×

Venice Film Review: ‘A Promise’

Alan Rickman, Rebecca Hall and Richard Madden star in this awkward, passionless period drama from Patrice Leconte.

With:

Rebecca Hall, Alan Rickman, Richard Madden, Toby Murray, Maggie Steed, Shannon Tarbet. (English dialogue)

A French director working with British actors and pre-WWI German setting could theoretically make a film that rises above Europudding mediocrity, but that potential goes unrealized by “A Promise,” Patrice Leconte’s unpromising first foray into English-language filmmaking. Led by a trio of lackluster performances from Alan Rickman, Rebecca Hall and “Game of Thrones” thesp Richard Madden, this awkward, passionless drama conveys neither the sensuality nor the drawn-out sense of longing required by its period tale of a young secretary who falls in love with his employer’s wife. The French-Belgian co-production will rely on high regard for Leconte’s past work to drum up arthouse interest offshore.

Adapted by Leconte and Jerome Tonnerre (who also co-wrote the director’s “My Best Friend” and “Intimate Strangers”) from Stefan Zweig’s posthumously published novel “Journey Into the Past,” the story begins in 1912 Germany, a time and place of rapid industrial change as quickly suggested by an opening-credits montage of clanging metal and fiery furnaces. Wealthy steel-factory owner Karl Hoffmeister (Rickman) needs an assistant and hires Frederic Zeitz (Madden), a young man of modest background but considerable intelligence and work ethic who quickly becomes indispensable to Karl, who is not in the best of health.

The emotional temperature mildly escalates when Frederic meets Karl’s beautiful and much younger wife, Lotte (Hall), and begins tutoring their young son, Otto (Toby Murray), with whom he bonds immediately. With Frederic soon spending almost all his time with the Hoffmeisters, it soon makes sense for the secretary to leave his lowly digs and take up residence in their well-appointed bourgeois home. Scowling from the sidelines is Frederic’s sometime lover (Shannon Tarbet), with whom he has one vigorous, if almost comically brief, final fling before moving on to a better life.

What sounds like an instant recipe for domestic disaster actually takes its sweet time, as Frederic and Lotte scrupulously avoid expressing feelings that are quite obvious to the audience, if not necessarily to themselves at first. He catches and disposes of a rat that frightens her in the drawing room; she transfixes him by playing the second movement of Beethoven’s Sonata Pathetique over and over and over again on the piano, its adagio tempo setting such a languid, monotonous rhythm that audiences may be tempted to start shouting musical requests at the screen.

There are occasional whispers in the direction of steamy/risible melodrama, as when Frederic, attempting to catch a lingering waft of Lotte’s fragrance (Repression for Women?), practically tickles the ivories with his nose. But for the most part, the key figures in this tastefully buttoned-up drama (the buttons and other early-1900s accouterments are supplied by costume designer Pascaline Chavanne) behave with a noble but dramatically lethal combo of loyalty and pride, so that by the time the outside world intervenes — a sudden business opportunity for Frederic in Mexico, the inconveniently timed outbreak of WWI — they have little to sustain their love beyond a vague promise to reunite when the war is over.

In keeping up corseted appearances, the film is clearly aiming for a meticulous slow-burn effect that is ill served by its wobbly command of mise-en-scene. While Ivan Maussion’s spare production design serviceably suggests a Teutonic background (the film was shot in Belgium), the bland, unburnished lighting and the cheap, digital-looking quality of the images (shot by the typically aces Eduardo Serra) have a dampening effect on the film’s attempts to build either a persuasive sense of historical reality or an erotically charged atmosphere.

Of the central trio, Rickman perhaps comes off best in a less prickly, more tender register than he has occupied of late. The usually appealing Hall somehow doesn’t look quite right in this particular context, and she seems at once too tall and too vivacious to be a desirable physical or emotional match for the wooden Madden. A dab hand at period entertainments (“The Widow of Saint-Pierre,” “Ridicule”), Leconte keeps things moving at a brisk enough pace to bring “A Promise” in at 98 minutes, with the effect that one of the story’s key themes — the long, agonizing passage of time — barely even seems to register. A long-distance letter-writing montage near the end is stacked with lines like “It is for our love that I am in mourning,” delivered with altogether less passion or interest than Karl and Frederic’s early conversations about metallurgical chemistry.

