020 Chilean Distribution (EXCLUSIVE)

    Key Chilean independent production-distribution company Storyboard Media has announced a knock-your-socks-off slate of seven domestic features, in varying degrees of completion, to be released in Chile across 2020. Bound for Venice’s Critics’ Week, Sebastián Muñoz’s “The Prince” was a hit at last year’s works in progress section at the San Sebastian Film Festival and will [...]

  • Tigerlily

    Banijay Rights Signs First Look Deal with Tigerlily Prods.

    Seeking to expand its scripted offering, Banijay Rights has signed a first look development deal with Tigerlily Productions, a U.K. production company whose credits include David Farr’s “The Ones Below” and “Remainder” with Tom Sturridge. The deal covers scripted programming developed, created and produced by Tigerlily for the U.K. and international markets. Tigerlily Productions, which [...]

  • Blanco-en-Blanco

    Stray Dogs Picks Up Int’l Sales Rights to Venice-bound ‘Blanco en Blanco’ (EXCLUSIVE)

    SANTIAGO, Chile – In the run-up to the upcoming 76th Venice Int’l Film Festival, Paris-based Stray Dogs has closed international sales rights on Chilean drama “Blanco en Blanco,” which holds its world premiere in the festival’s Horizons sidebar. Filmed last year in the frigid tundra of Chile’s Tierra de Fuego and Spain’s tropical Canary Islands, [...]

  • Gerard Butler Angel Has Fallen

    Film Review: 'Angel Has Fallen'

    “Angel Has Fallen” marks the third time that Gerard Butler, as the Secret Service agent and scowling samurai cowboy Mike Banning, has had to rescue the President of the United States from an international conspiracy so cuckoo bananas that the movie barely expects you to believe it. (Actually, in the six years since this series [...]

  • Jessica

    Ninja Thyberg's Female POV Porn Industry Portrait Seduces Buyers (EXCLUSIVE)

    HAUGESUND, Norway  —  Paris-based Versatile has announced a raft of pre-sales on Ninja Thyberg’s debut feature “Jessica,” set in the adult entertainment industry in L.A. World distributors that have pre-bought the Swedish drama take in Weltkino for Germany/Austria, Xenix for Switzerland, MK2/Mile End for Canada, KTH for South Korea and Movie Could for Taïwan. Several [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content