You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘I Am Breathing’

Emma Davie and Morag McKinnon deliver an achingly reflective look at the life of a man struggling with ALS.


Neil Platt, Louise Oswald, Oscar Platt.

Not so much harrowing as achingly reflective, “I Am Breathing” follows, with expressive respect, the last year or so in the life of a 33-year-old Scottish architect whose vivacious wife and young son can be of only limited help as he slowly succumbs to ALS, commonly known as Lou Gehrig’s disease. Currently playing a week at New York’s IFC Center before moving to an engagement at the Laemmle Music Hall in Los Angeles, the item could find further arthouse engagements on the basis of reverent reviews and numerous previous fest screenings, with lively tube sales and strong specialized ancillary also likely.

Shortly after his 2008 diagnosis with what’s been called the last truly incurable disease of the day, Neil Platt becomes determined to spread the word via a soon-popular blog he writes with maddeningly inaccurate speech-recognition software. He’s an expressive and self-aware fellow, explaining, “I didn’t want to be overshadowed by this.” Expressing regret that he didn’t begin fundraising for disease research earlier in his decline, he later wonders, “Maybe this has all brought out the best in me?”

He’s even able to see the dark humor in the situation, telling a story early on about trying to terminate his cell-phone service (“because I’m dying”) and being offered an extra three months if he doesn’t cancel. It’s the Scottish equivalent of Warren Zevon’s famous quip to David Letterman about how to approach imminent death: “Enjoy every sandwich.”

At the same time, knowing ALS will rob him of his ability to walk and talk, which it inevitably, inexorably does, he begins assembling a box of mementoes for his son, Oscar. In goes his favorite leather jacket, tie pin, first teddy bear and, in a nice Euro touch, the first lighter he ever bought.

Helmers Emma Davie and Morag McKinnon take nearly too respectful an approach; topics surrounding Platt’s condition left unaddressed include the intricacies of medical insurance and equipment hire, as well as the presence of any religious structure in their lives. Yet the biographical material, including homemovies and a detailed illustration of how Platt met and courted his wife, Louise, keep the viewer engaged. 

Through it all, Louise (who has since remarried, is writing a book on her experiences and continues the fundraising crusade) remains attentive and compassionate. There is but a single scene in which she succumbs to her fears, and it is handled tastefully and with aplomb.

Tech package is tidy. Editor Peter Winther inserts lyrical shots of the rural outdoors and print curtains from the room in which Platt sits immobile in his chair — a nice touch that evokes the world as he sees it while composing his posts, surrounded by friends and family. Ethereal score by Kieran Hebden and Jim Sutherland, collectively known as Four Tet, is a strong plus. English subtitles at strategic points do much to ameliorate the Scottish burr.

On June 21, the pic screened internationally in over 200 venues, public and private, in more than 35 countries to mark Global MND/ALS Awareness Day.

Film Review: 'I Am Breathing'

Reviewed online, Sydney, July 31, 2013. (Also in Edinburgh, Hot Docs, True/False film festivals; 2012 Intl. Documentary Film Festival Amsterdam.) Running time: 73 MIN.


(Documentary — U.K.-Denmark) An SDI Prods., Scottish Documentary Institute, Danish Documentary Production production. (International sales: DR Intl. Sales, Copenhagen.) Produced by Sonja Henrici. Executive producer, Noe Mendelle.


Directed by Emma Davie, Morag McKinnon. Camera (color), Davie; editor, Peter Winther; music, Four Tet; sound (5.1 surround, stereo), McKinnon.


Neil Platt, Louise Oswald, Oscar Platt.

More Film

  • Swiss Film Award Winners Led By

    ‘Those Who Work,’ ‘Chris the Swiss’ Top 2019 Swiss Film Awards

    Two debut features in writer-director Antoine Russbach’s “Those Who Work” and Anja Kofmel’s animated documentary “Chris the Swiss,” were the big winners at Friday night’s Swiss Film Awards, notching three plaudits each. Sold by Be For Films, “Those Who Work,” stars Belgian actor Olivier Gourmet, who has appeared in every single film by Jean-Pierre and [...]

  • Lupita Nyong'o as Adelaide Wilson doppelgänger

    Box Office: Jordan Peele's 'Us' to Easily Surpass 'Get Out' in Killer Opening Weekend

    Jordan Peele’s horror-thriller “Us” will likely slay the box office competition this weekend. It’s projected to generate an impressive $64 million through the weekend at 3,741 sites in North America, early estimates showed Friday. It’s over-performing recent forecasts, which had ranged from $38 million to $50 million. It should wind up with about $27 million [...]

  • France's Investment in Movies Plummeted in

    France's Film Production Levels Remained High in 2018, But Local Investment Plummeted

    While the volume of production in France remained high with 300 films made in 2018, investment in local films dropped by 15.2% to €1.12 billion ($1.26 billion), hit by the sharp decline in financing from traditional distribution deals and TV channels. Among the 300 films produced last year, 237 were French-majority films and 63 French-minority [...]

  • Unicorn Store Trailer

    Watch the First Trailer for Brie Larson's Directorial Debut, 'Unicorn Store'

    Brie Larson is seeking salvation from Samuel L. Jackson in Neflix’s first trailer for her directorial debut, the offbeat comedy-drama “Unicorn Store.” Larson is portraying a lonely 20-something dreamer who’s been kicked out of art school. She’s forced to move back home with her parents and take a temp job at a PR agency. But [...]

  • Patti Rockenwagner

    Chief Brand Officer Patti Röckenwagner Leaves STX Entertainment (EXCLUSIVE)

    Patti Röckenwagner is leaving STX Entertainment where she has served as the company’s chief brand officer. She announced her departure in a memo to staff, in which she said she was departing for “another opportunity.” The exit is an amicable one. Röckenwagner joined STX in 2016 as its chief communications officer before being promoted to [...]

  • Gabrielle Union

    10 Things We Learned at Variety’s 2019 Entertainment Marketing Summit

    Variety’s 2019 Entertainment Marketing Summit, which brought top execs to Hollywood’s NeueHouse on Thursday, covered considerable ground. From cutting through the noise in an oversaturated media landscape to welcoming exciting technology like virtual reality, industry veterans offered insight into what to expect from the marketing world in coming years. Here are 10 things we learned [...]

  • Orange Studio, OCS Join Forces On

    Orange Studio, OCS Join Forces on Flurry of High-Profile Series

    Following “The Name of the Rose”(pictured) and “Devils,” France’s Orange has unveiled four internationally-driven series projects as part of its commitment to step into premium original shows with its film/TV division Orange Studio and pay TV group OCS both of board. Currently in development, the social western “Cheyenne & Lola,” the dance-filled workplace drama “The [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content