You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘The Rooftop’

Jay Chou, Li Xinai, Darren Chiu, Alan Ko, Devon Song, A-lang Huang, Eden Huang, Eric Tsang, Kenny Bee, Wang Xueqi, Xu Fan, Andrew Lau, John Chiang, Lin Nadow. (Mandarin dialogue)

After his wistful, lyrical directing debut, “Secret,” Mando-pop star Jay Chou makes a brash departure with “The Rooftop,” a raucous ‘70s action-musical about a group of slackers and their brawling, skirt-chasing escapades. Like a school pageant with a Broadway-sized budget, this noisy production is a pileup of extravagant dance numbers, candy-colored sets and vintage props that, sans the requisite heart or hip factor, soon overstays its welcome. Although the pic has secured releases in several Asian markets (as well as a Stateside run), it’s grossed only a middling $12.4 million so far in China and faces even more disappointing reactions in Chou’s native Taiwan.

Chou deserves credit for attempting a musical, not exactly a popular genre in Chinese cinema; perhaps the most contemporary example that comes to mind is 2005’s “Perhaps, Love.” But while the writer-director displayed considerable promise in “Secret,” “The Rooftop” feels more like a vanity project, enabling Chou to indulge in his love of fantasy and nostalgia (the vintage automobiles are a collector’s dream).

The setting is a fictional island called Galilee, and while computer-generated aerial shots suggest Mediterranean climes, the local architecture and ambience suggest Taiwan in the ’70s — specifically, a Taiwan served up for mainland consumption, where the night markets and rooftop communities feel strenuously, flamboyantly manufactured. Not a word of Taiwanese dialect has found its way into the dialogue, and the fact that the release title in China has been changed to “Tiantai aiqin” (Rooftop Love Affair), spelling out  a concept alien to mainlanders, suggests a schizophrenic attempt to cater to pan-Chinese audiences.

Wax (Chou) and his ne’er-do-well buddies Tempura (Alan Ko), A-lang (A-lang Huang) and Egg (Devon Song) live in makeshift dwellings on a rooftop. They help out at an herbal pharmacy run by Dr. Bo (Eric Tsang), but care far more about their coiffure than their careers (several gags here are developed around their rock-star-inspired hairstyles, and Wax’s nickname, Langzigao, is derived from a brand of hair gel). Tempura makes a few bucks on the side collecting “rent” for local don Rango (Wang Xueqi), a job he’s so good at that Rango’s most ruthless henchman, Big Red (Eden Huang), feels threatened.

Wax, who has been crushing on the star of a shampoo ad, meets her in person and gallantly rescues her from gang harassment (or so he thinks). She turns out to be Starling (mainland newcomer Li Xinai), an aspiring actress working to pay off gambling debts that her father (Kenny Bee) owes to her influential co-star, William (Darren Chiu). When William, who has designs on Starling, detects her growing attachment to Wax, he enlists Big Red’s help to teach Wax and his gang a lesson.

Befitting a pop star of his prolific output, Chou composed 11 song-and-dance numbers for “The Rooftop,” staged with classic Broadway musicals like “West Side Story” in mind. At their best, the sequences reflect a playfully warped sensibility, matching props and costumes to curious, colorful effect: A prime example is a scene set in Dr. Bo’s pharmacy, where nubile nurses gyrate with lustful men in wheelchairs. Other showstoppers stage sexy hijinks or stylized fights against bizarre backdrops, such as a bowling alley or a traditional bathhouse.

Too bad the most diverting acts are frontloaded in the first 30 minutes or so, after which the narrative and performances run out of steam. The elaborate dance routines are shunted aside in favor of sequences tailored for Chou to play the kung-fu hero, and the mood becomes more boisterous as the visuals grow less exciting. The director has set himself the difficult task of gleefully sending up movie cliches and developing those same cliches into serious drama, with Big Red and William morphing from cartoonish goons into demonic villains and Starling reduced to damsel in distress. The overblown plotting reaches a nadir with an out-of-place sequence that pretentiously references “Rebel Without a Cause.”

Chou doesn’t so much act here as reinforce the cocky-yet-gawky image his fans find so irresistible; always on the move and at the center of the drama, he remains the film’s most watchable figure and its sustaining force. By contrast, his attractive co-star, Li, seems unable to muster more than either a smile or a frown, and her dubbed, Taiwanese-accented dialogue sounds gratingly unnatural. Chou has better chemistry with veteran thesp Ko, band singer Song and his regular lyricist A-lang Huang; as his buddies in real life, they know how to coast along onscreen without upstaging him.

Despite his florid shirts and campy swagger, eminent mainland thesp Wang Xueqi makes an incongruous Taiwanese gangster with his proper Mandarin accent and northern demeanor. Mainland thesp Xu Fan also sticks out as a rooftop resident, lacking the right groove in the dance scenes. Shaw Brothers action superstar John Chiang pops up in an odd cameo.

Tech credits reflect the hefty budget of about $10 million, with lenser Mark Lee Ping-bin giving the images his usual depth and luster. Top Hong Kong costume designer Dora Ng whips up a riot of colors with groovy bandanas and cutesy polka-dotted skirts. But the biggest show stopper is Yoshihito Akatsuka’s production design, making the rooftop look like a magical fairground and turning a set as mundane as the pharmacy into a veritable dance hall.

