×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Fruitvale

Best viewed as an ode to victim's rights, this well-intentioned drama forgoes nuanced drama for heart-tugging, head-shaking and rabble-rousing.

With:
With: Michael B. Jordan, Melonie Diaz, Octavia Spencer, Kevin Durand, Chad Michael Murray, Ahna O'Reilly, Ariana Neal.

A well-intentioned attempt to put a human face on the tragic headlines surrounding Oscar Grant, a 22-year-old California resident fatally shot by a San Francisco transit police officer on New Year’s Day, 2009, writer-director Ryan Coogler’s confident debut feature, “Fruitvale,” gets significant mileage from Michael B. Jordan’s star turn. Yet even if every word of Coogler’s account of the last day in Grant’s life held up under close scrutiny, the film would still ring false in its relentlessly positive portrayal of its subject. Best viewed as an ode to victim’s rights, “Fruitvale” forgoes nuanced drama for heart-tugging, head-shaking and rabble-rousing.

Given the facts of the case, the eyewitness video recordings on YouTube of Grant’s shooting, and the still raw nature of the material, it’s difficult to begrudge such an emotion-driven approach, particularly considering the smear campaign that followed Grant’s death. Coogler clearly feels a deep warmth for the lives he’s depicting onscreen, which should be reciprocated by audiences starved for tender portraits of black family life. But that affection gets in the way of a more complex examination of human nature and the thornier issues of how such tragedies happen, serving instead to make viewers feel real good before they feel real mad.

Consequently, “Fruitvale” piles on examples of Grant as a loving boyfriend to Sophina (Melonie Diaz), son to Wanda (Octavia Spencer) and father to Tatiana (Ariana Neal), with only fleeting glimpses of his foibles. Sophina remains angry about a recent affair Oscar had (though she has to forgive him, because he’s so darn sweet). He also spent time in prison (for reasons never made clear), has a temper that occasionally flares up and was fired from his grocery store job for missing work. Yet there’s never any question that by the time we meet him, all of this dubious stuff is firmly in Oscar’s past, and he’s dedicated himself to pursuing a better life.

Jordan, already a standout player on TV’s “The Wire” and “Friday Night Lights,” leaves no doubt he’s ready for leading-man status with a typically charismatic and naturalistic performance that puts auds firmly on Grant’s side. The actor is so convincing that there’s no need to stack the deck with scenes of Grant tending to a stray dog injured in a hit-and-run, phoning his grandma to help a stranger decide what kind of fish to fry for her boyfriend, and convincing a grouchy store owner to re-open his establishment so two women can use the bathroom.

But if Coogler’s intent is to rile up moviegoers and fill them with dread for the inevitable (glimpsed in cell-phone footage in the film’s opening moments), he succeeds at the most basic level. Every mention of an alternative plan for New Year’s Eve becomes an ominous “what if?” scenario, while the genuine concern Wanda and Tatiana show for Oscar’s well-being just hours before his death underlines the magnitude of their impending loss. Few would deny Grant’s killing was senseless and deplorable, but “Fruitvale” mostly functions to further the transformation of a flesh-and-blood man into an unintentional martyr.

Performances are strong across the board, even if no one beyond Jordan, Diaz and Spencer is asked to do very much. Kevin Durand and Chad Michael Murray have the daunting tasks of bringing the two BART officers central to Grant’s death to the screen, though both characters’ names have been changed. (The officer who actually shot Grant was convicted of involuntary manslaughter and served 18 months in prison.)

Tech credits are solid, with Rachel Morrison’s fluid handheld camerawork giving the actors room to breathe, and sound designer Bob Edwards’ work especially attuned to the power of silence.

Fruitvale

Production: A Significant production. Produced by Nina Yang Bongiovi, Forest Whitaker. Executive producers, Michael Y. Chow. Co-producer, Sev Ohanian. Co-executive producers, Lisa Kleiner-Chanoff, John Kwok, Octavia Spencer. Directed, written by Ryan Coogler.

