You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Montreal Film Review: ‘The Don Juans’

Opera is the subject, medium and language of Jiri Menzel's inventive if overstretched comedy.


Jan Hartl, Libuse Safrankova, Martin Huba, Ivana Chylkova, Anna Klamo, Jirina Jiraskova.

Opera is the subject, medium and language of Jiri Menzel’s latest comedy, revolving around a production of “Don Giovanni” by a Czech small-town troupe. Bursting with energy from the get-go, pirouetting through a blizzard of inventive gags spun at a terrific pace, “The Don Juans” unsurprisingly flags somewhat in extending its setup, with little infusion of new material, until the final curtain. The Mozart remains a source of real vitality, but what starts as whirlwind wit eventually grows repetitive. Still, the first 45 minutes generate a buoyant high that could carry the entire film for many auds.

The opera director Vitek (Jan Hartl) functions obviously as a likably sardonic, mockingly modest version of Menzel himself, as partly confirmed by his direct addresses to the camera; he attributes his success to the fact that he never took opera very seriously and doesn’t want to do anything original. A quick montage of would-be “modernist” Don Giovannis — from a long-haired, leather-clad motorcyclist baring his chest as he pours out his soul to a baritone on a toilet, pulling the chain to signal the end of his aria — illustrates his point.  Vitek claims not to like opera, but loves sopranos, as attested to by the large number of high-note hitters bedded in rapid succession, vocalizing their rapture through Vitek’s open bedroom window.

In counterpoint to Vitek is Marketka (Libuse Safrankova), another musical director, this one the leader of a children’s choir and the whimsical head of four generations of single mothers, all seduced and abandoned by singing Don Juans. Fearlessly impulsive, Marketka gets herself arrested twice.  The first time, she is nabbed for holding rehearsals in a fantastic abandoned 17th-century theater, complete with multiple trapdoors and movable flats. During her second run-in with the law, Marketka observes masked bank robbers stuffing money in the trunk of a stolen car (Vitek’s, actually), jumps into the driver’s seat and takes off — even though she can’t drive, which she proves immediately by crashing through the front of a butcher shop.

Vitek’s and Marketka’s storylines crisscross on several occasions, particularly in scenes involving Jakub (Martin Huba), an over-the-hill skirt chaser and once-famous bass whom Vitek woos out of retirement to play the Commendatore. Jakub could conceivably rep another surrogate for Menzel, returning after a long absence from filmmaking.

A number of filmmakers have recently produced some fairly amazing pics during their supposed twilight years. Like the Tavianis brothers with “Caesar Must Die,” Menzel brings an extensive theater background to his high-concept film comeback, though nothing could be farther from the Tavianis’ prison-set “Julius Caesar” than this frothy operatic romp. “The Don Juans” feels closer in spirit to Robert Altman’s swan song, “A Prairie Home Companion,” with its obvious surrogate for its aging director; its last hurrahs for a tradition-filled musical venue; and its heartless money man prowling in the wings. Menzel implies here that the angel of death, though not specifically incarnate, likewise lies in wait.

Popular on Variety

Montreal Film Review: 'The Don Juans'

Reviewed at Montreal World Film Festival (World Greats), Aug. 27, 2013. Running time: 104 MIN. Original title: "Donsajni"


(Czech Republic) A Bonton Film release of a Mediapro production in co-production with TV Nova, Medialogue. Produced by Adrian Sarbu. Executive producer, Misu Predescu, Pavel Novy.


Directed, written by Jiri Menzel. Camera (color), Jaromir Sofr; editor, Jiri Brozek; music, Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, Ales Brezina; production designer, Milan Bycek; costume designer, Sylva Zimula Hanakova; sound designer, Radim Hladik Jr.


Jan Hartl, Libuse Safrankova, Martin Huba, Ivana Chylkova, Anna Klamo, Jirina Jiraskova.

More Film

  • Fall Out Boy - Patrick StumpLeeds

    Fall Out Boy's Patrick Stump to Release 'Spell' Soundtrack, Hear First Single Here

    Fall Out Boy frontman Patrick Stump continues his extensive work in the film/TV soundtrack realm with the release of “Spell,” which comes on Nov. 1 on Milan Records through Sony Music Masterworks. The soundtrack features Stump’s music from Crush Pictures’ psych-thriller, including the ballad “Deep Blue Love.” a soulful, blues-tinged ballad performed by Stump and [...]

  • Tell Me Who I Am

    Film Review: 'Tell Me Who I Am'

    Amnesia has been so overused in movies — a convenient narrative device that effectively forces characters to become detectives into their own past — that it’s startling to encounter a film in which someone really does lose his memory. What’s doubly fascinating about the true-life case of Alex Lewis, in which the surprises just keep on coming, [...]

  • Cyrano, My Love

    Film Review: 'Cyrano, My Love'

    As fizzy as a freshly poured glass of Perrier-Jouët, though considerably less complex, writer-director Alexis Michalik’s “Cyrano, My Love” . Part fancifully fictional account of the play’s conception, and part “Waiting for Guffman”-style depiction of the wild antics behind its first production, “Cyrano” was released in France earlier this year, and its undemanding immersion into [...]

  • Barney

    Barney the Dinosaur Movie in the Works From Mattel Films and Daniel Kaluuya

    Mattel Films, Daniel Kaluuya’s 59% banner and Valparaiso Pictures are partnering to develop a live-action motion picture based on Barney, Mattel’s iconic purple dinosaur. “Working with Daniel Kaluuya will enable us to take a completely new approach to ‘Barney’ that will surprise audiences and subvert expectations,” said Mattel Films’ Robbie Brenner. “The project will speak [...]

  • Film Republic Sells Svetla Tsotsorkova's 'Sister'

    Film Republic Sells Svetla Tsotsorkova's 'Sister' to China, France (EXCLUSIVE)

    Svetla Tsotsorkova’s second feature film “Sister,” which played at the San Sebastian and London film festivals, has been picked up by Hualu in China and Tamasa in France. World sales are handled by Xavier Henry-Rashid’s Film Republic. The film, set in a small town in present-day Bulgaria, centers on a mother and her two daughters, [...]

  • Santa Barbara

    Morelia Film Festival Readies 5th Impulso Pix-in-Post Sidebar

    Morelia Film Festival’s (FICM) Impulso sidebar for pix in progress will run Sunday through Tuesday this coming week, having become one of the territories most important launchpads for Latin American feature films in post-production. Many of the participating films in recent editions have gone on to find festival success the world around. Last year, Hari [...]

  • SUPER FAMILY -- In Disney Pixar’s

    Pixar's Ralph Eggleston to Receive 2019 View Conference's Visionary Award

    The 2019 View Conference will present its Visionary Award to Pixar’s Ralph Eggleston. Eggleston, who won an Oscar in 2002 for his animated short “For the Birds,” has worked on such Pixar hits as “Toy Story,” “Finding Nemo,” “WALL-E,” and “Inside Out.” “I’ve long been a fan of the View Conference. It’s a great gathering [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content