Film Review: ‘A Place in Heaven’

This character-driven, allegorical epic should resonate with niche arthouse audiences in North America.


Alon Moni Aboutboul, Tom Graziani, Rotem Zisman-Cohen, Yossi Pollak, Sophia Ostritsky, Keren Berger, Michael Aloni, Sasha Avshalom Agarounov, Gabi Amrani. (Hebrew, Arabic dialogue)

A retired general lies on his deathbed, bitter and alone, prompting his estranged, ultra-orthodox Jewish son to try and save his soul from hell in “A Place in Heaven.” Yossi Madmony’s quasi-biblical story covers the history of Israel through 40 years and three wars, but, like the director’s previous film, “Restoration,” it is, at heart, a film about relationships between fathers and sons. Both character-driven and allegorical, this complex, good-looking, Toronto-bound epic drama should resonate with niche arthouse audiences in North America.

The meaning of the title soon emerges in a tale-within-a-tale that begins shortly after the founding of modern Israel: When a brave, much-admired officer dubbed Bambi (Alon Moni Aboutboul) returns to base after a daring mission, the cook’s assistant, a young rabbi, enviously tells him that he has earned a place in heaven for endangering his life on behalf of his Jewish brethren. As a secular Zionist, Bambi scoffs at this notion and notes that he would gladly give up that place in exchange for a plate of his favorite spicy omelet. Since religious law permits the trade of such abstract concepts as a person’s place in heaven, the cook draws up a contract.

Such impulsive behavior, typical of the arrogant young Bambi, proves to have long-term consequences. Likewise, when he falls in love with Ayala (Rotem Zisman-Cohen, who gets better and better with every film), the only child of a Yemenite rabbi (Gabi Amrani), he impetuously agrees to work for the old man for an entire year and study the Torah in return for her hand.

Popular on Variety

But another aspect of Bambi’s character is his stubbornness. Although he proves a man of his word during the year of labor, he shows no compassion for his father-in-law and refuses to say Kaddish for him when he dies. The old man’s subsequent curse will also play a role in Bambi’s destiny.

Bambi dearly loves his son Nimrod (drama student Tom Graziani, the weak link in the thesping department), but his obdurate, commanding personality causes the lad to reject his expectations and turn to other father figures. Nimrod ultimately forges a life of his own as a religious Jew, the very thing Bambi most despises.

Although some viewers may be put off by how heavily the writer’s hand shows itself throughout the narrative, Madmony’s ambitious screenplay masterfully merges the epic and the anecdotal. His protagonist, like the flawed heroes of the Old Testament, registers as recognizably human.

The forceful Aboutboul (who also has a successful career in Hollywood with films such as “The Dark Knight Rises” and “Body of Lies”) is poignant as the brilliant military man who defeats his enemies on the battlefield, but who fails the daily tests any father must face. Although the distaff characters seem to remain mostly in the shadows in the pic’s second half, Sophia Ostritsky and Keren Berger impress in small parts as Bambi’s Russian mistress and Nimrod’s born-again wife, respectively.

The craft package is first-rate, with Boaz Yehonatan Yacov’s elemental lensing contrasting the wild nature where Bambi thrives with the interiors where he seems like a caged beast. Editor Arik Lahav Leibovich deserves kudos for his compelling juggling of the pic’s many threads; Ophir Leibovitch’s atonal score provides perfect support.

Film Review: 'A Place in Heaven'

Reviewed at Karlovy Vary Film Festival (competing), June 29, 2013. (Also in Toronto Film Festival — Contemporary World Cinema.) Running time: 117 MIN.Original title: "Makom be gan eden"


(Israel) A United King Films release of a United King Films, Movie Plus Prods. production with the support of the Avi Chai Fund, Channel 10, Israel Film Fund. (International sales: Movie Plus Prods., Tel Aviv.) Produced by David Mandil, Moshe Edery, Leon Edery. Executive producer, Michal Graidy.


Directed, written by Yossi Madmony. Camera (color, widescreen), Boaz Yehonatan Yacov; editor, Arik Lahav Leibovich; music, Ophir Leibovitch; production designer, Miguel Merkin; costume designer, Laura Sheim; sound (SRD 5.1), Alex Claude, Daniel Meir.


Alon Moni Aboutboul, Tom Graziani, Rotem Zisman-Cohen, Yossi Pollak, Sophia Ostritsky, Keren Berger, Michael Aloni, Sasha Avshalom Agarounov, Gabi Amrani. (Hebrew, Arabic dialogue)

More Film

  • After Class

    Film Review: ‘After Class’

    Arguably the best thing about “After Class,” a purposely untidy and exceptionally intelligent dramedy about frayed family ties and academic contretemps, is writer-director Daniel Schechter’s refusal to ever let his protagonist off too easy. To be sure, lead player Justin Long’s graceless-under-pressure Josh Cohn comes across as more clueless than unsympathetic, less chronically selfish than [...]

  • Aubrey Plaza Spirit Awards

    Aubrey Plaza Returning as Indie Spirit Awards Host

    Aubrey Plaza will return to the white tent on Santa Monica beach to host the Film Independent Spirit Awards for the second consecutive year. Now in its 35th year, the ceremony honoring the year’s best independent cinema will be held on Feb. 8. The 2020 celebration will broadcast live on IFC. “Like all great independent [...]

  • New Republic Pictures

    'Suspiria' Producer Bradley J. Fischer Joins New Republic as President

    Bradley J. Fischer, whose credits include “Zodiac,” “Black Sawn” and “Suspiria,” is joining Brian Oliver’s New Republic Pictures as president and chief content officer. Fischer has signed a multi-year pact with Paramount-based New Republic. Fischer and Oliver will produce all New Republic projects, including film, television and streaming. Fischer will continue to produce his pre-existing projects, [...]

  • Alfre Woodard

    Alfre Woodard Reflects on Her First Oscar Nomination and Her Career So Far

    When Alfre Woodard was 22, she drove from Boston to Los Angeles, only stopping in her Tulsa, Okla., hometown. The four-time Emmy winner, now 67, has been acting ever since. Woodard’s career began in theater, despite her inability to sing or dance, with help from late choreographer Lester Wilson. An early play, “So Nice, They [...]

  • Julia Fox Uncut Gems

    Saoirse Ronan, Julia Fox and More Actors Discuss the Women Who Inspired Them

    In her first film role, Julia Fox blazes into “Uncut Gems” as Julia, the ambitious but loyal mistress of Adam Sandler’s jeweler. It’s a complex character the audience can’t always read. To play Julia, Fox says she had a couple inspirations. “My younger self, for sure,” she admits. “Looking at myself retrospectively, how I survived, [...]

  • Disney's MULAN..Mulan (Yifei Liu)..Photo: Film Frame..©

    Mulan Goes to War in Disney‘s Action-Packed Trailer

    Hua Mulan readies to put her life on the line for her community and family in a new trailer for Disney’s live-action “Mulan.” Based on Disney’s 1998 animated classic, “Mulan” tells the story of a woman (portrayed by Yifei Liu) who poses as a man to fight in the Chinese army. The footage, dropped Thursday, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content