×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Toronto Film Review: ‘How I Live Now’

Held together by a forceful performance from Saoirse Ronan, director Kevin Macdonald's adaptation of Meg Rosoff's novel makes up in emotional immediacy what it lacks in broad dramatic sweep.

With:

Saoirse Ronan, George MacKay, Tom Holland, Harley Bird, Anna Chancellor, Danny McEvoy.

The outbreak of World War III is viewed through the narrow but steadily captivating lens of an American teenager dwelling abroad in “How I Live Now,” a story of young love that quickens into a harrowing survival thriller. Held together by a forceful performance from the ever-resourceful Saoirse Ronan, director Kevin Macdonald’s uneven but passionate adaptation of Meg Rosoff’s prize-winning 2004 novel wisely sticks to its protagonist’s p.o.v. while avoiding a longer view of the calamitous events around her, making up in emotional immediacy what it lacks in broad dramatic sweep. Likely to be perceived as too violent for younger audiences but too goopily romantic for older arthouse-goers, the Magnolia release reps a tricky marketing proposition that will require ample critical support when it bows Stateside Nov. 8.

The film’s opening stretch is not especially promising, insofar as it seems determined to shackle the viewer to the most unpleasant lead character imaginable. That would be Daisy (Ronan), a New York teenager who, estranged from her immediate family, has come to spend the summer with her cousins in the English countryside. First seen arriving at Heathrow in leave-me-alone shades and headphones, Daisy proves hostile and stubborn from the get-go, rebuffing the warm welcomes of 14-year-old Isaac (Tom Holland) and his talkative younger sister, Piper (Harley Bird), though she regards their quiet, handsome older brother, Edmond (George MacKay), with almost grudging curiosity. In an early tipoff of what’s to come, the nominal parent of the household, Daisy’s Aunt Penn (Anna Chancellor), spends almost all her time in Geneva as part of ongoing international peace talks, while TV news reports of bombings elsewhere on the continent suggest a world quickly sliding into turmoil.

Daisy’s company is not made much more bearable by the incessant interior monologue we hear on the soundtrack, a constant stream of self-improvement tips such as “Step out of your comfort zone” and “Take risks.” Slowly but surely, she learns to do just that as her cousins — often accompanied by young friend Joe (Danny McEvoy) — wear down her defenses, bring out her inner sunshine, and introduce her to the pleasures of their blissfully unsupervised existence. At times resembling a coed version of Peter Pan’s Lost Boys, they spend much of their time wandering the countryside and swimming in a nearby lake; as vibrantly lensed by Franz Lustig, it’s a backdrop wild and romantic enough that Daisy and Edmond soon fall in love.

It’s during one such outdoor idyll that everything changes: Time seems to stand still as the kids hear a dull, distant rumble, followed by a sudden flurry of what initially look like snowflakes. Haunting and grimly poetic, the scene works because Macdonald (directing from a script by three writers) so scrupulously adheres to his characters’ restricted vantage, allowing the audience to share in the confusion and terror of suddenly being caught up in events beyond their understanding. Eventually, of course, it becomes clear what has happened: Terrorists have bombed London and martial law has been declared, setting in motion a chain of events that will reach even into their woodland refuge, tearing their fragile family unit apart.

From there, “How I Live Now” shifts into full-on disaster-movie mode as violent circumstances rip Daisy and Piper away from the boys and send them to London, where they are put to work at a labor camp. If we never get a complete picture of exactly what’s going on in the streets around them, let alone the world beyond Blighty, it’s a limitation that nonetheless dovetails with the film’s dramatically fixed perspective, as Macdonald wisely serves up a few fascinating, plausible details — the cold plates of spam and vegetables that pass for dinner; the tablets that must be used to disinfect all drinking water following threats of mass contamination — and allows our minds to fill in the rest.

Soon the story morphs yet again, as Daisy and Piper go on the run and encounter obstacles that bring to mind Cate Shortland’s recent youth-in-wartime-peril drama “Lore,” achieving moments of sharp, bristling tension as well as one grisly apotheosis-of-war-style tableau. Perhaps the film’s most obvious flaw is that Daisy’s fierce determination, pushing her to ever more desperate survival tactics, hinges primarily on her longing to be reunited with Edmond, a twist that may strike some viewers as naive and sentimental; at the same time, there’s something admirable about how unapologetically the film embraces its protagonist, moony teenage romanticism and all. It’s also clear that Daisy’s makeshift family unit was something special indeed, and there’s nothing weak or naive about her desire to salvage it, even if it means a life-or-death journey.

The role of Daisy likely wouldn’t have worked with a less capable actress at the helm, and Ronan, whose recent performances in films like “Hanna” and “The Host” have proven her willing to get her hands dirty, gives flesh, ferocity and weight to the character’s many transformations, from sullen ingrate to loving cousin, from passionate lover to Katniss Everdeen-style heroine. The other roles have been conceived along much thinner lines, although MacKay has a nice, watchful presence as the somewhat idealized love interest (he can tame hawks!) and Holland, so good in “The Impossible,” brings some of that pluck and energy to his scenes here.

