×

Toronto Film Review: ‘The Last of Robin Hood’

Co-directors Richard Glatzer and Wash Westmoreland defang their material in this wild and crazy true Hollywood story.

With:

Kevin Kline, Susan Sarandon, Dakota Fanning, Bryan Batt, Max Casella, Jason Davis, Matt Kane, Patrick St. Esprit, Ric Reitz, Justina Machado.

Errol Flynn just might be the role Kevin Kline was born to play, but “The Last of Robin Hood” doesn’t do either actor justice, reducing the matinee idol’s scandalous final fling — with 15-year-old starlet Beverly Aadland (an older-looking Dakota Fanning) — to a waxy, smallscreen-caliber intrigue. It’s as if co-directors Richard Glatzer and Wash Westmoreland fell for this wild and crazy true Hollywood story on the strength of its sheer outrageousness and then grew too close to the surviving characters over the course of their decade-long research and development, defanging what could have been a saucy period romp.

The public likes its celebrity peccadilloes steaming fresh, suggesting tough travels for this long-petrified intrigue. If the identical scenario were to happen in Hollywood today, however, audiences would be ravenous for juicy inside details. But given the 1950s setting, you can practically imagine them asking, “Errol who?” as they pass over a project that superhumanly attempts to represent all three perspectives: Flynn’s last great love, young Beverly’s naive infatuation and her mother’s astonishing ability to ignore what was happening right under her nose.

As played by Susan Sarandon, Florence Aadland should have been the most fascinating character here. After all, May-December romances are something of a cliche in Tinseltown, where bright young things are easily enticed by any advantage their careers can get. But Beverly’s situation was unique in that her mother — a washed-up dancer with a wooden leg who’d been lying about her daughter’s age for years — was so blinded by whatever vicarious thrill she got from Beverly’s success that she practically thrust the two lovers together.

Popular on Variety

Flynn makes the first move, however, spying Beverly from across the studio backlot in one of cinematographer Michael Simmonds’ few striking shots: Fanning is seen reflected in a window, behind which Kline surveys a parade of young starlets. Simmonds typically brings a far more organic look to his Ramin Bahrani collaborations, disguising their low-budget origins, whereas here, one can’t help but recognize all the ways the production had to cut corners in re-creating the period (sets seem underdressed, rooms look overlit, and streets are empty, except for Flynn’s lone vintage automobile).

The directors based the script not only on Florence Aadland’s “The Big Love,” a highly suspect account of her daughter’s love affair, but also firsthand interviews with Beverly Aadland and her Hollywood High classmate Ronnie Shedlo (played by Matt Kane), who served as Flynn’s assistant. Shedlo was the one who drove the star to meet with Stanley Kubrick about playing Humbert Humbert in “Lolita,” an irony almost too good to be true.

All of this research turns up fascinating details that might have otherwise been lost to time (including a hilariously campy reconstruction of Flynn’s “Cuban Rebel Girls” shoot), but interferes with the script’s ability to assume a single point of view, which would have given audiences an easier time of connecting with this creepy story. Nabokov himself surely would have appreciated the unreliable-narrator angle, had the co-writers opted to privilege either Flynn’s or Florence’s version of events (and viewers surely would have been smart enough to take their accounts with a grain of salt). Alternately, a “Rashomon” approach, in which similar events are seen through different sets of eyes, might have worked.

Instead, the script represents a too-tame middle ground, which gives the unfortunate impression that perhaps the filmmakers want us to empathize with this icky romance. For openly gay directors Glatzer and Westmoreland (who were on more comfortable ground with “The Fluffer” and “Quinceanera”), that’s an incredibly risky position to take, as homophobes level the argument that allowing gay rights opens the door to all sorts of other unconventional relationships — of which statutory rape by a straight, pushing-50 star needs no champions.

Toronto Film Review: 'The Last of Robin Hood'

Reviewed at Toronto Film Festival (Special Presentations), Sept. 6, 2013. Running time: 92 MIN.

Production:

A Lifetime Films presentation in association with Killer Films and Big Indie Pictures. (International sales: Cinetic Media, New York.) Produced by Declan Baldwin, Maggie Malina, Pamela Koffler, Christine Vachon. Executive producers, Todd Haynes, Rob Sharenow, Tanya Lopez, Molly Thompson, Colleen McCormick, Lisa Hamilton Daly.

Crew:

Directed, written by Richard Glatzer, Wash Westmoreland. Camera (color, HD), Michael Simmonds; editor, Robin Katz; music, Nick Urata; production designer, Jane Healy; art director, Alexandra West; set decorator, Adam Willis; sound, Aron Siegel; supervising sound editor, Javier Bennassar; re-recording mixer, Leslie Shatz; visual effects supervisor, Adam Polanger; line producer, Gary Giudice; associate producers, Tim Pedegana, Alexander A. Motlagh; assistant director, Chip Signore; casting, Kerry Barden, Paul Schnee.

With:

Kevin Kline, Susan Sarandon, Dakota Fanning, Bryan Batt, Max Casella, Jason Davis, Matt Kane, Patrick St. Esprit, Ric Reitz, Justina Machado.

More Film

  • Dan Scanlon (L) and US producer

    Berlin: Director Dan Scanlon Discusses Pixar’s 'Onward,' and His Michigan Inspiration

    Pixar’s “Onward” saw its world premiere at the Berlin International Film Festival, and the film’s director, Dan Scanlon, and producer, Kori Rae, talked to the press at the festival about the film, which follows brother elves on a magical quest to reconnect with their late father. Tom Holland and Chris Pratt voice the brothers who [...]

  • Johnny Depp arrives for the 'Minamata'

    Johnny Depp on 'Power of the Small' at Launch of 'Minamata' at Berlin Film Festival

    Johnny Depp arrived at the Berlin Film Festival Friday to support the film “Minamata,” in which he plays celebrated war photographer W. Eugene Smith. In the film, based on real events, Smith is pitted against a powerful corporation responsible for poisoning with mercury the people of Minamata in Japan in 1971. Directed by Andrew Levitas, [...]

  • "Last Film Show"

    Berlin: Orange Studio Launches 'The Last Film Show,' 'Old Fashioned, 'Love Song For Tough Guys' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Under the new leadership of industry veteran Kristina Zimmermann, Orange Studio, the film/TV division of the French telco group Orange, is launching three new projects at Berlin’s European Film Market: “Last Film Show,” “Old Fashioned” and “Love Song for Tough Guys.” Directed by Pan Nalin (“Samsara”), “Last Film Show” follows Samay, a 9-year-old boy living [...]

  • Bootlegger

    Best Friend Forever Acquires Cannes' Cinefondation Prizewinning 'Bootlegger' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Brussels-based company Best Friend Forever has acquired international sales rights to Caroline Monnet’s feature debut “Bootlegger” which won best screenplay at Cannes’ Cinefondation in 2017. A well-known contemporary artist, Monnet has shed light on Indigenous identity and has debunked stereotypes through her works, which have been shown at the Whitney Biennial in New York, Palais [...]

  • Greed

    'Greed': Film Review

    I’ve got this friend who makes his own clothes. Not the generic kind cut from dowdy prairie-dress patterns, but chic, design-it-yourself garments that look better than most anything you’d find on a ready-to-wear rack. I figure he’s the only person I know who’s not guilty of contributing to the kind of sweatshop misery writer-director Michael [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content