Popular on Variety

Venice Film Review: 'A Promise'

Reviewed at Venice Film Festival (noncompeting), Sept. 4, 2013. (Also in Toronto Film Festival — Special Presentations.) Running time: 98 MIN. Original title: "Une promesse"

Production:

(France-Belgium) A Fidelite production, in association with Wild Bunch, in co-production with Scope Pictures, with the participation of OCS, Wallonie. (International sales: Wild Bunch, Paris.) Produced by Olivier Delbosc, Marc Missionnier. Executive producer, Christine de Jekel.

Crew:

Directed by Patrice Leconte. Screenplay, Jerome Tonnerre, Leconte, based on the novel "Journey Into the Past" by Stefan Zweig. Camera (color, widescreen, HD), Eduardo Serra; editor, Joelle Hache; music, Gabriel Yared; production designer, Ivan Maussion; costume designer, Pascaline Chavanne; sound, Paul Laine; re-recording mixer, Thomas Gauder; casting, Sussie Figgis.

With:

Rebecca Hall, Alan Rickman, Richard Madden, Toby Murray, Maggie Steed, Shannon Tarbet. (English dialogue)

More Film

  • Editorial use only. No book cover

    'Hocus Pocus' Sequel in Development at Disney Plus

    Disney Plus has launched development of a sequel to 1993’s fantasy comedy “Hocus Pocus” with “Workaholics” writer and co-producer Jen D’Angelo on board to script. The original “Hocus Pocus” starred Bette Midler, Sarah Jessica Parker, and Kathy Najimy as a trio of witch sisters who have been cursed since 1693 in Salem, Ma. The witches [...]

  • Lady Gaga

    Variety Wins 2019 Eppy Award for Best Digital Magazine

    Variety has won two Eppy Awards from Editor & Publisher, including Best Digital Magazine and Best Collaborative Investigative/Enterprise Feature for “American (In)Justice” — a collaboration with fellow PMC property Rolling Stone. “American (In)Justice” also tied with USA Today’s “Copy, Paste, Legislate” collaboration with The Arizona Republic and the Center for Public Integrity. Variety has provided [...]

  • Joker Maleficent: Mistress of Evil

    Box Office: Villains Face Off Again as 'Joker' and 'Maleficent' Battle for First Place

    Despite three new nationwide releases, domestic box office charts look to be dominated by holdovers — Warner Bros.’ “Joker” and Disney’s “Maleficent: Mistress of Evil” — during the last weekend in October. “Maleficent: Mistress of Evil” debuted last weekend with $36 million in North America, enough to dethrone “Joker” after the super-villain origin story’s back-to-back [...]

  • Yasushi Shiina

    Tokyo Market is Finding New Strengths, Says Yasushi Shiina

    Clouds on the global economic horizon and disruption to the scheduling of the event, have done little to dampen the interest of foreign visitors to TIFFCOM, Japan’s biggest film and TV market. Especially those from China, says market head, Yasushi Shiina. The market is again running at the Sunshine City shopping, entertainment and business complex [...]

  • "Weathering With You" directed by Makoto

    Toho Unveils Dual Media Romance 'Love Me, Love Me Not' at Tokyo Market

    Japan’s biggest film company, which produces, distributes and exhibits its own product in partnership with leading media companies, Toho has brought a line-up to TIFFCOM full of present and future hits. The biggest is “Weathering with You,” the love story animation by Makoto Shinkai that surpassed the $100 million mark only a month after its [...]

  • Hit Me Anyone One More Time

    TIFFCOM: Pony Canyon Saddles up FujiTV's Smash 'Hit Me Anyone'

    One of Japan’s five major broadcast networks, Fuji TV has also been a pioneer and leader among the networks in feature film production. This year at TIFFCOM long-time partner Pony Canyon is representing Fuji TV films that have recently hit number one at the Japanese box office. Among the hottest, with three straight weeks atop [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content