Macdonald does crisp, propulsive work in conjunction with editor Jinx Godfrey, while Jacqueline Abrahams’ production design makes the most of the film’s limited resources and intimate scale. Sound work is meticulous.

Toronto Film Review: 'How I Live Now'

Reviewed at Wilshire screening room, Beverly Hills, Aug. 20, 2013. (In Toronto Film Festival — Special Presentations.) Running time: 101 MIN.

Production:

(U.K.) A Magnolia Pictures (in U.S.) release of a Film4 and BFI presentation, in association with Protagonist and Entertainment One, of a Cowboy Films and Passion Pictures production, in association with Prospect Entertainment. (International sales: Protagonist Pictures, London.) Produced by Andrew Ruhemann, John Battsek, Charles Steel, Alasdair Flind. Executive producers, Tessa Ross, Robert Walak, Piers Wenger, Nigel Williams.

Crew:

Directed by Kevin Macdonald. Screenplay, Jeremy Brock, Penelope Skinner, Tony Grisoni, based on the novel by Meg Rosoff. Camera (color), Franz Lustig; editor, Jinx Godfrey; music, Jon Hopkins; music supervisor, Abi Leland; production designer, Jacqueline Abrahams; art director, Astrid Sieben; set decorator, Philippa Hart; costume designer, Jane Petrie; sound (Dolby Digital), Nigel Albermaniche; sound designer, Glenn Freemantle; re-recording mixers, Ian Tapp, Niv Adiri; special effects supervisor, Chris Reynolds; visual effects supervisor, Simon Hughes; visual effects, Union Visual Effects; stunt coordinator, Jo McLaren; line producer, Rosa Romero; associate producers, Jeremy Brock, Nicole Stott; assistant director, Adam Lock; casting, Nina Gold.

With:

Saoirse Ronan, George MacKay, Tom Holland, Harley Bird, Anna Chancellor, Danny McEvoy.

More Film

  • Octavia Spencer Bryce Dallas Howard

    Octavia Spencer, Bryce Dallas Howard to Reunite for Comedy 'Fairy Tale Ending'

    Octavia Spencer and Bryce Dallas Howard will reunite for the ensemble comedy “Fairy Tale Ending.” Jim Hecht (“Ice Age: The Meltdown) and Tracy McMillan (“Marvel’s Runaways”) are writing the screenplay. More Reviews TV Review: HBO's 'Brexit' TV Review: 'Deadly Class' on SyFy Howard will also produce the Universal movie through her Nine Muses Entertainment alongside [...]

  • Robert Smith, Longtime Executive at DuArt

    Robert Smith, Longtime Executive at New York's DuArt Film Labs, Dies at 88

    Robert Smith, a longtime executive with New York’s DuArt Film Labs, died Jan. 11 in Montvale, N.J. He was 88. Smith spent some 62 years with DuArt, the film processing and post-production facility founded in 1922 in the penthouse of an automobile garage in Midtown. Smith rose to president of DuArt before retiring in 2015. [...]

  • Bird Box

    Los Angeles On-Location Feature Filming Surges 12.2% in 2018

    On-location feature filming in Greater Los Angeles expanded impressively in 2018, gaining 12.2% to 4,377 shooting days, according to FilmL.A. Production activity for feature films rose 15.5% to 1,078 shooting days during the fourth quarter, with 146 days coming from projects receiving California tax credits — including Netflix’s “Bird Box,” Quentin Tarantino’s “Once Upon a [...]

  • 'Ghostbusters': First Look at Jason Reitman's

    Watch the First Teaser for Jason Reitman's 'Ghostbusters' Sequel

    If there’s something strange in your neighborhood, it’s time to watch a teaser for Jason Reitman’s “Ghostbusters” forthcoming film. Sony Pictures released a first look at the upcoming movie, a sequel to the 1984 classic. The footage shows a glimpse of the memorable station wagon Ecto-1. The studio announced on Tuesday that the wheels are [...]

  • Anne Hathaway

    Anne Hathaway to Star in Robert Zemeckis' 'The Witches' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Anne Hathaway has closed a deal to star as the Grand High Witch in Robert Zemeckis and Warner Bros.’ “The Witches” adaptation. Variety first reported that Hathaway was holding the offer for both that and “Sesame Street,” and at the time, scheduling for both films were holding up dealmaking. With those issues settled, Hathaway is [...]

  • Film Ratings Overhauled in the U.K.,

    Film Ratings Overhauled in the U.K. With Tougher Restrictions on Sexual Content

    The body that oversees film ratings in the U.K. is tightening its age restrictions and giving movies with certain types of sexual content older age ratings. The British Board of Film Classification said the changes were in response to public demand after a consultation that took in the views of over 10,000 people in the [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content