×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Toronto Film Review: ‘Finding Vivian Maier’

This initially playful, ultimately haunting look at the once-secret career of street photographer Vivian Maier is an aptly obsessive study of obsession.

With:

John Maloof, Joel Meyerowitz, Mary Ellen Mark, Phil Donahue, Duffy Levant, Joe Matthews, Michael Strauss, Howard Greenberg.

An aptly obsessive study of obsession, “Finding Vivian Maier” sifts through the volumninous work and scant personal details of the titular street photographer, posthumously recognized as a genius of the form and a master of cultivated mystery. That this initially playful, ultimately haunting documentary is co-produced and co-directed by the principal owner and chief curator of Maier’s art, John Maloof, raises questions of self-promotion that could never be directed at the subject, who kept her many thousands of photos hidden from view. But Maloof also makes a compelling corollary to the compulsive shutterbug, resulting in the docu equivalent of double exposure.

Maloof and his collaborator Charlie Siskel strike a deft balance between insider knowledge and universal intrigue, allowing the film to score with Maier cultists as well as the heretofore uninitiated. Giving ample screen time to the photos themselves, bought by Maloof for cheap at a storage locker auction, the directors characterize Maier’s striking black-and-white work as that of an outsider who related particularly well to those on the fringes of ‘50s- and ‘60s-era American society, including children, African-Americans of all ages, and the poor of any color. (One of the docu’s many talking heads likens Maier to “Robert Frank with a square format.”)

At least as captivating as Maier’s photography is the slow-developing image of the woman behind the camera. Often dressing in men’s clothing and a large hat, her low-slung twin-lens Rolleiflex in tow, Maier toiled for decades as a nanny in the Chicago suburbs, taking her charges along on shoots in the big city and stashing countless rolls of undeveloped film in boxes that ended up lining the tiny bedrooms where she stayed. One former employer of Maier’s, speaking to the nanny’s reclusive nature, claims, “She would never have allowed this (film) to happen” in her lifetime.

Exactly why Maier chose to withhold the photos she clearly held dear is a puzzle the filmmakers can’t solve. Still, the photographer’s suppression of her own work seems entirely consistent with the picture of Maier as the epitome of eccentricity and elusiveness, a woman who exaggerated her experiences in France (along with her pseudo-continental accent), spelled her name in various ways and evidently had few if any friends. Her photos’ poignant grasp of “humanity and tragedy,” as one interviewee puts it, seems to have stemmed in part from her typically secret longing for community; apparently, Maier suffered abuse as a child and mental illness as an adult.

Fascinating glimpses into the artist’s psychology come largely from interviews with those whom Maier cared for many years ago. Recalling their odd childhoods with “Ms. Maier,” several of the nanny’s former charges persuasively point to her considerable “dark side,” even as the film suggests that nannying isn’t so different from Maier’s style of photography, both involving the expression of compassion.

For his part, the thirtysomething Maloof — periodically seen on camera, but not to an annoying degree — emerges as a kindred hoarder of the highest order, someone whose tons of images have been collected as a means not only of shrewd investment, but of psychological survival. Overhead shots of Maloof’s piles of Maier ephemera — including even her old receipts for film purchases — make clear that the documentarian not only loves the shooter’s street portraiture, but identifies with her temperament, admitting at one point that he’s “kind of compulsive with stuff” (an understatement to be sure).

Tech credits are sharp, and the film’s only significant flaw is its failure to elaborate on brief suggestions that Maier’s work, first beloved by visitors to Maloof’s blog, has remained unpopular among gatekeepers of the art-world establishment — especially when coupled with its climactic images of gallery-goers enjoying the fruits of Maier’s (and Maloof’s) labor, images that appear to contradict the earlier claim.

Toronto Film Review: 'Finding Vivian Maier'

Reviewed at Toronto Film Festival (TIFF Docs), Sept. 8, 2013. Running time: 83 MIN.

Production:

(Documentary) An IFC Films/Sundance Selects release of a Ravine Pictures production. Produced by John Maloof, Charlie Siskel. Executive producer, Jeff Garlin.

Crew:

Directed by John Maloof, Charlie Siskel. Camera (color, HD), Maloof; editor, Aaron Wickenden; music, J. Ralph; sound, Scott Palmer, Steve Lynch; associate producers, Anthony Rydzon, Lars Oxfeldt Mortensen.

With:

John Maloof, Joel Meyerowitz, Mary Ellen Mark, Phil Donahue, Duffy Levant, Joe Matthews, Michael Strauss, Howard Greenberg.

More Film

  • 'Downton Abbey' Full Trailer Released

    'Downton Abbey' Full Trailer Released

    The first full trailer for “Downton Abbey,” the much-anticipated movie spin-off of the hit TV series, has been released. The trailer for the Focus Features title was released on the film’s official Twitter account after debuting on NBC morning show “Today.” While little of the plot has been given away to date it is known [...]

  • 'Black Mother' Review: Hypnotic, Intense, Lyrical

    Film Review: 'Black Mother'

    The first set of images in “Black Mother,” Khalik Allah’s intensely felt act of cinematic hypnosis, is a cavalcade of monochrome, vignetted portraits: A young woman in a tight minidress dances in a market; a shirtless man wriggles on one foot, extending the other leg gymnastically high in the air; an old woman with milky [...]

  • Editorial use only. No book cover

    China's Huanxi Media Picks Up 'Snowpiercer' TV Show From ITV Studios

    China’s Huanxi Media Group Limited has bought the exclusive broadcasting right in the mainland for the forthcoming sci-fi TV series “Snowpiercer” from ITV Studios Global Entertainment. The show is based on South Korean director Bong Joon-Ho’s film of the same name and is set to debut on TBS in the U.S. in the spring of [...]

  • James Marsden attends the 2019 MOCA

    New Abortion Ban Laws Take Center Stage at MOCA Gala

    Forty years ago in Los Angeles, the decision to invest millions in a museum dedicated exclusively to contemporary art — not to mention its formerly desolate downtown location, where the vibe was more apocalyptic than artsy — was a risky proposition. But now that the city’s cultural heart has shifted south of Hollywood, it seems [...]

  • I Lost My Body

    'I Lost My Body' Director Jeremy Clapin On His Critics’ Week Breakout

    CANNES  — Jeremy Clapin’s feature debut “I Lost My Body” follows Naoufel, a young man who moves to France, falls in love and tries to create a new life.  Then in a parallel storyline, it follows Naoufel’s severed hand, which runs, jumps and rolls across Paris in an attempt to find the rest of its [...]

  • WGA Agents Contract Tug of War

    Writers Guild Expands Suit Against Agencies With New Fraud Allegations

    The Writers Guild of America has bulked up its lawsuit with additional fraud allegations against Hollywood’s four biggest talent agencies. The WGA amended its suit Monday in Los Angeles Superior Court with the claim that CAA, WME, UTA and ICM partners have engaged “constructive fraud” by allegedly placing their own interests ahead of their clients [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content