Crew: Camera (color, widescreen), Rachel Morrison; editors, Michael P. Shawver, Claudia S. Castello; music, Ludwig Goransson; music supervisor, Haroula Rose; production designer, Hannah Beachler; set decorator, Kris Boxell; costume designer, Aggie Rodgers; sound, Darcel Walker; sound designer/supervising sound editor, Bob Edwards; re-recording mixers, Zach Martin, Edwards; visual effects makeup, Aurora Bergere; visual effects supervisor, Catherine Tate; visual effects, Academy of Art University, River Road Creative, Ekuipp Prods. & Breakfast Studios; stunt coordinator, Rocky Capella; line producer, Richard J. Bosner; associate producer, Gerard McMurray, Haroula Rose; assistant director, Antonio Grana; second unit camera, Jon Else; casting, Nina Henninger, Tracy "Twinkie" Byrd. Reviewed at Sundance Film Festival (competing), Jan. 19, 2013. Running time: 100 MIN.

With: With: Michael B. Jordan, Melonie Diaz, Octavia Spencer, Kevin Durand, Chad Michael Murray, Ahna O'Reilly, Ariana Neal.

More Film

  • Italy's Notorious Pictures Expands Into Exhibition,

    Italy's Notorious Pictures Expands Into Exhibition, Plans 200 Screens by 2023

    Italian distribution and production company Notorious Pictures is branching out into exhibition, aiming to have 20 multiplexes up and running within the next five years. The company has appointed former UCI Italy chief Andrea Stratta to head up a new Notorious Cinemas unit. The company said it was already in the process of taking out a [...]

  • cats logo

    As 'Cats' Starts Production, Downtown Lands Admin Deal for Andrew Lloyd Webber's Music (EXCLUSIVE)

    Downtown Music Publishing has entered into a multi-year publishing administration deal with Faber Music, which represents the musical repertoire from “Cats,” the beloved and long-running Broadway sensation currently being turned into a feature film starring Taylor Swift, Jennifer Hudson, James Corden, Idris Elba and Judi Dench, among others. The Universal picture, directed by Tom Hooper, recently [...]

  • Nicholas Cage. Actor Nicolas Cage poses

    Nicolas Cage to Star in Horror Movie 'Color Out of Space'

    Nicolas Cage will star in the horror movie “Color out of Space” for Elijah Wood’s SpectreVision. Principal photography will begin next month with South African filmmaker Richard Stanley directing his first feature in more than 20 years. Stanley co-wrote the script with Scarlett Amaris. More Reviews Concert Review: Lady Gaga Outdoes Her Other Vegas Show With [...]

  • 'How to Train Your Dragon: The

    'How to Train Your Dragon: The Hidden World' to Bow in China on March 1

    “How to Train Your Dragon: The Hidden World” will swoop into Chinese theaters on March 1, its Beijing-based promotion company He Song confirmed to Variety on Wednesday. The date puts its China release a week after its Feb. 22 debut in the U.S. and also pits it against “Green Book,” which has scored a China release [...]

  • Songs for Screens Powered by Mac

    Songs for Screens: Beyond 'Bohemian Rhapsody,' 2018 Was a Record Sync Year for Queen

    As “Bohemian Rhapsody” approaches a landmark $800 million at the global box office, another Queen milestone quietly took place in 2018. With appearances in nationwide campaigns for Amazon, Ram Trucks, Google, Peloton, Silk Almondmilk and many more, Queen’s music was licensed by more blue-chip brands than any other calendar year. And in the first few [...]

  • Sundance Film Festival Placeholder

    A Changing Film Market Raises the Pressure for Sundance Indies to Succeed (Column)

    Regretfully, I never go to the Sundance Film Festival anymore because I need to mind the editorial store back home, knowing that our crack team of reporters and critics will be filing great scoops and reviews while freezing their butts off (sorry!). I have lots of fond memories from the days when I frequented Park [...]

  • Jimmy Kimmel Oscars

    Will the Oscars Be a Hot Mess Without a Host?

    Who will host this year’s Oscars? With one month left until the telecast on Feb. 24, there’s still no definitive answer. Insiders tell Variety that the ceremony will likely buck the tradition of having a master of ceremonies. Instead, organizers have chosen to patch together a host-less show. That could mean a lot of airtime [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content