×

Film Review: ‘Singing Women’

Even die-hard fans of distinctive Turkish auteur Reha Erdem may find their patience stretched by this ponderous island-set tale.

With:

Binnur Kaya, Philip Arditti, Kevork Malikyan, Deniz Hasguler, Vedat Erincin, Aylin Aslim.

Even die-hard fans of distinctive Turkish auteur Reha Erdem may find their patience stretched by “Singing Women,” an uneasy mix of whimsy, apocalypticism, social satire and murky parable set on an island being evacuated for an expected earthquake. This ponderous tale will no doubt attract some defenders, but seems unlikely to travel nearly as widely as the helmer’s prior projects, like “Times and Winds” and “Kosmos.”

Predictions of a major temblor have the authorities urging locals to take daily ferries to the mainland while they can, but not everyone on this wooded isle is obeying that command. Well-off curmudgeon Mesut (Kevork Malikyan) thinks this is just a plot to separate him from his precious possessions; his loyal, put-upon housekeeper, Esme (Binnur Kaya), wouldn’t dream of abandoning her post.

Meanwhile, horses are dying of some mysterious illness — and so, perhaps, is Mesut’s ne’er-do-well son Adem (Philip Arditti), who has torched his marriage and job, and now slinks home to guilt-trip Dad into some better-late-than-never fatherly love. But Mesut isn’t having it, convinced his offspring is simply trying to con him again, even once the island’s elderly doctor confirms a fatal diagnosis. Said medico takes an incongruous romantic interest in Meryam (Deniz Hasguler), a pretty waif whom Esme takes in after finding her cowering in the forest. Other figures include Adem’s flight-attendant wife, Esme’s bachelor brother and Maryem’s formerly abusive, newly apologetic ex.

There’s a low-key farcical edge to these romantic entanglements — all pathetically dysfunctional, particularly on the male side — while occasionally mystifying and miraculous events suggest that God is trying to teach a lesson to these foolish humans (again, particularly on the male side). But it’s all so cryptic and frequently listless that few viewers will be enchanted by experiencing Erdem in a (comparatively) lighter mood. Particularly irksome are the frequent scenes in which hammy Kaya and mostly glum Hasguler giggle and frolic like children on a sugar high, an intended expression of innocent joie de vivre that comes across as cloyingly fake.

Popular on Variety

Helmer’s usual d.p., Florent Herry, provides some beautiful outdoor shots, and the soundtrack of pre-existing compositions (several by Arvo Part, whom some promotional materials curiously suggest contributes an original score) provides more lyricism — occasionally more than the onscreen content deserves. Tech package is assured.

Film Review: 'Singing Women'

Reviewed at Toronto Film Festival (Special Presentations), Sept. 11, 2013. Running time: 122 MIN. Original title: "Sarki soyleyen kadinar"

Production:

(Turkey-France-Germany) An Atlantik Film production in association with Bredok Film and KMBO Films. (International sales: Atlantik, Istanbul.) Produced by Omar Atay. Executive producer, Claudine Avetyan. Co-producers, Mustafa Dok, Vladimir Kokh.

Crew:

Directed, written, edited by Reha Erdem. Camera (color, HD), Florent Herry; production designer, Omar Atay; sound, Erdem, Herve Guyader.

With:

Binnur Kaya, Philip Arditti, Kevork Malikyan, Deniz Hasguler, Vedat Erincin, Aylin Aslim.

More Film

  • Taylor Swift Variety Facetime

    Taylor Swift Opens Up About Overcoming Struggle With Eating Disorder (EXCLUSIVE)

    In the new Taylor Swift documentary, “Miss Americana,” which premiered at the Sundance Film Festival Thursday night, there’s a montage of derogatory commentary about the singer that has appeared on cable shows over the years. One of the less nasty remarks: “She’s too skinny. It bothers me.” As it turns out, it eventually bothered Swift, [...]

  • The Painter and the Thief

    'The Painter and the Thief': Film Review

    Incredible. That’s the word that comes to mind with Benjamin Ree’s “The Painter and the Thief,” a stranger-than-fiction friendship story in which vérité techniques produce unbelievable results. I don’t mean to imply that this astonishing documentary isn’t truthful. Rather, I’m in awe of how things played out, and fully aware that there was a certain [...]

  • 'The Cost of Silence': Exclusive First

    'The Cost of Silence': Exclusive First Look at Sundance Doc on Deepwater Horizon Spill

    “The Cost of Silence,” a new documentary about the aftermath of the 2010 Deepwater Horizon explosion, doesn’t just chronicle the worst oil drilling disaster in history. It looks at the devastating impact that the use of chemicals called “dispersants” had on Gulf Coast families. It turns out the so-called cleanup was not the success story [...]

  • Cuties

    'Cuties': Film Review

    Eleven-year-old Senegalese immigrant Amy (Fathia Youssouf) reckons there are two ways to be a woman. Amy could mimic her mom (Maïmouna Gueye), a dutiful drudge with three kids and a husband who’s just announced he’s bringing home a second wife. Or she could copy the “Cuties,” a quartet of brazen girls who wear tube tops [...]

  • Crip Camp

    'Crip Camp': Film Review

    If “Crip Camp” strikes you as a politically incorrect name for a movie about a summer camp where kids on crutches, in wheelchairs, and otherwise living with disabilities found it possible to feel included rather than ostracized, consider this: The irreverent, stereotype-busting documentary was co-directed by Berkeley-based sound designer Jim LeBrecht, a spina bifida survivor [...]

  • Summertime

    'Summertime': Film Review

    “Use your words.” I remember one of my sheroes saying that to a stammering 4-year-old decades ago. Here was a woman who’d dedicated her life to preschool education, whom I assisted for several summers, trying to get through to a tongue-tied little boy. The more he sputtered, the more upset he got, unable to express [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content