You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Judge Nixes Warner Bros.’ Bid to Sanction Rep for Superman Heirs

Studio claimed Marc Toberoff interfered with settlement talks

A federal judge has rejected an effort by DC Comics to have the court impose sanctions on the attorney to the heir to “Superman” co-creators Jerry Siegel and Joseph Shuster, as they are engaged in a bitter and protracted legal battle over the rights to the Man of Steel.

In an order issued on Friday, U.S. District Judge Otis Wright said that the efforts by DC Comics, a unit of Warner Bros., were “just a rehashing of the tortured course of discovery in these Superman matters.”

DC Comics, represented by attorney Daniel Petrocelli, claims that attorney Marc Toberoff interfered with settlement negotiations that Warner Bros. was engaged in back in 2001 and 2002 with the Siegel heirs. DC contends that after Toberoff approached the heirs to express interest in purchasing the Superman rights, the heirs repudiated a settlement agreement and took Toberoff on as their attorney.

DC Comics filed suit against Toberoff in 2010, and has since claimed that he was concealing information in the discovery process in the way that his firm logged correspondence as attorney-client privileged information.

But Wright wrote that he was “skeptical of DC’s contention that any perceived deception here caused it any real prejudice, as the letters at issue here actually serve more to discredit DC’s cries of intentional interference than they do to bolster them.”

He noted that a Nov. 2, 2002 letter from Laura Siegel to Michael Siegel “unambiguously reveals that Joanne and Laura Siegel fired Kevin Marks,” who had been representing them, upon “their ‘dissatisf[action]’ with ‘the revolting offer from DC’ in February, 2002.

But that was six months before they first learned that Toberoff had made an offer to Marks in August 2002, Wright wrote.

Wright wrote that while he was “admittedly deeply troubled” by “Toberoff’s repeated failure to update his privilege logs” to reflect some of the correspondence between Michael Siegel and half sister Laura Siegel Larson, the “record does not support a clear inference that this logging inaccuracy was the result of a deliberate attempt to mislead the Court of DC Comics; rather, it appears more likely the result of a misplaced reliance on the attorney client-privilege and the related joint-litigation privilege.”

The litigation centers on the heirs’ termination of certain DC Comics’ rights to Man of Steel under a provision of the Copyright Act that gives creators and their families the ability to reclaim the works after a certain period of time and under certain conditions.

In January, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals held that an Oct. 19, 2001 letter between DC and Siegel’s daughter, Laura Siegel Larson, was an agreement by the Siegel heirs to grant their reclaimed rights to DC in exchange for millions of dollars. DC and Warner Bros. claim that this essentially means that the case is over and it has the rights, while the Siegel heirs argue that there is still a dispute as to the meaning of the 2001 agreement’s terms, whether it really transferred the rights of the character from the heirs to DC and whether DC later breached the pact.

Popular on Variety

More Film

  • Ted Sarandos - Netflix

    Netflix's Ted Sarandos Says Disney Plus Launch Changes 'Nothing' for the Company

    Netflix chief content officer Ted Sarandos claims he’s not getting distracted by huge competitors — like Disney — rumbling into the company’s streaming turf. The exec was asked what has changed for Netflix with the Nov. 12 launch of Disney Plus, which the Mouse House boasted as having signed up over 10 million users so [...]

  • Tribeca Film Institute

    Tribeca Film Institute Announces Winners for Aspiring Filmmaker Program

    Tribeca Film Institute announced the winners of their 2019 TFI Pond5 program funding aspiring filmmakers. Eight applicants, narrowed down from a pool of 200, were awarded with up to $7,500 in funding for their filmmaking endeavors. The program, in junction with media company Pond5, began the initiative last year to support indie filmmakers in “systematically-excluded [...]

  • Game Awards OrchestraThe Game Awards, Show,

    Game Awards 2019 to Play on 53 Cinemark Screens Alongside 'Jumanji: The Next Level'

    This year’s Game Awards, recognizing the top video games, creators and esports of 2019, is coming to the silver screen. In a three-way partnership, the Game Awards, Cinemark Theatres and Sony Pictures are teaming on a superticket program pairing the Dec. 12 live simulcast of the 2019 Game Awards in 53 Cinemark locations with a [...]

  • Frozen 2

    Film Review: 'Frozen 2'

    Released in 2013 to a record-scorching $1.29 billion, “Frozen” was such a huge hit for Walt Disney Animation Studios that many of its fans were probably assuming its sequel would play it safe and deliver more of the same: a sparkling 21st-century fairy tale in which a pair of wide-eyed heroines shrug off the need [...]

  • Variety New Leaders in TV

    Lena Waithe's Hillman Grad President Is Among Variety's New Leaders in Film

    Every year, Variety seeks to identify the next generation of leaders in the entertainment business, looking for representatives in the creative community, film, TV, music and digital. This year’s group has a heavy New York focus: We selected executives from forward thinking companies such as Spotify, Group Nine and Endeavor Audio, as well as writers [...]

  • Lilly Burns Tony Hernandez

    Jax Media Soars by Amplifying Unique Voices of Auteur TV

    Jax Media has emerged during the past few years as one of television’s busiest and buzziest production companies. The New York-based company headed by four partners — Tony Hernandez, Lilly Burns, John Skidmore and Brooke Posch — has an enviable track record of scouting new voices and executing stylish shows on a less-than-stratospheric budgets. The [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content