Film Review: 'The Rooftop'

Reviewed at Ximending Showtime Cinema, Taipei, July 14, 2013. Running time: 122 MIN. Original title: "Tiantai"

Production: (Taiwan-China-Hong Kong) A Buena Vista Film (in Taiwan)/Edko Film (in Hong Kong)/Well Go USA Entertainment (in U.S.) release of an Evergrande Pictures, Talent Films, Chuang Ying Entertainment, Edko Film presentation of a Chuang Ying Pictures Entertainment production in association with Sun Entertainment Culture, Mojo Entertainment. (International sales: Ablaze Image, Taipei.) Produced by Wu Xuedan, Wu Hong-liang, Bill Kong, JR Ren. Executive producers, Jimmy Huang, Liu Keng-hung. Co-producers, Timothy Mou, Zhang Zhe, Esmond Ren.

Crew: Directed, written by Jay Chou, based on his story. Camera (color, widescreen), Mark Lee Ping-bin; editor, Wenders Li; music; Chou, Jason Huang; music supervisors, Chou, Josh Lo, Chavy Lee; production designer, Yoshihito Akatsuka; art directors, Makoto Asano, Li Miao; set decorators, Wang Ping-sen, Huang Wen-hsien, Chang Lu, Wang Shanshan; costume designer, Dora Ng; sound (Dolby Digital), Tu Duu-chi; re-recording mixers, Tu, Wu Shu-yao; dance choreographer, Michael Zhao, Snow Huang; special effects supervisor, Li Hsien-chun; visual effects supervisors, Sing Choong Foo, Cheung Ka-wah, Zhu Xiaobin, Wang Jing, Terry Zhang, Jason Zhang; visual effects, Beijing Crystal Film TV & Media Technologies Co., Beijing Orient Media Co., Magic Color; action directors, Yang Kil-yong, Seo Seung-eok; martial arts choreographers, Lee Cheol-woo, Shin Bum-sik; stunt coordinator, Gino Yang; line producers, Maxx Tsai, Yu Chang-hong; assistant director, Hao Fangwei; second unit director, Chen Tung-han; casting, Wu Chen-chen.

With: Jay Chou, Li Xinai, Darren Chiu, Alan Ko, Devon Song, A-lang Huang, Eden Huang, Eric Tsang, Kenny Bee, Wang Xueqi, Xu Fan, Andrew Lau, John Chiang, Lin Nadow. (Mandarin dialogue)

More Film

  • Nicolas Cage

    Film News Roundup: Nicolas Cage's 'Jiu Jitsu' Obtains Cyprus Support

    In today’s film news roundup, Cyprus is backing Nicolas Cage’s “Jiu Jitsu”; “The Nanny” and “Amityville 1974” are moving forward; “Milk” is returning to theaters; and Garrett Hedlund’s “Burden” is getting distribution. CYPRUS REBATE Nicolas Cage’s “Jiu Jitsu” has become the first international film to use Cyprus’ new tax credit-rebate program by filming entirely in [...]

  • Zhao Tao

    Zhao Tao Gets Candid in Kering's Shanghai Women in Motion Showcase Interview

    Zhao Tao is one of the most recognizable faces in Chinese art cinema thanks to her longtime collaboration with director Jia Zhangke, whom she married in 2012. From 2000’s “Platform” to last year’s “Ash is Purest White,” her work has plumbed the moral depths of modern China and brought stories of the country’s drastic change [...]

  • Skyline on the Huangpu River with

    Chinese-American Film Festival Seeks Particular Dialog

    With U.S.-China ties at an ever-sinking low, the Chinese-American Film and TV Festival on Tuesday pledged to improve communications between the two countries —  at a Chinese language-only press conference Tuesday that had few foreigners present. Most attendees who took to the stage to give congratulatory speeches that seemed more intent on heaping praise upon [...]

  • Murder Mystery

    Netflix Reveals Record-Breaking Stats for Sandler-Aniston 'Murder Mystery' Flick

    “Murder Mystery,” the latest Adam Sandler film to debut on Netflix, broke viewing records on the streaming service, the company revealed Tuesday. The film, which is co-headlined by Jennifer Aniston, was seen by close to 30.9 million households in its first 3 days, according to a tweet sent out Tuesday afternoon. 🚨ADAM SANDLER AND JENNIFER [...]

  • Agents Accuse Writers Guild of Refusing

    Writers Guild 'Plans to Respond' to Agents' Proposal as Frustration Mounts

    In a sign of increasing frustration, Hollywood agents have accused the Writers Guild of America of foot-dragging in the bitter two-month dispute. “It has become clear as more days pass that the Guild is not interested in making a deal,” said the negotiating committee for the agents in statement issued Tuesday. “Over the past year, [...]

  • Jermaine Fowler arrives at the 69th

    Jermaine Fowler to Co-Star With Eddie Murphy in 'Coming 2 America' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Jermaine Fowler is set to play one of the leads opposite Eddie Murphy in Paramount’s sequel “Coming 2 America,” sources tell Variety. “Hustle & Flow” helmer Craig Brewer is on board to direct the pic with the studio planning an August 7, 2020 release. Plot details of “Coming 2 America” are unknown, as are the [...]

  • Henry Golding attends the Fragrance Foundation

    Henry Golding Starts Long House Shingle With 'Inheritance,' 'Harrington's Greatest Hits'

    “Crazy Rich Asians” star Henry Golding has started Long House Productions in partnership with China’s Starlight Cultural Entertainment Group with two features in the works. Golding’s first feature under the Long House banner is action adventure “The Inheritance,” based on an original story idea by Alistair Hudson and Golding. Hudson is writing the script for [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content